We are repainting our house and need help replacing the very gold stucco color. We narrowed it down and are trying to decide between these two Sherwin Williams colors: smoky beige (short board in pic) and practical beige (tall board in pic).

Any votes for one or the other?

Also - we had originally been inspired by the color of the garage of another home but haven't found any luck on trying to get close to that color. (Pic below)

All Opinions are welcome.