Software
Houzz Logo Print
benedecary

Eco wood treatment ruined my fence

10 years ago
Hi everyone,

could you please help me? I've worked for months on my garage and fence. I've put white cedar for siding. I didn't want to refinish it every too years, so I applied Eco Wood Treatment with a sprayer. Some of it turned gray, some of it turned kakhi, very uneven, looks dirty. It also stained with rust all my concrete sidewalk and patio. And it left marks on my garage door.

Can it be washed out? Can I restore the original color of the wood or put something on it that would brighten the tone? What can I do to make the wood look good again and to get rid of the rust stains?

thank you very much

Comments (27)

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Photos please.

  • 10 years ago
    Here's what it looks like..
  • 10 years ago
    And...
  • 10 years ago
    And...
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Have you contacted the maker of the Eco Wood Treatment? I've seen red cedar leave "stains" on concrete just like this. It was due to the tannins in the wood, not necessarily the treatment itself. Red Cedar bleeds off a colour that is very much like red wine stains. This happens with or without sealant. White Cedar will have the same amount of tannins, but in a more gold or rust colour (colour of white wine instead of red). The tannin bleed is more pronounced after it rains.

    As for the garage door, when using the sprayer, did you properly drape/tape off the door prior to applying the material?

    What type of prep did you do to the cedar? What type of prep was required by the Eco Wood Treatment? Is there any documentation about the Eco Wood Treatment that mentions application over cedar? Some products have specific warnings about specific woods. I'm wondering if there was anything written that specifically mentions cedar.

  • 10 years ago
    You are right, the notice said that it would stain windows and concrete. I sas not aware of that, since i watched the video on youtube, that did not mention any warning and precaution. I found that the magicic eraser works quite well on the windows, but the Rust bleed on the concrete is still a concern. Thanks for your help
  • 10 years ago

    Try some CLR on the concrete

  • 10 years ago

    It helps if you read the directions on the package before posting wrong information

  • 9 years ago

    If Cedar isn't absolutely bone dry, and any fungal residuals lightly sanded off prior to application, that beautiful variation of rusts will occur. The UV will mottle it more bland as time passes. My issue is whether it's all that its crapped up to be. Couldn't find a MSDS on it either.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    to return natural color to wood use Deck Brightener (oxalic acid). like always test a spot.....for concrete a light solution of concrete etch but best to use a professional.

    This solution is design to react with the tannin in the wood.....i think your problem was that white cedar does not have a high concentration of tannin compared to red cedar or redwood......i have used eco with great results as a painting contractor but the wood should not have any contaminates on the surface and should be flooded with a hudson sprayer.....concrete has been a problem and have cleaned it with concrete etch with good results....Primarily this is a distressed finish and greys more with age so if you looking for a clean look this is probably not a good ideal.......for a water proof clear coating after its clean with deck brightener try using C2 Guard to give it protection but first talk to your local paint store (not home depot). every major paint company makes their version of a deck brightener so you should have no problem finding it.

    Good Luck

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Looks to me like the rust stains are rust stains. Are those steel column bases? Are they maintained with paint? If not, and not galvanized, they'll rust. Regarding splotches, my experience is that for a consistent look, you have to have a clean surface and brush the product into the grain evenly, not just spray it.

  • 7 years ago

    My wife and I bought a timber peg lake house last March and the interior was a monolith of orang-ish red cedar beams. While we love the structure - the deep orange tone was just not something we were thrilled with. The interior wood has never been stained or otherwise treated so we decided to use Eco Wood treatment. WOW!!! We and everyone else who visits the house are ABSOLUTELY DELIGHTED with the results. The wood all turned a consistent, silvery chocolate color - not a hint of orange remains. The final color developed in about two weeks. I am so grateful to have discovered this product as I wanted the wood to look weathered/distressed without any shine or loss of wood grain visibility. We used a pump sprayer and did an occassional brush touch-up for the few areas that required a second application.

  • 7 years ago
    Hoping to resurrect this post as I’m researching this product for my deck. We live in the Northeast with long winters and a ton of moisture/lake effect snow.

    Can anyone comment on how well it has held up on a wood deck that was previously painted? I plan on sanding it down to raw wood but wouldn’t be able to get between the boards. Zero maintenance seems too good to be true.

    I also read one review that complained about permanent staining from bird droppings, cat urine, and a lime wedge. Contact with acidic materials appears to remove the product. Has anyone else experienced this?

    Thanks in advance!
  • 7 years ago

    Epicurious122, i was also considering it but when I saw the post above yours, the response from EcoWoodTreatment, I decided this was not a company I wanted to buy from.


  • 7 years ago

    lb45 I checked the guy with the ECHO WOOD TREATMENT post and he is not the company rep. He is a business out of California and sells/uses the ECO product.

    I've had excellent service and information from contacting the company/manufacturer. Their website is www.ECOWOONTREATMENT.com and from my local Sherwin -Williams professionals where I purchased the ECO WOOD TREATMENT from. The company is from Bridgewater, N.S phone number is 902-688-1117 Fax is (902)-688-1199 email: ecowoodtreament@yahoo.com

  • 6 years ago

    grammar not grammer


  • 6 years ago

    Wood bleach powder, diluted with water will take rust off of concrete and bathtubs and showers if you have an iron heavy well as i do. My plumber taught me this trick last year, i cant believe how well it works

  • 6 years ago

    Hello I am researching this product for my deck. I have a big deck (60 feet by 20 feet) 5 years old that I had never stain or treat before. I was planning to apply some protection but I don't want to do any maintenance myself so I was looking at the eco wood treatment product. I want to know, since most posts are a year or 2 old, how is the experience after some time of this product. Also I was considering Thompson Waterseal clear protection. I dont know much about these products and I will appreciate your help and expertise!!! These are two pics of my deck. Thanks!



  • 6 years ago

    Eco wood treatment

    My wife and I bought a timber peg lake house last March and the interior was a monolith of orang-ish red cedar beams. While we love the structure - the deep orange tone was just not something we were thrilled with. The interior wood has never been stained or otherwise treated so we decided to use Eco Wood treatment. WOW!!! We and everyone else who visits the house are ABSOLUTELY DELIGHTED with the results. The wood all turned a consistent, silvery chocolate color - not a hint of orange remains. The final color developed in about two weeks. I am so grateful to have discovered this product as I wanted the wood to look weathered/distressed without any shine or loss of wood grain visibility. We used a pump sprayer and did an occassional brush touch-up for the few areas that required a second application.

  • 6 years ago

    It stained my concrete where the sprayer leaked without me realizing... this is just eco wood treatment straight from my mixing bottle. Not happy.


  • 5 years ago

    I'm using this stain on huge fir beams in my new post and beam house after finding that very very expensive stains like weatherwood do not tackle red consistently and leave a horrible result. I spoke with that company btw and they are extremely ignorant and unhelpful. I used this stain in desperation after the builder recommended it. I'm impressed. the result is more consistent. it can stain very dark to black but I sprayed a bleach solution, why not, over the staining and the beams lightened up. they look excellent. oxalic acid can be used for the same purpose but wearing protective gear is a must. For lightening one can also use a white maintenance oil on the wood. great result too.

  • 5 years ago

    Lime

  • 5 years ago

    Lime wash then

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    can anyone tell me how this product holds up over time? I have a newly installed pool deck.. treated lumber and trying to find the best product to use. Thank you.

  • 4 years ago

    I want a light grey on my western cedar siding .I applied some Eco to an extra piece of cedar. It's a lot darker than I had hoped. If I add more water to the 1 gallon would I get a lighter color?