Software
Houzz Logo Print
mikerno_1micha

Hi Al, Tapla, quick question for you)

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

Is it possible to have a Magnesium deficiencies while using Foliage Pro?

As one member put it...

"even if my trees do not look deficient (I do have a Persian lime that has a few older leaves like that, 'Mg deficient' but I figured that was not fixable), I should apply Epsom salts? I had no idea, but will do it if it will cure this issue on my tree.

This member and others have been told to use Epsom Salts to correct the issue and yet I never seem to have this issue..

The members being told to use Epsom Salts are using the 5..1.1 mix and Foliage Pro...Vinegar if their water pH is too high.. This is the answer one got that is using Foliage Pro and the 5.1.1 mix used with Lime...

"The leaves on your tree are showing a magnesium deficiency. My guess is that you have not fed your tree with magnesium (Epsom salts MgSO4) in some time. The symptoms of magnesium deficiency always shows up on the tree's older leaves, because in citrus magnesium is a translocation element. Translocation means that when a citrus tree is deficient in magnesium the older, more mature leaves, translocates their stored magnesium to the tree's younger leaves to insure that they are given all the nutrients that they require (the tree's priority). Thus called a translocation element. Magnesium deficiencies can occur at any time of the year, but are most common in the fall . To cure this deficiency dissolve one tablespoon of Epsom Salts (Magnesium Sulfate MgSO4) in one gallon WARM water (Epsom salts poorly dissolves in cool water) then apply to the root zone, it can also be applied as a foliar spray. It could take several applications a couple weeks apart, until symptoms disappear. Epsom salts should be applied to container tree's three times a year, especially for trees in fruit"

Please let me know if it was sound advice given....

Thanks! Hope you are doing well too

Comments (6)

  • 10 years ago

    Mike, I find it hard to believe that a Mg deficiency would occur in 511 if dolomitic lime had been incorporated and FP used as fertilizer. I'm interested in what Al has to say.

    myermike_1micha thanked User
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Hopefully he will answer as soon as he gets a moment..I see a lot of naysayers on other threads and I am getting the feeling he will be directing his attention away from here(

  • 10 years ago

    Al, bout your statement: If plants are exhibiting chlorosis because of an Fe (iron) deficiency,
    and the grower doses with Epsom salts, and the plant subsequently
    returns to a nice green color,
    Why would a plant return to green color with Epsom salts if it had an Fe deficiency?

    myermike_1micha thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    You can force a plant to turn greener by overdosing with a nutrient (Mg, Mn, Fe) that already exists in the soil in adequate amounts and is available in adequate amounts, which serves to illustrate that GREEN doesn't necessarily equate to HEALTHY if you must go to such extremes to achieve it (green).

    A common symptom of a P deficiency is dark green foliage, but does anyone suggest that we withhold all P from our supplementation program so plants take on that healthy green glow? Of course not - so why should we be over-quick to supply toxic (an excess is a toxicity and has the same potential to limit as a deficiency) levels of any nutrient? To make our plants pleasingly green at any cost? Very often, chlorosis is a cultural issue unrelated to nutrition. If over-watering is causing chlorotic foliage and we overdose with N, Fe, Mg, or Mn and see an improvement in leaf color, did we fix the over-watering problem and is the plant healthier?

    An improvement in leaf color CAN be a sign of improved health. It can also be a manifestation of a toxicity of one nutrient masking a deficiency of another. It's very hard to beat a supplementation program that supplies ALL the nutrients plants normally take from the soil, in a ratio at which the plant actually absorbs the nutrients, and at a concentration high enough to ensure there are no deficiencies yet low enough that water/nutrient uptake isn't impaired by a concentration of dissolved solids in the soil solution that's too high.

    To justify dosing with Epsom salts on an 'at will' basis, one would need to be sure there was indeed a Mg deficiency in need of remedy, or show error in the bold print immediately above. It's worth repeating that if there is indeed no deficiency of Mg in the soil solution, dosing with Epsom salts has ONLY the potential to limit and no potential to benefit. The only exception (I can think of) to that thought might occur when the level of free Ca in the soil was so out of balance (high) with the level of other nutrients, that an excess of Mg was needed to ensure the plant could take up an adequate supply.

    Al

    myermike_1micha thanked tapla (mid-Michigan, USDA z5b-6a)
  • 10 years ago

    Thank you Al!! I knew I could count on you for your help and expertise...You never disappoint me with helping me to be successful..Thanks for your patience after all this years..I can never sit back and say I have learned it all...

    I can save this thread and it will come in very handy..)

Sponsored
Daniel Home
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars20 Reviews
Premier Interior Design Team Transforming Spaces in Franklin Co, Ohio