Software
Houzz Logo Print
kag426

Knob and Tube

10 years ago

Hello all,

Sorry if this has been posted before. I've gone through the old posts and do not see my exact question so hoping this is not a duplicate post.


I am currently having some work done on the exterior of my 1920 American Foursquare...The front portico is gettining a facelift with new brick steps and columns...me, in my infinite wisdom, asked the contractor to open up the ceiling of the portico and raise the height so I can fit a new light fixture in there. Well, he opened it up today and informed me the old light is still on knob and tube wiring.

This was a surprise to me as there is no visual evidence of active knob and tube wiring in the basement or attic. There is one old porcelain knob in the attic without any wire connected so I knew it was there at one time. I had my fuses updated to a nice new 400 amp CB box when I bought the house two years ago and there was no indication that knob and tube was still in play. My question is this...

How can I tell if there is knob and tube still active in the walls in the rest of the house, without tearing up the plaster walls to look inside? Is there a way to tell by the outlets whether the electrical feeding into them are knob and tube?


Thanks in advance

Comments (6)

  • 10 years ago

    So I did a little more investigating when I got home last night. The wiring is NOT knob and tube, but it is cloth insulated wiring. It should probably get updated sooner rather than later, but from I'm reading it's not as big of a concern as K&T. Is this right? The coating where I can see it seems to be in fairly good condition.


    I had my CB Panel updated when I first moved into the house. I believe it's 400amp with plenty of room to expand. The box is grounded (copper wire comes from the box and is secured to metal pipes nearby. The electrical service was in the basement and had to be moved outside, and it is also grounded to a metal stake in the ground. With this in mind, is the cloth wiring in the house still a potential hazard?

  • 10 years ago

    Note: It looks like braided cloth over rubber sheathing.

  • 10 years ago

    Provided the terminations are done property, there's nothing wrong with older wiring. (Hell there's nothing wrong with K&T if used as it was intended, most problems come from people hacking on it over the years) or covering it with insulation etc...).

    Cloth jackets over plastic conductors were a common early for of ROMEX prior to them going to all plastic. Tons of it still in safe use.

  • 10 years ago

    I found a lot of circuits, primarily lighting, of cloth insulated wire. The strange thing is that it seems many people are unaware of what it is. Just Copper wire with cloth insulation and no additional plastic or rubber jackets. They think it is either some kind of NM cable or assume that is what knob and tube looks like.

    Anyway, to your question. On the lighting in my house I concluded this. The wiring was sized for lighting using old incandescent bulbs. Lighting keeps getting more efficient, so now with CFLs or LEDs the lights are at a fraction of what the original design amperage is. When I found my cloth wires I went ahead and put in LED bulbs everywhere just to get some peace of mind. The right longer term solution is to replace it. I'd go with armored cable since you can snake it inside your old plaster walls and not worry about the nails in the lathe board.

    If your walls/ceilings are open you can go with a cheaper option like EMT. My biggest concern about leaving the cloth wiring in is that in an older home there could always be things going on in the walls or attic that I don't see. If a leak forms or a mouse gets in and decides to chew on the wire and it starts shorting inside the wall I'm not sure what it would look like and I don't want to find out.

  • 10 years ago

    Knob and Tube is not cloth insulated. It's usually a black rubber material. Early NM is cloth sheathed and other than that it may not have a ground, it is fine.

    EMT is cheaper than Type AC? Not around here. EMT runs about 90c a foot and that's before you put conductors in it. Type AC is about half that. Then figure labor.

    Never had a mouse chew open wiring...groundhogs and squirrels on the other hand...