Software
Houzz Logo Print
larsi_gw

People blaming Front loaders on their problems

10 years ago

Good Morning. I was chatting with one of my fav Laundry Room members early today, and we were both laughing about how many people blame all their laundry problems on their washing machine, mainly their front loader.

Besides Speed Queen, a front load washer will clean better day after day, year after year compared to a top loader.

So many people blame their front load washer, and then will be like:

I will only use liquid detergents and wash in cold water.

I will only use Charlie's Soap, Soap Nuts, 7th Generation, Ecos, etc, etc..

I always leave the door closed on the washer.

I add a little bit of my Astrology sign to the fabric softener reservoir, because this is what my Life Coach told me to do.

LOL. So for those who think we are cray, cray about our HOT water washes and using real detergents (mainly powders).... PLEASE do not keep blaming your washing machine. The problem is the operator!!!

Comments (79)

  • 10 years ago

    Doesn't Tonnage mean boatload? I do buy an excessive amount of detergents and I do like my phosphates..I'm just trying to figure out what thst has to do with someone washing in cold water, not cool or tepid but cold..how are all these related?

  • 10 years ago

    I'm happy to spend a little extra doing hot washes and using the hot water. Everyone spends money in different ways.

    As for turning up the water heater that's not a good idea at all. 125 F is the recommended and that's plenty warm. Over that there's a danger of scalding.

    larsi_gw thanked rococogurl
  • 10 years ago

    Turning up the water heater isn't assured to have an impact on the temperature of the water IN the washing machine. Machines nowadays with "dumbed-down" temperature control will just add more cold water to the hot to attain the target 70°F or 75°F "warm" temp ... or 95°F to 105°F "hot" temp.

    Not to mention, it's MUCH more efficient to have a machine with onboard water heating and heat 5 gallons IN the machine than turn up a 40- or 50-gallon whole-house water heater.

    larsi_gw thanked dadoes
  • 10 years ago

    If cold washing is OK and saves energy why not just turn the heater off and take cold showers (your body can handle it), wash your dishes in cold, hands in cold, etc? As others have said, I've already got the water why not use it? The costs are minuscule, the results are real, and it just makes sense. Like all "energy savings", the claims are wildly over stated.

    As far as phosphates in detergents using algae blooms. As others said, they can be removed in the wastewater for those on municipal systems. Septic systems it will make your grass grow better. The real culprit is industrial and farm use. Heard on the radio that in my state, PA which discharges a lot into the Chesapeake that after 6 years of the phosphate ban (started in 2010), the Chesapeake still has higher than normal levels and farmers and industrial users are next up. So home use is miniscule.

    It's all education. Our TL's sucked at cleaning, sucked at clothing care and wasted resources. Been a FL user since 2004 and have had longer lasting cleaner clothes than any TL can dream of.

    larsi_gw thanked itguy08
  • 10 years ago

    I've had a Bosch 3200 FL since 2006 & never had one problem with it cleaning! Before I had a decent Maytag TL, but since my water heater is set at 120, I never had a truly hot wash. I have always used powdered tide in my FL & am still using boxes I bought for 1/2 price 5 years ago. Been using Walmart Persil perls for whites & now using Cheer HE for colors. My washer is almost 10 years old & I am getting very nervous about the day when it needs to be replaced. The onboard heater is amazing & I have to find one that works the same, which sounds like next to impossible these days from what you all say. I have found that my Bosch FL definitely rinses better than my old Maytag. My DS#1 always got a rash if I didn't use "Free" detergent, but I can use anything in this one & the fragrance is barely noticeable after rinsing & no rash. I do mostly warm washes with at least one sanitary wash per week & at least one hot load. I just have to keep reading here to plot my replacement, which I hope is still a few years away!

    larsi_gw thanked Cadyren
  • 10 years ago

    I'm with you Cindy . I also have been thinking I need to know what is out there now in case my 7 year old Bosch Nexxtplus bites the dust. It seems I might have a hard time finding a machine (unless I spend megabucks) that will duplicate the temps on this machine.

    I run my loads on hot or warm, never cold unless it is in one of the programmed cycles like wool or delicate or jeans.

    I do one or two sani cycles a week. I have a real thing about getting rid of that body oil smell in clothes and sheets there is no way a cold cycle is going to do that.

    larsi_gw thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    Grapeleaves, I hope your Bosch lasts you many more years, really is not good when a loyal appliance needs replaced in these modern times.

    As for washing sheets in cold water, I'm surprised the amount of people that do this and think their sheets are clean, but I suppose since body oils are invisable until they build up a bit some people don't see it so its clean...give me hot lol

  • 10 years ago

    I think it may be fine to use COLD occasionally as long as your machine is providing and maintaining 85 degree water. It shouldn't matter if there's a blizzard outside, your machine should still deliver and maintain the water temperature at 85 degrees. My Miele has no problem doing that. In fact, my Miele has a NO HEAT setting (tap cold) in addition to a COLD (85ºF) setting.

  • 10 years ago

    ... after washing only on cold FOREVER (20+ years), I started washing on warm and sometimes hot after reading more about it here a month or two ago. Maybe I'll make it all the way up to hot for all my washes! I just struggle to go against the label instructions, LOL.

  • 10 years ago

    I suppose if you shower before bed and wear pajamas, your sheets probably don't get all that dirty in the first place.

    MRB

  • 10 years ago

    Manual in my Bosch says cold is 60 degrees.

  • 10 years ago

    Grapeleaves, when a garment label says COLD that means a temperature of up to 85ºF. I would recommend using a different setting that provides water closest in temperature to 85ºF. That will reflect the temperature recommended on the garment label.

  • 10 years ago

    I never use cold. 85 degrees is closer to my warm (90) according to my manual.

    Warm is the coolest water I use. I mostly use hot and use kids care or temp boost (160) quite often.

  • 10 years ago

    @Cindy.. I'm curious, would you mind posting some pictures of those boxes? :)

  • 10 years ago

    Most of the detergents sold in our stores any more are pods or liquid. The boxes of dry detergent are the huge size of Sun or Arm & Hammer and are usually located on the bottom shelf. The other granulars, like Perls, are sold in the same plastic jug as the liquids. Costco and Sam's sell dry detergent but again, huge sizes that I can't wrangle into a grocery cart without pinching a nerve. I have an RO system so no issues with hard water. My washer has cold, cool, warm, hot and sanitizing/steam cycles. What did we wash with in cold water before liquids became so common? I remember using Wisk and Woolite. Were those the only two?

  • 10 years ago

    Powder will dissolve in Cold Water. And I mean, really, really Cold Water. It just takes some agitation, and clothes moving around to do so.

  • 10 years ago

    Moroseaz, your right powders are hard to find and small and medium sizes even harder. I just bought the big 102 load box of Tide Mountain Spring scent that I love because its brisk and herbal smelling and I have a TL and a large family so I'll use it but what about others that have a FL and small families..I always thought powders should come in smaller boxes also and they should be on the shelves.

    I have to say your cold must be my warm.. I don't know what was used for cold water in the past but even liquid detergent has to desolve and activate and water too cold won't let that happen. Right now my cold tap is in the low 40's .

    I think era came out in the 70's..with the logo being Protein gets out protein.. but I can't think right off the top of my head lol. Its he!! getting old LOL.



  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    @mamapinky0.. Powders do come in smaller boxes. You can buy a 22, 30, 32, 40 , 52 , 64, 78, 80 , 120 & 180 load box of Tide depending on what Retailer your shopping at. The problem is.. retailers have slowly eliminated VERY limited shelf space for powders to make room for new detergent formats & variations like Liquids & Pods.

    Don't blame Procter & Gamble, or Sun Products, or even Church & Dwight. They simply aren't receiving orders for their Powder Products to be placed on store shelves. Honestly.. in a lot of Places, Wal-Mart is the only "leading" retailer offering a decent powder selection.

    Very Sad.

  • 10 years ago

    Sorry, but I'm here to disagree with whomever thinks that clothes get cleaner in a front load washer than in a top-loader. Save your breath. Or your typing.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Well sir, I have the proof in the nasty stuff I've run through my FL that comes out clean. Including white steam mop pads that go in black and come out a very light shade of gray, almost new. Or stained kitchen cloths that stunk, sat for a month or 2 and came out smelling clean. Or even a pot holder mitt that I used for smoking meats that was nasty greasy and came out almost new. Or the cloths I use to detail my cars that have wax, brake dust, dirt and oil that come out new time and time again.

    No TL I've ever used could get results like that.

    larsi_gw thanked itguy08
  • 10 years ago

    itguy, I have to agree. This little Asko runs circles around any TL I have ever owned and I have owned a lot!


    larsi_gw thanked Donna-37
  • 10 years ago

    I seen it comming...The great debate. Personally I think you can get great results with a FL or a TL it all depends on the user. I've never had a FL but I've read tons of posts...I know there are people in this forum that would never tolorate less than absolutly clean and sweet smelling clothes, some use a FL and some a TL. Now someone may say Pinky how do you know your TL'er gets your clothes as clean as possible if you've never used a FL'er...but I know. I'm one of those people I was talking about that wont tolorate anything less than perfection in the laundry room. Are my whites brilliant and my blacks black because I use a Speed Queen..no...they are this way due to many different things...my machine, water chem, water temp, detergent choice, booster/additives, invested time, ...if I suddenly was presented a FL'er would I still have brilliant whites..no, not at first, but after I learn to use it and apply my other knowelage along with it, yes I would, just like the other FL users here that have brilliant whites. I chose a TL because that's what I'm comfortable with and I wasn't ready to change and learn a new way, not because I think clothes would be less clean. I think its ridiculous for otherwise intelligent adults to banter back and forth that my washers better than yours or my clothes are cleaner than yours or a FL or TL cleans better..hog wash...its all in the users hands unless you happen to have a broken machine. All of my TL washers have cleaned as well as everyone that uses a FL and gets excellent results. .becsuse like you I apply all of my other knowelage along with my washer.

  • 10 years ago

    I don't own any clothing that can be washed on hot. Maybe towels, if I'm happy with the fading eventually, and dishcloths/towels (which I normally do on sanitize) and usually undies just because I think they should be washed on hot even if it destroys the sexy fabric pairs. I washed a coloured regular load on warm on my new machine since that was the default for the normal load so I thought I'd try it, and clothing that has been washed for years already on cold, ran, and so items with white in combo with the colours got discoloured. Grrrr. Not to mention the fabrics with rayon and such that hot water shrinks even if it doesn't enter the dryer.

    Anyway, we have tons of dance wear, yoga wear, all sorts of fabrics and dark colours that hot water just won't work. I have no idea if a top loader worked better as any top loaders I have used have been when I rented so they were commercial machines. I've owned front loaders since I've owned my own home, for 14 years. But I still won't use hot to make my clothing cleaner as I destroy it in the process. Cold seems to do a decent job on my clothing, although both of my last front loader sets have heaters which heat the cold to a proper temp and don't use tap cold unless requested.

  • 10 years ago

    What temp is your warm that it could ruin anything?

  • 10 years ago

    Blue..do you wash sheets on cold?...I can't understand why warm would make clothes that were washed for years run..does a temp of 120 deg f also ruin your clothes?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    No idea what the temp is, new machine and of course the manual doesn't say the temps. These are items that have never, ever been washed on anything but cold. They were mostly the kids undies that got it, and my youngest has been in undies since 16 months, is recently 4 and the undies still fit her, so that is how long they have been washed in cold, 2.5 years? Wondering now if I did all the undies together in a hot load...maybe that is what I did. And the bright yellows and greens and white waist bands had the dark navy's bleed on them...usually I mix their undies in with the same coloured clothing but since I do adult undies on their own in hotter temps, I figured I should be doing the same for the kids so I may have done an exclusive undie load on hot. Still scared to try warm on darks and bright colours!

    I don't know what 120 means, would have to go convert to celsius. lol But, sheets I don't wash on cold, I wash them on warm. Would like to use hot or even sanitize, but we have bright coloured patterns and even warm has faded them (with my Electrolux wave touch 70). I haven't yet washed sheets in my new machine. That will be this weekend's experiment.

  • 10 years ago

    I don't know I'd 100% blame warm water for fading issues. Could be the fabric, the dye, the detergent, etc.

    We usually wash on warm for everything.

    I've got some polo type shirts that are "faded" at the seams and such that are probably 7 years old now. Other T-shitrs are about as old and as dark as the day they were bought. They all are usually done together so get the same water treatment, detergent, etc. I think it's a combination of the fabric, dye, and detergent that works to fade rather than strictly water temp.

    We just got a new sheet set for the bed and it's navy. Washed it according to the directions - warm. Even with Woolite Dark detergent the amount of blue dye in the wash water was crazy. Will be interesting to see how this one does as I do all bed stuff in sanitize as our dog sleeps in the bed with us. Other deep red bed sheets still look good after years of this treatment.

    Enjoy your new machines!

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    If you have city water you can also blame that as the chlorine in it will cause fading over time.

  • 10 years ago

    I think a lot of cold water users must live in warmer climates. My tap cold is frigid. I couldn't bear to put my hands in it.

    I have a laser temperature reader. Playing with it yesterday, the cold fill temp in my Asko was 50. That's too cold for any detergent to work. As the incoming water was so cold, my LG's warm cycle was 65, hot 85 before heater kicked in. I couldn't heat shrink anything if I tried. Lol.

    larsi_gw thanked sandy1616
  • 10 years ago
    We have a whole house filter, so no chlorine. I just don't think clothing is made like it used to be. If I look at labels, most everything expects cold and many things also says a gentle wash. That doesn't include all of our hand wash items.
  • 10 years ago

    My laser thermometer has told me LG's 'warm' is 85-90 degrees.. usually the first load is around 85 and if i do another right after it's usually 90. 'Hot' is only about 105. There is an 'extra hot' but the machine won't let me open the door to get a reading. I rarely if ever use cold. And I'm tempted to use 'hot' more..but I don't have any issue with clothes not getting clean.

    I'm curious about the chlorine.. I know sodium percarbonate reacts with chlorine bleach, would a little neutralize it? Also, in the beer brewing world, we can use 'campden' tablets, or potassium metabisulfite to remove chlorine and chloramines in city water..I wonder if it's laundry compatible..it takes a very small amount to do it's work. It also sterilizes..hmmmm


  • 10 years ago

    Modern FL machines use so little water in the wash portion of the cycle that you are saving very little if anything by washing in cold water all the time.

  • 10 years ago

    Sspeer, sodium percarbonate will neutralize chlorine bleach. If you use LCB to sanitize clothes, leave the sodium percarb out.

    Just for kicks, one time I mixed some LCB with peroxide and it bubbled and fizzed up a lot.

  • 10 years ago

    tideman_59, I don't wash in cold to save money. I wash in cold because 90% or more of the clothing I own says 30C wash on the label and a good chunk of the laundry is also labelled to wash on gentle cycle. We have lots of delicate fabrics and fabrics that aren't just cotton (combos with rayon and such), and if the clothing item was expensive enough, I'd rather not test hotter water on it and risk wrecking it, so I follow the label on the majority of items.

  • 10 years ago

    Not judging but if anything needs hot water it's kids undies, for me if they are gonna shrink (they don't) than so be it but cold or cool water will not clean undies even if they look clean. Ecoil lurks in undies. That doesn't mean they need boiled but a long hot wash is required.

  • 10 years ago

    Yes, I agree on undies in general. I used to do the little kid's with their regular clothing but moved to a separate kid's undies load now. And I already have a separate load I do for my teenager's undies, and then a separate load for our undies.

  • 10 years ago

    Is there a reason the undies all get done seperatly? Your all living under the same roof lol

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    No, no reason other than my own persnicketiness that they must be done separately.

    I also do our socks with the undies, and my teenager and I have a bunch that are the same socks. Keeping them separate makes the sock separation easier. Also makes undie sorting easier as I can toss all her clean undies/socks into a laundry basket and hand it to her and say "here" and if she uses them out of the basket, fine, if she puts them away, fine. And then I can bring a basket up to our room that is just our stuff. We often live out of the undies/socks basket for a few days before either of us get around to putting them away. Same with the little kids. (parents room top floor, little kids main floor and oldest has basement room so we can't live out of the same basket easily ;))

  • 10 years ago

    This is a VERY interesting thread, lots of different opinions and advice. :)

  • 10 years ago

    Just to say .... if the reason for separate underwear loads is to prevent cross-contamination between them and regular clothing ... there will be "live" fecal matter and other germs left in the machine and shared between loads unless chlorine bleach is used or the machine is sanitized accordingly between an underwear load to the next.

  • 10 years ago

    Dadoes, you've given me a great visual. .I'm running with the chlorox lol

  • 10 years ago

    20/20 did a segment on this a few years back. They swabbed a machine and there was millions of contaminants. Looking at the machine, it seemed perfect.

    DaDoes you might have seen the same thing? I have also read articles that tells the same thing as 20/20. Glad you brought that up.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    dadoes, no, for me it's because I wash underwear on hot and my regular clothing does not get washed on hot. So, mine are separate because I use different cycles/temps.

  • 10 years ago

    Until recently I was using a Miele that had Sanitize, Hot, cold and NO HEAT. Of course its instructions were not written for humans but with research I discovered that it does heat cold to 85F, and hot to 105F. However the beast suffered a terminal failure (the spider on the tub broke -$1500 for the parts) so out it went and a new Electrolux came in. The Electrolux has similar settings but no indication whatsoever in the manual as to what the actual temperatures are. On the Miele a tablespoon of detergent was all that was needed usually and I got excellent results. Really sad to see it go. The Electrolux (EIFLS60JIW) is clearly not made to the same standards but seems well made anyway. The drum is larger. I don't know yet if its as efficient on detergent as the Miele was. I don't know if the steam cycle has any antbacterial properties which would be nice. I believe the detergent does have some antibaterial properties

  • 10 years ago

    @Laundry Mitch...I guess you mean a picture of the 5 year old Tide box?? I bought 8 boxes of the 68 load size back when they downsized & made it more concentrated. I'm on my last box & will get a picture tomorrow.

  • 10 years ago

    Yes, Cindy Noll.. that'd be great :) I do have to sadly inform you though.. your in for a awful surprise the next time you buy a box of Tide Detergent. P&G has modified the Original Scent significantly to appeal to "new" consumers wanting strong scents.


  • 10 years ago

    1audio, sorry to hear about your Miele. What model was it?


    105F sounds low for hot temperature on a Miele. On my W4840 it's 140F.

  • 10 years ago

    I switched back to Tide after using another detergent for awhile and when I ran my first load with it, I thought, "WTH? Dang, that stinks!".

    Ugh- bought 2 huge bottles of it at Costco. Needless to say I'm using the minimum per load.

  • 10 years ago

    Cindy, if you look around in pharmacys like Rite-aid you may find some of the older boxes of Tide. I'd check stores that don't sell a lot of laundry supplies. Or if you have a Ollies discount.

  • 10 years ago


    suburbanmd - That temp was a typo. Its the same model as yours. I was really sorry to see it go. The part that broke has a lifetime warranty from Electrolux. Miele also has an extended warranty on those parts in other markets, just not the US.