Software
Houzz Logo Print
toronado3800

Acer Palmatum - Invasive?

From MOBOT's website I clicked to this invasive plant site: http://www.invasiveplantatlas.org/subject.html?sub=3001

Where it reports Acer palmatum "has escaped cultivation, naturalised and is considered a weed in New South Wales and other parts of Australia. Acer palmatum
has escaped and naturalized in the eastern United States and Hawaii,
Canada and New Zealand. Widespread use of this plant increases the
probability that more will escape from cultivation.

I HAVE seen a couple seedlings under one of my neighbor's trees over the last fourteen years. None has made it though. Even one I popped up in the fall. I don't recall ever seeing it on a U.S. State's list of invasive plants and it isn't like I see them sprouting along the highways here..

Can someone educate me? Where is this an issue with them?
"



Comments (14)

  • 10 years ago

    "invasive" is probably too strong a word for its situation here in the US. To the best of my knowledge, the only state that lists it as 'invasive' is VA and even there it has only naturalized to a degree in a couple of parks. And 'naturalized' is far cry away from being significantly invasive!!

    To be sure, if happily situated and established, JM's can produce a lot of seeds and they can germinate freely. But this is a somewhat fussy tree AFA specific growing conditions are concerned so I believe concerns of it becoming invasive like Albizia or Ailanthus or Norway maples is overstating the case.

    Japanese maples are very popular and heavily planted in my area - virtually every garden has one or more. And the PNW offers nearly ideal growing conditions for these trees. And while I often encounter seedling JM's in the vicinity of larger mature trees, I've yet to ever see one growing 'wild' (as in not intentionally planted) in a natural wooded area.

  • 10 years ago

    I wish they were here! Something besides ugly white pine and ailanthus on the roadsides LOL.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I understand what you mean Logan.

    Many areas have subtle difference sobIbthought I'd ask. Everything seems invasive in Australia for example, maybe there they have Acer palmatum volunteers lining highways.

  • 10 years ago

    I've seen only a few Acer palmatum seedlings naturalizing in my neighborhood. I think our late summers are just too dry for them to survive except in limited shaded, damp locations. I dug up a nice reddish one and it might be a keeper.

  • 10 years ago

    In truth, this reads like a lot of other earlier invasions. Somewhat concerned, not too much, but the plants keep selling. I doubt we really know what the parameters for this one to explode are. But many an invasive plant starts out "not too bad" as far as invasiveness, then it goes crazy. Once upon a time, those few common buckthorns showing up in the woods here were "no cause for concern" too.

    Still, who knows? Maybe Japanese maple will not become a scourge. For that matter, I thought we'd be seeing more problems with Amur maple by now. A condo complex where I used to do landscaping and maintenance has Amur maples with full groundcover of seedlings under them each year. This looked worrisome to me back when, but I'm not seeing Amur maples showing up all over creation. So maybe the Japanese maples will follow that path and be relatively well-behaved.

  • 10 years ago

    Well, if they become invasive maybe they won't be so darn expensive to buy. LOL!

  • 10 years ago

    Just from experience! Thanks for correcting me.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Since eastern North America is much more like eastern Asia than here in the P. N. W and California, has already had a number of popular woody ornamental plants of Asian origin go bananas in some areas it wouldn't surprise me at all if Japanese maples started being seen seeding out in numbers. Presumably we only have them carpeting garden beds here because those often get watered.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    "But many an invasive plant starts out "not too bad" as far as invasiveness, then it goes crazy."

    Evolution and natural selection.

  • 10 years ago

    Interesting, I have seen what I thought were seedlings of my (expensive) bloodgood but was SURE it couldn't be possible since they cost so much $!

    The one I am really having issues with is the crape myrtle. One huge one in landscape that was planted probably years ago by previous owner, and just took out 4 over 8' tall and have a bunch of smaller ones to pull out. zone 7a...is this happening to others in my zone as well with crape myrtle?

  • 10 years ago

    I find four or five seedlings under my bloodgood each spring and feel irrationally excited. None have survived their first Virginia summer.

    My crapes don't seed much but boy do they send out root suckers. Seedlings would be easy to pull LOL.

  • 10 years ago

    Maybe seedlings from the true species JM would have better chances to survive. Cutleaves, purple leaves, hanging branches and so on will not help in the competition with other shrubs.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    "I find four or five seedlings under my bloodgood each spring and feel
    irrationally excited. None have survived their first Virginia summer."

    I don't mean to seem like I'm "bragging" about my microclimate, but I have 2 old bloodgoods or similar and get scores of seedlings. And they do almost all survive. I don't mind them at all - they are much easier to pull out than other tree seedlings. The woods adjacent to my lot have at least 5 seedlings in various stages maybe as big as 5 feet tall. But overall I don't think JM will ever become truly invasive in the way of other plants...or not any time soon. For one thing the ones in the woods would never survive being strangled by Asian Celastrus, which would soon happen if I weren't removing it. There are so many other big-league invasives around here - tree of hell, paulownia, albizia, multiflora rose, celastrus, rose of white trash sharon...that JM would never be anything other than the background noise. I suspect the people paid to think about the question have come to the same conclusion, too.