http://www.oldhouseguy.com/shutters/

Someone posted this excellent article the other day so I'm sending it along to help with your decision. I think the bigger issue here is the clumpy, overgrown shrubbery. I would remove all of it and get a professional landscaper in to do justice to your home with new plantings.

Because the windows are smaller in scale, I like it shuttered.

I think the house looks better with shutters. I also think the landscaping needs a make-over;)

I absolutely refuse to allow you to put "fake shutters" on your house! ;^) Since you already applied new siding on your house it may be cost prohibitive. But just adding a "wide board" around the window trim will bring out the windows more than you might think. Functioning shutters are great...but please...no fake shutters! Good luck.

You could only really do shutters on the single windows and I wouldn't bother. I do think your door color needs to be deeper. Definitely landscaping.

I would like to see shutters but not black. I think you should paint them white!

I totally agree with David no shutters and the removal of the over growth and a really large black planter where you have the little short one