I totally agree the surround does not work , get a reclaimed wood piece for a mantel if you must have one. IMO a piece of art on the stone is all you need

I would like to recommend painting the fireplace surround to unify it with the stone more. What are your thoughts ?

Mark, have you been in hiding?

I appreciate the feedback! I was hoping to just put up a big piece of art and call it a day

I realize I will probably have to do something more significant at some point; I am intrigued by the idea of painting the surround though.

Love Mark's idea. I would also eliminate the iron artwork to the right and just go on finding art you love for the mantel.

Ruining stone with paint does not formalize it to harmonize with that mantle. You need to pick one or the other style direction, and eliminate the clash. Either the stone, or the white mantle surround has to go. Then a big piece of art.

What color what would you suggest I paint the mantle? Also any suggestions on shape and size of the art work? Thank you thank you!!!

Sophie Wheeler if you are referring to my comment I did not suggest painting the stone at all. The mantle does look better painted.

I'm happy to suggest a size for art, but honestly, this is the prime spot in the room, so you should pick something you really love to be the star. If you aren't sure of your taste, go to one of the large online art sources and page through the botanicals and similar (landscapes? abstracts?) to find something that clicks.

I don't see your stone as being rustic, nor do I think the mantel is too formal. If the wall was done in fieldstone or some other large, irregularly-shaped stone and the surround had fluted pilasters, dentil or egg and dart molding and/or cherubs, then I'd be concerned.

While I think a wood beam would look better, I don't the current mantel is bad and I don't think it is worth changing at this time. But it is way too bright white. I agree that painting it would be a big improvement. And a big piece of art will help, too - I really like acm's suggestions.

I agree painting the mantel area is a good idea to try before extending time and expense into something else. How about considering a gray color i.e.: 2 shades darker (in a satin or semi-glass sheen) than the walls if those are the tones in other areas of your space?

I agree with bizideas. Paint mantel 2 shades darker than Revere Pewter in a satin/semigloss and find something botanical to be the star of the room.

carriebear28....my 2 cents...take it or leave it. I would remove the mantel if underneath is the stone and put it a nice big beam. If the mantel is easily removed without hurting the stone underneath, then you are not looking at a lot of money. The mantel, even if painted doesn't fit the stone look. I think because it is in the center of attention, it calls out for fixing.