OMG Mitchell Gold? Stunning.

Just go ask them!

Why do you want to change the wall color? I think the darker tone compliments the floors and table very well.

Side Chairs

End Chairs

Bench

Upholstered side (4), Upholstered Arm (2). Choose a fabric that is light grey, or several shades down from what the wall color is. That way you bring in lightness, but don't have to paint the room. A wide stripe might be very nice and sheer, flat roman shades so you retain the outdoor light, but you have a finished window.

What an incredible find! Here are some options from Overstock:

How someone let that table go, IDK! Good on you Jess!

I strongly recommend you sit in the chair before committing. It is so personal and you want to invest in chairs you can hang out in after a company dinner.

Also, as you can see from the above suggestions, you really do have several options for style and finish - all could work with your amazing table - it is about your personal taste and preference and how formal or casual you want to go. Take a nod from what is going on in the adjacent rooms.

I have cream colored leather with key hole back (similar to those pictured above in Beach House 11 photo) - actually from Pier I, on sale, so didn't break the bank! Have held up well, look great and are very easy to clean (don't have to worry at all about stains- well except maybe red wine!)

Let us know what you are leaning toward!

Hi Jess! Congratulations on your incredible find! What do you think about pairing the table with these curvy, tufted dining chairs from Z Gallerie? For the wall color, I would go with a greige such as Sherwin-Williams' #7531 Canvas Tan. Buon Appetito! Wendi

inspiredinteriorsbywendi.com

Hey Jess, here are a few chairs from pictures of other designs by interior designers:

Urban Elegance On The Lakefront · More Info

Condo Renovation - Waterfront. · More Info

Luxury Lorne Park Reno · More Info

How about chairs in the Brno style?

I agree about white MCM chairs! I did a search and found a couple of chair options but the legs weren't exactly compatible with table base -IMO. That's why I didn't post pic............

I absolutely agree with jjwery recommendation for side ghost chairs. Do them in "smoke"

Pedrali Queen Chair, Translucent Smoke Gray, Set of 4 · More Info

Maison Dining Chair · More Info

Thanks everyone for your comments and suggestions! I really appreciate it. Going chair shopping this weekend while everything is on sale :). We actually have ghost style chairs (calligaris ice chairs) in our kitchen dining room. I'll update this post when we've purchased the chairs and finished the room. Thanks again!

What is the style of your home? LR, etc???

So we've decided on neither of the chairs in that picture. I don't think we want a bench. I think we will be chairless for a while because I'm so indecisive. Thanks all for the suggestions. Maybe we'll have more luck with the July 4th sales :P

Hey Jess - yes,this is a difficult decision!

How do you feel about this one: Note the back is wood, front is white leather? and legs metal - might be interesting?

https://www.allmodern.com/Jacque-Side-Chair-WADL3434-WADL3434.html

May I suggest different window treatments for your kitchen eating area? Right now, so much of the fencing, etc. is distracting from the beauty of your interior. Consider bottom up shades blinds. They will block unsightly views while still allowing in light and a nicer view from the top of the windows.

Best.

@visualizemaven - great suggestion! Never thought of that. @tedbixby - thank you. I definitely don't want to settle and we aren't in a rush. Everyone has such great suggestions, but it's hard to buy a chair online when you can't sit on it and feel it and see how good the construction is.

ok - I think the color of the chairs is good but the height of the the chair backs is off. Try pulling them away from the table if you are committed to keeping them. also, ground the entire room with a large rug.

What is your thinking regarding a chandelier? That will make a huge impact in pulling your room together.

IMO a picture gallery will not be desirable because it will just be more rectangle elements being introduced into the room. A better choice will be a very very very large dramatic mirror OR very very very big abstract colorful painting.

Due to the subdued vibe in the room, what you do with the focal point wall and chandelier is critical to the room being a success.

I really like your Crate and Barrel chair choice! Some of the earlier chairs you tried looked too tall. These are great!

Yikes! Are those Mitchell Gold end chairs actually that big or just look incredibly huge and unbalanced in the pic!?

Jess- are the chairs you purchased leather? If so, they are very cleanable. No worries; I know from experience!