you have so much wood in the room I would find a set with some color that would complement the wood. like dusty blue or light sage green what ever works with the cabinet and floor tones. the table top could be wood color if that would help pull it together, or maybe a black set to match your frig and stove. good luck

Thank u for the comments... If I didn't have middle schoolers I would consider the glass option.
These choices seem reasonable? Or not right? Looking for counter height

You definitely have enough wood in the room. Go for a black set.

???

We all seem to be giving you the feedback that there is too much wood going on.

As an aside, have you considered switching out your island counter top to a slab of black honed granite? (not glossy) Also, I would try and stain the floors to a much darker color brown.

Then you could get a wood table.

OR - I will post another option to help break up all the wood......

http://www.jenniferfurniture.com/category/dining-room/maysville-square-counter-height-5-piece-dining-set.html

http://www.jenniferfurniture.com/category/dining-room/theo-5-piece-counter-height-dining-set.html

I get that you do t want to buy stock in wonder for the glass top so how about going black ground table with upholstered parsons (or other chairs) in a bright color/pattern of your choosing? It would give you a pop of color and break up all the wood. Perhaps a coordinating are rug??

That was "stock in Windex" lol