Software
Houzz Logo Print
upperbaygardener

mystery about a dead silver maple

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

There was a huge maple in my yard until late last summer, which it collapsed from a rotten trunk. But, before this, other than a much smaller fork off the trunk falling (had happened 2 years earlier) and Hurricane Irene bringing down a major limb, it had seemed healthy. The crown was full and turned a nice clear yellow in the fall. Very vivid. It wasn't in my long term plan to keep the tree, but it shaded my main rhodie bed. (luckily, there's another maple, probably an Acer rubrum, still providing most of the shade for it...on that front, there was probably a little too much shade in the area and I would have gotten rid of the silver maple soon anyhow)

Here's the odd thing. I must have removed almost 10 junk maples on my property by now. Various sizes up to huge - 30"+ diameter trunk - it was also rotted out. In all cases, they vigorously resprouted. Even ones shaded by other maples that were struggling. This tree had a big corner of the yard to itself; yes the inside was rotting but there were no signs of the crown being sick. Well, I figured it might wait until this spring to send up some suckers or trunk sprouts. (my tree guy left a 2' tall stump, I didn't have it ground) Nothing. Nada. Zilch. The "outer ring" of the trunk at that point was still very thick, the rotted out core only about 12" wide and then 8-12" of still solid wood. But picking around along the bark layer shows that it is seemingly very dead.

Is it possible the tree was actually on the verge of death and somehow keeping a full crown? Or could the trauma of the trunk collapsing just killed the root system? The fact it didn't resprout just makes me wonder if you can always "judge the tree health book by the cover" so to speak. A possibility I just thought of is that the heavy rains of June mostly killed the root system, and the tree was just ambling along on "life support" - maybe the collapse was because of this, somehow. But again, it definitely had a full crown of healthy leaves when it fell.

Comments (6)

  • 10 years ago

    I could show you a several-thousand acre swamp right near to where I write this consisting largely of very huge silver maples. They are extremely tolerant to moisture. On the other hand, silver maple is a known poor compartmentalizer. So what kind of "rotted out" are we talking here? A hollow trunk? That's par for the course! My giant had several areas of extensive decay buried deep inside the enormous trunk. And where storms had taken limbs off were some nice developing breaches of Wall 1, to use the Shigo system. BTW, I drove through that swamp about a week ago. It is the headwaters for Duck Creek, which runs into Green Bay just above the city of that name. These trees were in standing water everywhere one cared to look. Likewise at my son's where we planted trees this weekend. He's got lots of green ash in the floodplain forest he owns there but there are some big silvers too, which is utterly commonplace up here. I'm having a hard time picturing one just rotting for the hell of it.

    Now if you're talking about a hollowed-out trunk, via the breaching of Wall 1, as described above-sure, a hollow tree like that can be perfectly healthy and stand that way for a long time.

  • 10 years ago

    There's a large silver maple on the sunny edge of a forest clearing on my brother's lot that is severely declining for some reason -- no significant branch loss or rot visible. Maybe just attribute it to the species' short life, but I see much bigger and older silver maples all the time.

  • 10 years ago

    Good point though-these are not long livers.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    SORRY! spoke too soon. I think they might have just appeared after the paltry amount of rain we had a couple days ago, but finally there are some tiny trunk sprouts. However other, smaller, maple and ash weeds I cut down last year are already vigorously growing. Maybe it just took longer to reactivate buds deep in the trunk. They are sprouting over a foot down from the edge left by the chainsaw, so I was right to note that the cambium is dead up there.

    Anyhow they are easy to deal with at this point. I always let whatever wants to grow out, grow out. In late summer, give one spray of glyphosate. It will finish it off every time, I've never had a spray a maple twice. Sometimes the shouts are 5' high at that point.

  • 10 years ago

    Other things are sprouting overnight, like a Lespedeza. I guess I hadn't realized how dry it was.

Sponsored
Kuhns Contracting, Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Central Ohio's Trusted Home Remodeler Specializing in Kitchens & Baths