Software
Houzz Logo Print
ijsbrandtga

3-Year Struggle to find Front Door Color

10 years ago
I moved away from the Atlanta Metro area and bought my rural home 3 years ago. I am inspired by the large property which gives me room to farm and garden and by the absence of militant HOAS! But, with all this freedom, I am struggling with color choices. My home has a very light beige-stone colored siding and a copper roof. It faces East and has a recessed front door which begs for hydrangeas, hostas and other shade-part shade plants. As you can see, there are some clunky Holly's to the right with a heavily pruned laurel of some sort as an end cap. I like color and purchased some paint from the Disney metallic line. My choice was a metallic teal that reminds me of verdigris to play off the copper roof. In the last picture of paint chips, the color I chose is the first one, Ariel's Tale. I haven't pulled the trigger yet and wanted to get some thoughts/ideas before doing so. Help???

Comments (42)

  • 10 years ago
    P.S. I want to add that there was a lot of overgrown shrubbery up against the house when I bought it. I have removed the overgrowth and now need to get the siding pressure washes which will make it several shades lighter. I took one of the pictures this past winter and the others this week. I would like to work towards a cottage garden/French country look. I'm thinking of applying flagstone to the exposed concrete.
  • 10 years ago
    You should power wash before selecting the door color as the color change will effect your decision. Personally I think the teal you are leaning toward is a bit garish. If you like teal I would look at a deeper version.
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Take your cue from the roof. A much deeper rust tone. Sorry.......no teal

  • 10 years ago
    3 year struggle to choose a door color? It's only paint.
    #1stworldproblem.
  • 10 years ago
    Thank you!!! I wasn't "feeling" the teal and that's why I headed here to post! Any help with the color family is appreciated - somewhere to start once the pressure washing is done. Rust - as in reds or browns? Any design suggestions?
  • 10 years ago
    Here is a suggestion for a blue. It is more grayed which I think would look better than a bright bluefish.
  • 10 years ago
    http://www.gardenista.com/posts/curb-appealorange/

    Here a is article from Pinterest showing orange tones for front doors
  • 10 years ago
    Are you painting the door yourself or hiring someone to do it? If you're doing the prep and paint yourself I say just buy the paint and try it so you can see how it looks. I've had good luck with that for interior doors because Lowes and Home Depot sell inexpensive samples at the paint counter for about $3.50 and I only need one or two to paint the whole door. Maybe check if they sell exterior paint in sample sizes. My only problem has been limited sheen options - they only had flat and satin for interior paint.

    I like edwards4four's suggestion of a darker teal.
  • 10 years ago
    Although you were looking for paint help, could your struggle be that the door style is not working? In a nice rural setting a wood door might add the depth you are looking for.
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Mater Metal, or color that flatters the roof. I like the simplicity of your house.... I would get a large iron piece to center above windows in gable right of your entryway.... clean all that mess up and power wash, come in with mulch and plantings, lighting, and maybe stain concrete porch and walkways.... You desperately need landscaping.

  • 10 years ago
    wow - I love the idea of a wood door! I never thought of staining the concrete stairs - is that a better option than paint? I will definitely look into that. I also feel that the bottom window to the left (that's the garage) looks lonely and awkward. should I just leave it alone? Thank you everyone for these great ideas. I very much appreciate the help.
  • 10 years ago

    All I see when I look at the picture is the dirty stairs. And it looks to me like the sidewalk could be expanded?

  • 10 years ago

    I think a bright color could be great, but I'm not sure that teal will really go well with your roof once it changes from coppery tones to the eventual green. Has that really not happened yet? It's such a... whitish green, with aqua undertones, that it can be hard to anticipate. I might just go with a bright color to cheer up my doorway for now, and change things up once the green has really settled in.

  • 10 years ago
    I dont think the roof is actually copper, but a copper color metal. I like the word one person used about the teal being "garish." but, like you mentioned, I was trying to find that right "pop" of color that is talked about so much.
  • 10 years ago
    BTW the stairs are not so much dirty as they are stained from mold/mildew? It's such a shady area that gets very little-to-no-sun.
  • 10 years ago
    In addition you can replace the rockets with a bench on the left side adding a piece of metal artwork for color above planters on each side of the door in front of the sidelights a large welcome mat
  • 10 years ago

    I agree with Katharine. I would opt for more blue than green. From the swatches above, I like Glimmering Wings or Fender Flash.

  • 10 years ago
    I don't know if that Disney paint is still available but that's okay. I had guessed that the metallic paint would be good with the metal roof. I'm just very new at this so I appreciate all the kind guidance more than you know. I like the welcome mat idea and will look for one with some bright colors. I want to plant some astillbes and ??? in the planters and use the "thriller filler spiller" formula. Any thoughts about the lonely garage window? Shutters?
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    No metallic and no teal. If the chairs are staying, I would do charcoal black. Also, those steps are not to code. Way too steep. I would have those steps replaced before I spent a penny on painting the door because the door color you have looks perfectly fine. Order a set of precast steps that go all the way across.

  • 10 years ago
    Copper color
  • 10 years ago
    very good idea! Thank you! I hope they aren't terribly expensive; there are many DIY projects from the former owner that were obviously not permitted.:(
  • 10 years ago

    You should paint your door a color that makes you smile every time you walk in the house.

    You don't need to please anyone else.

  • 10 years ago
    Katherine, I like the blues you pointed out earlier and I am now "following" you. Is there a way to communicate one-to-one with other Houzz members?
  • 10 years ago

    My first reaction was also to have the stairs changed first! Wider, comfortable height, width and fully extended to the right; I say to the right since I noticed a small door on the left bottom which probably can not be cancelled completely. If it can be, than have the stairs extended to both sides completely: this will make the whole entrance look larger. You can always decorate the steps with lovely pots and seasonal shade loving plants.

    NO to teal since you intend to plant that area; teal and green foliage will kill each other. Be brave and go for a lighter (or brighter) & contrasting colour to enhance your plants and brighten up the entrance, it will be more "inviting".

    Good luck :-)

  • 10 years ago
    Teri,
    Go to a persons profile, then click follow. Thank you. There is a message icon on top right of the profiles. I am on an iPad so it may be different than a pc.
    Btw, I explain directions terribly so I hope it helps.
  • 10 years ago
    I like the front of your garage. Your house has nice texture with the siding. Please don't add shutters. They are too traditional for your house. A tree or bushes properly placed in front of garage will make a big difference.
  • 10 years ago
    Teri, I have done private mssg but I don't know how I did it...lol
  • 10 years ago
    Teri, go to my profile and click on message...you did not enable your messages yet so I have to post here. please excuse us other posters...off topic
  • 10 years ago
    Katherine - forgive my ignorance but I do not see a message icon on your profile, just the "share" icon. I also went to my profile and do not see anything that enables messaging - though I do have an Inbox. I also looked for a Houzz Help icon - no luck on that either. :(
  • PRO
    10 years ago


    Terri- The mettalic paint will be too garish, but it sounds like you would like a pop of color. So I would suggest going with color, not a neutral black or copper, etc. There are beautiful shades of blue or green that would look perfect with your copper roof. Sand the door, use an oil based primer, then two coats of an oil based paint. It will have some sheen, but not be garish like a metallic. The door doesn't have to match anything, let it be a stand out! Go for color!! :)


    Springwater Cottage · More Info

    1920's Remodel and Basement Extension · More Info

    Traditional Entry · More Info

    My Houzz: Cheery and Breezy Pittsburgh Home · More Info

  • 10 years ago
    Teri, I am the worst to explain...mostly I do trial and error. Don't feel bad. Sooner or later we will figure it out. Maybe someone will help.
    Did you decide on a door color?
    I like the idea of a wide steps then you could add a couple of urns or pots of flowers on one of the steps.
  • 10 years ago
    No color decision yet, but one thing is clear: NO metallic! Got some great ideas too! I'm anxious to see what help I can get with my living room....
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    Why the indecision on color for one door? What is blocking you? That is the biggest problem to resolve. Pick the color you are most drawn to the second you see it and try it. It will be freeing!
    Terri Osipov thanked Flo Mangan
  • 10 years ago
    I think it's like looking at a Chinese menu. There are so many choices. if there is a way to take a picture once the pressure washing is done and then get an app where I can "try on" different colors then I think that may be the solution to choosing.
  • 10 years ago
    I am very new to the technology stuff. I'm learning and constantly amazed.
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Just try it, we all learn by trial and error. That is just life!

    Terri Osipov thanked Flo Mangan
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    There is a way to try different colors- try this: http://www.benjaminmoore.com/en-us/for-your-home/personal-color-viewer

    You can upload your own pics and save them if you create an account. I use it all the time to 'repaint' my rooms and it is so helpful for visualizing! I uploaded a pic of my living room and used it to change the colors of the walls, ceiling, and door. So much easier than painting swatches everywhere.


    Terri Osipov thanked Jen W
  • 10 years ago
    Did you paint your front door?
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    Wow, three years! Without knowing your budget it's tough. Agree with others; power wash house and front walk and stairs. If stone walk and stairs is not an option, stain is great idea! Also, the front door needs to go. Does not fit house. Dark stain on door. Add color with a pair of large planters on each side of door. Plant your hydrangeas . Add evergreen shrubs for off season color and depth. Plantings on side of walk. Look at pictures of houses like yours in shelter magazines. That will help guide you.

    Enjoy!
    Barbara Brown
    Barbara Brown Interiors
    Terri Osipov thanked Barbara Brown Interiors, Inc.
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    Oh yes... One more thing; no metallic Disney paint. Less is more, I love painted front doors.... Do walk , cleaning and plantings, look at pictures in magazines, then pick your door finish.... Have fun!
    Terri Osipov thanked Barbara Brown Interiors, Inc.
  • 10 years ago
    I would do something like this no crazy color let your roof and ingesting patterned siding stand out
    Terri Osipov thanked Danielle Black