Software
Houzz Logo Print
bbxrider

tub vs jacuzzi tub

remodeling my master bath, its very small for a master 5x10, I am definitely of opinion to put in a tub, the other common bath with a tub, IMHO just would not work if the lady (or gentleman) of the house just wanted a nice soothing bath, in a nice bathroom, in a nice tub, with privacy, with a angle back to lean up against, etc etc. so... I I don't have the room to put in shower in addition to the tub. my dilima is to put in a nice tub, deeper style for soaking OR a jacuzzi tub. problem with the jacuzzi tubs they tend to be like a 19"+ height which seems quite a hurdle to step into with out some sort of platform or step, which I don't really have the floorspace for. any opinions about the high height to have to step 'over' to get into tub/shower combo which is going to be an everyday event?

Comments (11)

  • 10 years ago

    Shower only. No tub. All you need is a hall bath with a tub.

    Remodel and Construction Services thanked User
  • 10 years ago
    Remodel for yourself, but having a tub in the master bath is still a good idea. Whirlpool tubs sound nice, but really how many times are you going to sit there and fill the tub all the way up to turn on the jets?
    I would get a longer or bigger tub with the shower in it as well, or skip a tub altogether and do a very large shower with two heads and a nice bench to sit on, under the water.
    Good luck with your decision
    Remodel and Construction Services thanked sunnydrew
  • 10 years ago

    Kohler offers low-profile tubs.

    KOHLER K-1124-G-0 Archer 6' BubbleMassage Bath with Comfort Depth Design · More Info

    The Archer BubbleMassage bath features Comfort Depth design, a deep soaking experience with a low step-over height.




    Remodel and Construction Services thanked Jillian - Interior design student
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    The trouble is that most of the pretty soaker tubs are not designed for tub shower use. You need an alcove tub with an integral tile flange if you need it to pull dual duty. More people would rather shower than use a tub, so designing the bath fro that gets the maximum return on utility for the expenditure.

    Remodel and Construction Services thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    Agree with maria regarding jacuzzi type tubs. A soaker tub takes less water to fill, stay hot longer (don't forget to insulate whatever you get), takes up less space and is easier to clean.

    Remodel and Construction Services thanked Jillian - Interior design student
  • 10 years ago

    Totally agree with mariadgs. If I was house hunting, a jetted tub would be a big negative. But a soaker tub would be great as long as the water heater is big enough to actually fill the tub with hot water.

    Remodel and Construction Services thanked User
  • 10 years ago
    Alternative to jacuzzi and soaker is bubble jet, check out what Bain Ultra has to offer (they invented the technology) but Kohler and others make bubble jet also. Bubble jet tubs don't offer the concentrated force of jacuzzi jets, but they also don't attract mold nor have the cleaning issues. Sophie is right you will need to find a tub that can successfully double as shower; best if you visit a plumbing supply store and discuss options with professionals. Good luck!
    Remodel and Construction Services thanked susanalanandwrigley
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    thanks everybody for your input, I've got over the jacuzzi tub idea, just too small a bath, so.... I'm putting in a 'real' jacuzzi in the back yard. still struggling with tub vs no tub, although I would think it should be easy now with the backyard jacuzzi. I'm going to get input from 2 local realtors and an interior designer. there's at least one interesting curved apron tub with matching curved sliding doors, see pic. it has an appealing utility, however an open shower only with floor to ceiling tile and floor to ceiling glass is really awesome, see sample pic. my size is limited to 32x60, so maybe a small seat in the center, not a full bench like the pic, I would think aiming both shower heads while sitting on a seat competes with a tub soak, :-) my thinking is the openess of the shower only with the extra room for not having the tub walls will add a dimension to the other wise small bath size, whew

  • 10 years ago
    When we redid our bath, we chose the Kohler Archer tub, to use up about the same footprint we had, but narrower width. We then created the larger shower. The result was great.
  • 8 years ago
    Sunnydrew

    Could you share the dimensions of your bathroom?how big are the tub and shower?