The stark difference between the trim and the main house color doesn't work. Also, the door style conflicts with the rest of the house. I think if the colors were more coordinated then the stone column would "fit", plus I think the porch would look better if the column stays. Landscaping would also anchor the house and complete the look. I have an online service, Creative Visual Concepts, where I do mock ups to show how changes might look on your home. If you're interested check it out.

The shutters definitely need to go since they make no sense on bay windows. If you keep the bay window, planting a hedge (such as boxwood) or something else below to fill in the space would make it look more anchored. Is the roof the red/brown it appears in the pics? Is it staying? If so, I would look at warm colors vs. cool.

The roof is red/brown and it is staying (at least for a few more years). Any good color combos you recommend? We will do landscaping under the bay window.

With the red/brown roof and stone on the front of your house, sage green would look great along with yellow. Whatever main color you choose for your house, I would paint the trim a darker color and not use white. It's the white on the house that does not look right with the stone and roof color.

I would keep the stone. Paint the house a light tan or taupe and paint the trim, garage door, and front door a darker shade. Remove the shutters and plant short shrubs under that window. If it's in the budget, replacing the front door would modernize the house.

I like your current house color. The dark trim is an unpleasant distraction though. I scribbled it out to give your house a softer look. I also scribbled out the stone column and the tiny stone wall attached to it. I gave you two shades of neutral on your house.

@kimk76, I got your email request but when I try to reply it keeps bouncing back as undeliverable. Do you have another email address that you can contact me with?