I vote for the first one.
I have to say that sofa is fabulous! Love it.

Thanks. The walls in that room are so high, I am worried the mirror will look small in comparison. Here is a picture of the wall where the mirror wall go. I put painters tape up to approximate the width and height of the mirrors.

Thanks. I Iove the sofa too. I was debating on the color forever but I am happy I took the plunge.

So the tan sofa will be gone from the room. It's just in there now before I donate that and a few other things. The blue sofa will actually go on the opposite wall in front of a set of windows. I have another tan sofa in that spot right now, which will also be gone soon. Where the blue sofa is currently I am planning to get 2 chairs. The room is a combined living and dining room so I don't want to overfurnish and have it look cramped and stuffy. (The dollhouse will also be moved soon.)

I agree with tedbixby that it's impossible to say whether particular leaner mirrors would work well in a room based on seeing one part of one wall.

Yes it would just be the mirror on that wall. Here is a picture.

Here is another one

Here is a wider shot of the room.

I was just thinking if I could find chairs with a patterned back, that might look cool to have them in front of the mirror so their backs reflected in the mirror.