Software
Houzz Logo Print
pstantonlong

Am I doing something wrong, or is it just bad luck?

9 years ago

My first attempts at growing dwarf conifers seems to be a bust. Late last fall I planted a schoodic pine in well prepared soil; a mix of mason sand and screened topsoil and humus from my woods. The plant was mailed from a NW nursery, very small just a scion on a root stock maybe 5 " high and wide. Did not survive my z4 winter here in the NE. Another dwarf P. sylvestris 'Little Brolly' from the same source looks very poor this spring. Same soil and conditions.

Any thoughts - suggestions from you successful dwarf conifer growers?

Comments (14)

  • 9 years ago

    you should plant in native soil. .after bare rooting the plant ... with adjustments for soil type ... and then.. proper watering and good mulching ....


    see link ..


    i cant tell from your facts... but the fastest thing i learned when starting.. is to not invest in first year grafts ... i learned to let the grafter/grower run the first winter risk ... wherein many die .... were yours what might be called.. fresh grafts???


    what is your native soil???


    ken

    https://sites.google.com/site/tnarboretum/Home/planting-a-tree-or-shrub

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    buying fresh grafts is always a crap-shoot. Many die within the first couple of years for no particular reason. Best chance of success is to stick with 3rd-year or older grafted conifers.

    If cost is an issue, buy them young; pot them up and babysit them for a couple of years. Planting out a fresh graft is always a risky venture.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Pot planting is huge challenge. One condition goes wrong it can kill the plant.

    Your soil combo seems ok. I do not see anything wrong with it. What might go wrong is the cold-hardiness in your zone and the size of the pot. The bigger pot is better in a colder zone. Secondly, make sure the plant itself can take the lowest cold temp in the zone.

    Ken - as well most Garden Centers and plant experts - recommends to use native soil but I beg the difference when it comes to pot planting. While it is 100% true that you better use the native soil for those in the ground, it is not true for pot planting. Why? because you are forcing your plant to live in a controlled soil conditions. The first concern is the soil type. If is it not airy and well-drained then you kill it. If your soil acts like a temp conduit during summer or winter then you kill it.

    The soil condition, pot size, zone hardiness where the plant can survive is another major concern, how often you need to water the plant, is it more often in summer than the spring.. how about spring frost...

    You will find out all these via try and error but not until you already spent a lot money to learn an expensive lesson.

    The best place to reduce the risks of killing your plants is to talk to your local nursery. Keep in mind that not all of them know well how to raise dwarf conifers in pot. Make sure you find a person that knows this thing well.

    Our conifer hobby is quite exotic and expensive too. But that the price we have to pay to get what you love.

    Only a handful of people like us on this planet. We look at a conifer and then we go... wow... waaaa.....ahhh... umm..... and we can look at it for hours without being tired.

    Is that weird?

    It is getting weirder when your wife is threatening to leave you for good. Reason? You did not spend enough time with her. All day long, all moth long and all year long, day and night the only thing you want to talk to your wife is your conifers.. even when you and your wife is on vacation.....

    Sometime I think my previous life was a dwarf conifer. If not, then why I love them so much?

    Yak!

    Good luck!

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks all for your input; I'll try to respond in order and post an image, first time so we'll see.

    Ken; Yes to the native soil although amended with sand and some leaf-mold from my woods, we have clay soil. No I did not bare root the plants. Planted late fall so moisture has been abundant since they have been in the ground.

    Could be they were both first year grafts. Very small and I paid $25 each.

    Conifer K; I may give containers for the first couple of seasons a try. Thanks.

    bamboo_nuts; Appreciate your enthusiasm! These plants are not in pots, in my naivete I planted them directly in the intended permanent location in the garden. P. sylvestris, aka scots pine does well here, at least the species, schoodic is a jack pine which grows in Schoodic, Maine so also should be hardy here. Really not a container growing enthusiast but if needed

    in order to get them ready for the garden I will do it.

    "Only a handful of people like us on this planet. We look at a conifer and then we go... wow... waaaa.....ahhh... umm..... and we can look at it for hours without being tired.

    Is that weird?"

    Maybe it is weird, but for sure a beautiful thing!

  • 9 years ago

    Images

    Little Brolly

    Little Brolly, then Schoodic Pine, then the site. Little Brolly is to the right of the second step. Schoodic is in the patch of green above the central stone.

  • 9 years ago

    I love the stone steps. The Little Brolly got new growth. I think it's ok. Schoodic was already gone.

  • 9 years ago

    Late last fall I planted a schoodic pine in well prepared soil

    ===>>>>

    i read that as planting in the ground.. with amended soil.. when did the facts morph into growing in pots???


    clay plus sand is close to cement .. sand does not increase drainage ... i hope you read the link ..


    my best guess.. those rocks heated in winter sun ... and stressed cold dormant needles ... plus all the other stresses of course ... plants do not appreciate ging in and out of dormancy all winter long ....


    please go to your members page.. and add your location so it shows up on every post and reply ...


    the problem with pots is winter storage ... it is not easy.. especially the further north you go ... and potting media is the most important thing in the pot ...


    second pic.. its dead ...


    ken



  • 9 years ago

    Ken; thanks for your reply. Starting to see that it is probably a case of my doing something wrong, more that bad luck. Read the TNArb. link, good. I've been planting trees here in Southern Tier NY, near PA border for about 20 years now. Mostly bare root from our state nursery and in the spring, and lately plugs also, some times in the fall. So mostly they go straight in the ground; plugs just in a dibble hole, and bare root with a planting bar. But these are all tough trees proven for my area and most do survive. Have read and new most of this stuff, but get lazy, complacent maybe. The things I've been planting are forgiving of that.

    Dwarf conies and garden conie cultivars are a new experience for me, so I'm down low on the learning curve.

    About sand added to clay, at a low percentage yes cement, but up around 1:1 does seem to drain pretty well.

    Our clay, at least subsoil, is so impermeable that all that is need to have a pond here is to dig a hole!

    Not quite sure how to proceed now, The Little Brolly has some life in it but I am not pleased with the brown needles. I guess I'll wait and see how it does. I knew schoodic was dead. Should I try again, spring plant with a more mature schoodic?

    Don't know how containers got in the picture, I want my plants in the ground not in containers. Except for the propagation stage.

    Doubt they broke dormancy, under the snow most of the winter in this cold place.

    Just planted a blue shag P. strobus hope I don't kill that too. And the birds nest spruce rooted cuttings... and ... and ...

    Stanton



  • 9 years ago

    depth of planting is real important,,,try to spread roots out

    ron

  • 9 years ago

    Hey plantkiller;

    Yes, I check the soil line , keeping it at or a bit below what it was in the container.

    Looking thru a list of planting does and don't from the TN Arboretum, thanks to ken for the link in this thread, I see several things I transgressed on.

    1.) I planted late in the fall; I think sometime in December. Certainly the plants had no time to root. Possible the ground froze and they could not take up water. Frost heave may have been an issue as well. I plant trees in the field this time of year often with good results, but usually the snow cover keeps the ground from freezing. But the stones and steps where these were planted is a different condition.

    2.) I did not bare root the plants sufficiently.

    3.) I did not mulch the plants.

    4.) The soil was amended with a lot of organic material.

    The rocks and steps in the planting site create something like a container conditions. I suppose the soil is much more likely to freeze than the soil in a field or garden bed.

  • 9 years ago

    also a baby plant in that ground cover might struggle

    also underlying soil may not drain well,,,what's under the rocks(which I love,,very artistic)

    ron

  • 9 years ago

    The rocks function as a retaining wall along the east side of the house. They were set during the sitework for the house. The bank was probably mostly disturbed earth, subsoil as is typical of most home construction sites. They were set with a backhoe with a little crushed stone under to help position them. They sat like that for nearly 17 years. Last spring I finally got around to planting. During those 17 years I had been dumping organic material in among the stones. I dug everything out to about a foot deep, went into my woods and dug topsoil and screened it, mixed it with mason's sand about 1:1 and the organic material and backfilled between the rocks about a foot deep maybe more in some spots. I planted mostly juniper and some yucca, the GC is sedum. So under it all is the clayey subsoil but on a good slope which drains to the pea stone surrounding the house and eventually to footer drains. The junipers and yucca like pretty sharp drainage and they seem to be doing alright so far.

    I think I'll do a perc test on the spot where I planted poor old schoodic.


    ron, Don't kill any plants!

  • 9 years ago

    you got a good start,,,keep trying ,,,I do

    ron

Sponsored
Innovative & Creative Custom Closet Designer Servicing Franklin County