Software
Houzz Logo Print
letsgobird7b

Spider mites! Is there a systemic ?

9 years ago

I moved my 120 succulent pots inside and they've been doing so well until I found spider mites on a few last night. Do I use alcohol to remove them as I did mealy bugs and scale? Is there a safe systemic as I have parrots and am very leary of pesticides. Also, I believe dry environment promotes them, should I mist around the plants frequently? I've got 7 ft tall fiddle leaf fig, rubber plant and pony tail palm close to them and im nervous that they will get them. Thanks for any info

Comments (32)

  • 9 years ago

    The problem with spider mites is getting the unhatched eggs, I WOULD DO A ALCOHOL WIPE AND A SYSTEMIC. bAYER MARKETS A (darn) product that I see recommended on several plant forums.

  • 9 years ago

    Neem oil will work both as a spray or as a soil drench, where it will have systemic properties. And as it is a natural product with a multitude of human uses as well, it is very unlikely that your parrot would have any issues with the stuff.

    If you choose to go with a more "traditional" insecticide, make sure it is registered specifically for spider mites. They do not respond to many common insecticides as they are not really insects but belong to an entirely different classification.

  • 9 years ago

    Avid or Floramite are sort of systemics (translaminar). Imidacloprid will not kill them.

    Many acaracides are quite nasty so do some good research. Most are $$$.

    Misting will not really help enough to make a difference.

  • 9 years ago

    Acaricides are definitely very dollardollardollar. I've used neem for regular winter prep, both as spray and dilute soil drench before coming in. This has prevented winter outbreaks for me for 3 years now.

    I've used neem also as plant dunk, for a Faucaria tuberculosa "Sato" infested with spider mites. Just as a sensitivity benchmark for reference, I dunked the thing, pot and all, thrice over a period of two weeks, during which it stayed in the dark corner of the litter room. 5 ml per one liter of water.

    If you have several, do not reuse the solution, flush them each time and dunk the plant in fresh solution. It's a bit of work but I guess I just haven't found my red line yet, for when to resort to scary pesticides. Save it for the really bad ones like aloe mites.

    Pagan

  • 9 years ago

    I have heard of using mouthwash to spray on the plants. It contains alcohol and some other benefits that I can't find right now. I have no idea about the spider mites?

  • 9 years ago

    I had a bad spider mite attack on my cacti last year, shortly before their winter rest. I made a combination of 50% Listerine Original mouthwash and 50% water in a hand sprayer, and thoroughly wetted them all down three times, at one week intervals. To my great surprise (I was not expecting much, but there was not really anything else I could get here) the mites all disappeared, I have not noticed any for more than a year now. Some plants still have the scars, but no mites left. Worth a try, I think.

  • 9 years ago

    Yes, I have heard about it but never used it yet. It contains Thymol and Benzoic Acid along with Alcohol. I didn't know how much to dilute it. I have heard only good things with it.

  • 9 years ago

    It was probably the alcohol in the mouthwash that curtailed the spider mites, as it does not contain any plant oils in sufficient concentration for them to have any effect. And it will not work as a systemic, only for a topical application.

  • 9 years ago

    Yes, I figure it is the alcohol too. And you are right, it is not a systemic, so not what the OP was asking for. But it worked and it was easy and as non-toxic as you can get a mite killer, apart from hot water at just the right temperature, so I thought it was worth mentioning ;-). Years ago I used to zap them with pretty nasty stuff that is not even available any more, so I was delighted with my unexpected success.

  • 9 years ago

    Pagan could you please share what ratios you use for the neem spray? These guys and thrips are hands down the most frustrating.

    To the listerine discussion, I have used original listerine on various orchid species in the past to prevent fungal and minor bug issues with no damage. I believe its the alcohol that desiccates them.

    Systemics as mentioned by pagan and mayo ^^ are quite $$$, and many will only last "systemically" 20-60 days before you need to reapply or rotate with another miticide. I have heard decent things about Tetrasan as it only kills mites and not other beneficial insects but it too requites proper ventilation, gloves, mask, etc.
    Some plants are spider mite magnets might be worth evaluating if they're worth the trouble.

  • 9 years ago

    I have a 1-gallon pump sprayer and for regular prophylactic spraying in autumn, I add a tablespoon of neem extract. Mind you this is going to reek. I don't mind the smell, since I'm familiar with the tree so I associate it with just random green-ey oil smell. Those not familiar with the smell of tropical jungles might object.

    As emergency treatment which I do not use as spray but as full dunk, I make it a bit stronger. 5 ml to a liter of water. Take note though that I don't use soil so the substrate only retains as much as pumice can hold on to. I dunk the whole plant. And I did it thrice over a two-week period. In between dunks I rinsed off the roots with a strong solution of Bt a couple of days after each dunk. If you're worried about too much watering, put the pot on a cotton towel or some cotton rag that will absorb liquids quickly. It really depends on what plant you're treating. I don't use it by itself if I'm treating an active infestation. I always accompany it with Bt as soil drench. They probably don't survive very long in very gritty substrate but while they're alive, they'll get ingested by whatever is alive in the substrate.

    I hope your thrips problem gets resolved. What did they hit?

    Pagan

  • 9 years ago

    Pagan - What's the reason for the Bt and are you using BTi or BTk?

    Interestingly enough, you can't even buy neem oil here in Canada anymore!

  • 9 years ago

    Pagan,

    I'm also curious about the reason for the Bt.

    Minty,

    I am also battling those #%£%#!!! thrips. I've had them a low levels on a few plants for a few years, but this year they are everywhere! I've a new type of pesticide to try ( Safers End All II) but am reluctant to do it indoors, and winter has come early here. Any advice?

  • 9 years ago

    Breton - I haven't had to deal with thrips yet and I'm glad for that!

    Here's the use information for Safer's End All II: http://m.plantproducts.com/ca/viewproduct.php?pid=1314

    You can use it indoors, but I would spray outside and bring the plants in. It's an Insecticidal soap Pyrethrin combination mix. Not listed to kill thrips (check bottle) but I think it should work. You will need to repeat many times to get them all with this pesticide; I read they are extremely resilient.

    It works on spider mites too but becomes increasingly phytotoxic with subsequent sprays. I would keep out of the sun after spraying to prevent some of the damage and lengthen the life of the Pyrethrin as will (it degrades under light).

    Other brands of this stuff damaged some of my succulents but others looked fine.

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks Kevin

    I realize it doesn't say thrips on the label, but the knowledgable staff at my local plant store were quite certain it would work. It's going to be below 0 here for the next week ( so no taking plants outdoors) and then we'll be away for the holidays... Wish I could get do something about them now! Tempted to paint the thrips with the EndAll 2 rather than spray everything, but realize I'll miss most of them. But at least I'll see some die!!!!

  • 9 years ago

    Pagan thanks for sharing your formula, what kind of succulents have you
    used this on if you dont mind my asking. Im leery of neem
    because my understanding of oils is that they can suffocate the plant or it to leave it vulnerable to roasting under intense sun. Bt is bacillus thuringiensis right? The stuff thats in mosquito dunks and gnatrol?...

    Thrips are relentless and they will attack just about everything- seedlings, haworthias, mesembs, you name it. For ex: I started some seeds back in September and didnt realize I had a problem till I one day saw "chomps" of seedlings, a few pots became larvae snacks. Infested pots were disposed of and the remaining got some crumbled mosquito dunks BTI on the top and a fan running.

    Breton you need to find out where the thrips are coming from to cut them off otherwise its endless. What kind of soil are you using for your succulents? Do you have other houseplants nearby?...

  • 9 years ago

    Minty,

    Thanks for the response. I was battling them on a Haworthia maughanii and a Delosperma sutherlandii last winter. A summer outdoors seemed to knock them back. But now they are popping up on Echies, Pleiospilos, and random other genera. All of my house plants are succulents (about 150 at the moment) . Infestation seems confined to plants under growlights, so far. I've been dabbing them off with rubbing alcohol whenever I see them ( I know simply painting them does not kill them, but pickling them does) but I am also trying to have a life! My plants have been a bit drier than they would like lately due to general business and the addition of a second sunblaster bulb to my setup. All my plants are in gritty mix. Thinking I should add a fan perhaps. Would it need to be on constantly?

    And does Bt really work on them? I didn't think it would.... I'll try it if it helps at all.

  • 9 years ago

    Letsgobird... Sorry to hijack your thread!!!!

  • 9 years ago

    I had gnats too so I used it on all the plants. I was using Bt israelensis or whatever that "i" is. That time, my pot of grapto was infested with spider mites and it also infected my Faucaria tigrina. I dunked them both. Both have non-fleshy roots, unlike, say, haworthias.

    I've applied neem on haworthias too though. And everything I have, actually. But remember I do this before they go indoors whether I see anything or not. So they are not in the sun at all. Then they're in the shelves unlit for a week before I switch everything on.

    I've only had a few occasions to use neem in high summer. It has never been a problem, provided the treated plants are in the shade while they are being treated and for another week after the final treatment.

    I mean, I'd readily use scary chems if an infestation ever gets out of hand on a plant I particularly like. It's hard to use them safely and responsibly but not impossible. So far, though, it hasn't happened. I'm a little nutty about prevention. I keep new plants isolated for a whole season, for example. And I think I draw my line at armored scales---any plant that has it gets tossed, full stop. Fortunately, that's the worst I've had to deal with so far.

    Soil-free substrate has really cut down on bothersome creatures, I noticed. Also I stopped buying plants from BBS long ago.

    Pagan

  • 9 years ago

    Letsgobird we took over your thread, sorry :/!

    Breton, arent they the MOST frustrating creatures, you think you got them then they show up again. AGHHH! They do not discriminate, all plants are an opportunity.
    Okay first thing is sourcing where they're emerging from- inorganic mix is the way to go with these guys. A few suggestions, let everything dry out completely, make sure there is NO standing water at the bottom of your pots/trays for maybe a good week or two. Get some mosquito dunks/mosquito bits and crumble them on the top of your soil. Be a little stingy with the watering till you get rid of these guys.
    A fan helped in blowing adults away so they dont lay their eggs in the soil, but I dont recommend keeping one going 24/7-too much of a fire hazard imo.

    Pagan thank you so much for your help! Okay its a relief to know that you've used it successfully on haworthias without incident. By dunking you mean the entire plant or just the roots? I will give this a go on a few plants that seem to be problematic.
    Yeah I too prefer using less harmful options before going to other alternatives. Isolating plants for a few seasons is the way to go if you can, but persistent pests will always find a way, especially growing indoors for an extended period of time seems to make this more probable. What can you do :)

  • 9 years ago

    The two plants I have dunked, yes, I do mean dunking the whole thing--pot and all--in the solution. Then throw that away if you are treating more than one plant. Fresh tub every time.

    This one got the full spa treatment last winter:


    The grapto is in the basement.

    Question about the thrips--when they're blown away, don't they just try to scuttle back in search of a plant?

  • 9 years ago

    What's BBS?

  • 9 years ago

    BBS means Big Box Store.... Any of those giant chains...


    Minty

    Thanks. I have actually noticed that when I leave my plants drier than usual for a bit, the thrip population increases quickly. I've read that they prefer warm dry conditions. Are your thrips the little black ones?



  • 9 years ago

    Breton they do prefer warmer environments, it allows their cycle to occur more rapidly, its quite gross. Yeah they are tiny and black and fly in a circular pattern. They're attracted to CO2 and bright light and I generally find them hanging out at bright windows or near plants. Crush as many adults as possible.

    http://ipm.ucanr.edu/PMG/PESTNOTES/pn7448.html

    In your position I would: first find the source- why are they there in the first place. Second make their conditions more unfavorable- changing soil, adding grit to the top of pots, less frequent watering, mosquito bits (this is important), fan when possible, cooler temps, killing off as many adults, grow a carnivorous plant nearby, put a thin screen over your plants so adults cannot access your plants etc.
    They are relentless but can be overcome if you're not using an organic soil and can control moisture levels.

    Pagan thats a good looking faucaria, fresh tub for each plant is the way to go, I agree. How are all your plants doing this winter?

    For fungus gnats, if you keep a fan on for awhile and the current is strong enough they don't have the opportunity to land and lay eggs so they f off elsewhere. The fan is just one part of the treatment, if I didnt use the mosquito dunks/bits, find the source, and so on they'd still be rampant.


  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Minty

    The link you posted seems to be all about fungus gnats, and I thought Breton was referring to thrips?

    There are many posts on this forum about fungus gnats, and I def. agree that moist and organic environment will 'keep them coming'. I started using very gritty mix about 3 yrs ago, and almost never see a fungus gnat.

    IMO, thrips are even more dangerous than FG, and probably more difficult to eliminate. Do not know anything about them...

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Yup, thrips are small and wiggly pests. They can hitch a ride with air currents but I don't think they fly?

    Supposedly extremely difficult to control.

  • 9 years ago

    Yes, I have never seen my thrips flying! They are not flies, which I why I was surprised to hear mention of using Bt. They do jump though. A screen would not keep them out, they are minuscule. I am not using organic mixes.

    May get some yellow sticky traps to try, I've heard they may help.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Bt works on guts - it has to be eaten to kill the maggot/larva. The fungus gnat flies are not killed by Bt, they live only about a week. But in that short time they lay approx. 300 eggs.

    I do not know much about thrips, but I read that they have wings: ..."Adults are very small (less than 1/25 inch) straw-colored or black slender insects with two pairs of feathery wings. Without the use of a hand lens, they resemble tiny dark threads"... They fly or leap/jump. Apparently, they are attracted to blue sticky trap (rather than yellow). Blue trap is also good against leaf miners.

  • 9 years ago

    Bt-i for flies, Bt-k for lepidopterans (moth and/or butterfly larvae). I was using it for gnats. The neem treatment I suggest is for spider mites, which is the original subject of the OP. Not sure how thrips got into the Bt or even the neem discussion but it is neem that can be used against thrips as well; they get smothered pretty much the same way other insects do.

    I've never seen thrips, they sound horribly mobile, Minty. I'd be tempted to swipe the buggers with a powerful vacuum cleaner. All the jumping and flying make them worse than armored scales which at least do not fly about very far (the young do jump) and I don't even bother with those anymore, I just ditch them and plant they rode in on.

    Pagan

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Bti works on fungus gnats, but IIRC, on larvae, not on flying adults. Different strains of Bt works on different insects - there are about 1000 different strains of Bt. For FG, Bti is the strain used. (I was surprised to find out that until 1977, only 13 Bt strains were described. Other subspecies of Bt has been discovered since then.)

    ..."Bt has to be eaten to cause mortality. The Bt toxin dissolve in the high pH insect gut and become active. The toxins then attack the gut cells of the insect, punching holes in the lining. The Bt spores spills out of the gut and germinate in the insect causing death within a couple days"...

    Some other ways to control larvae: diatomaceous earth; potato slice; layer of grit or sand on surface of soil; cinnamon powder; hydrogen peroxide; beneficial nematodes. IMO, best way is to make sure there is no water sitting around, plants are not over-watered (moist soil is heaven for FG), and as little organic matter as possible.

    To get rid of flies (adults), I have used vinegar (actually, I use it on fruit flies, since I do not have problem with FG): not to spray, just put some in a dish or cup. Take small plastic bag, cut one corner off to create tiny hole - only big enough for fly to get in. Put this over the container with vinegar creating a small 'crater', secure with a rubber band. Flies are very attracted by vinegar, will fly inside -can't escape back out- and will drown.

    Or use yellow sticky traps.

  • 3 years ago

    Neem oil can be dangerous. I used it on a plant near my edible portulaca, then forgot to rinse the portulaca and poisoned myself. The neem oil seems to have destroyed my gut biome. It took about 6 months of probiotics to correct. Neem oi is "potentially toxic and can cause metabolic acidosis, seizures, kidney failure, encephalopathy and severe brain ischemia in infants and young children" wiki. In a separate case it caused blindness. The warning is on the label. It just didn't occur to me that it was a problem since I had seen it was in Indian toothpaste. The poison is the dose, I guess.


Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations