Without knowing/seeing the room/furniture into which the item will fit, it is impossible to say which console would be best. They are all quite ornate, and I presume they are going into an eclectic environment. Three are dark and one is comparatively lighter. What is needed for the room; a light touch or more grounding via a dark piece? They also seem to reflect different decorating sensibilities - Asian, Spanish, Jacobean and over the top French. Can you provide photos of the space where you plan to use one of them? If it is for a foyer, the piece should hint at the owner's personality and style, as well as reflect some of what one may expect in the adjoining spaces.

I love ornate furniture but like the person stated above me, what room is this going into? Are you using the same colors and decor that are with the console? That would also be a deciding factor.

From just looking at these pieces without all of the info needed, I love the first one the best and the second one is very close as well. I do not care for the other two, and I'm not a fan of distressed furniture!