Software
Houzz Logo Print
antlersinautumn

Pumice alternative?

Since pumice isn't too easy to find locally for me I have been thinking about possible, easy to access alternatives for it....one idea I had that I have yet to test out involves terracotta pots. If I were to get the smallest size TC pots/trays and break them up a bit do you think it would work like pumice would in a succulent soil mix?

I couldn't really find much information on the subject so I welcome all opinions/suggestions on this.

Comments (25)

  • 9 years ago

    Thank you, mayo that thread is extremely helpful and I have saved it for future reference :) , but I couldn't find the answer to my main question on there... I'm trying to experiment with terracotta pieces (sort of like the expanded clay pebbles except jagged). I'm just curious if anyone else has done something similar.

    So far I have not actually used this method with any of my plants because I don't have any I'd be willing to use as a guinea pig, but I do test my mixes in small pots (with no plants).

  • 9 years ago

    I would think that would be extremely labour-intensive and somewhat costly with a relatively small yield of useful aggregate, personally...but perhaps worth a small batch for experimentation :)

    My mom uses smashed terracotta as filler in the bottom of large patio planters. Large chunks at the bottom with a drain tray punched full of holes over top, then she fills it with soil and plants.

    When I was looking for pumice, somebody at the pet store suggested buying pumice stones, like for your feet or the ones for rodents, and smashing them up. I ixnayed that pretty quick as a bad job.

    kd

  • 9 years ago

    I actually thought about the whole pumice stone for feet thing, but was unsure if it was suitable because a lot of times beauty products can be processed with extra chemicals/fragrances/etc.


    And yes it would be tons of work to do for a big batch, but I'm only thinking of using it for a smaller batch just for succulents that need extra fast drying soil.

  • 9 years ago

    Agreed about the beauty products, but I'd like to think the ones at the pet store for live animals wouldn't have anything added to them.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Yes that's true that pet store ones would probably be on the safer side. I'll have to check out local pet stores to see if they carry any pumice rocks/products.

  • 9 years ago

    To help answer your question about smashing terracotta pots, I don't think it is practical to get it small enough to be useful for a soil mix.

    If you manage to break into even small chunks, they are just useless filter. The water held will be minimal and space wasted because no roots can grow there.

    The pieces should be around 3/16" each. Bigger than that would not be very helpful.

    Antlers In Autumn thanked ewwmayo
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I can't tell where in the country you are. If in the US, often Bonsai suppliers have pumice.

    Why not use the perlite as many of us do?

    I believe I read in some of the results in Mayo's link above, they were found to have comparable water holding capacity.

    I use both, perlite mixed into in my houseplants like tropicals, & pumice mixed in w/ my succulents & Hoyas since I had a great pumice source.

    Mayo, I hadn't seen that before, or perhaps not read the detail. Super useful, thanks for sharing all that. Glad one can call this back up & re-visit it, having missed it earlier.

    Edited to correct 'why note' to 'why not', sorry.

  • 9 years ago

    Where do you live? I've bought the last couple of bags of pumice from our local garden supply who opened a new hydroponics section. It's about $17.50 plus tax, but is a pretty large bag and has very little waste once sifted. Only problem is that I went back to buy more (I bought the only two they had at the time) and he said they're on back order. I emailed Lexi at global pumice and she said their 15 lb bag ($25 w/ free shipping) "ranges from 3.5-4.5 gallons of product". After sifting the pumice I bought locally I got approximately 28 quarts, or 7 gallons, of product (although I did include largest pieces in that). I was really hoping they would be a good alternative, but that's just too much. Shipping must cost a fortune though, so I'm sure that's why. They do also sell a product called Dry Stall that is the same exact thing, but cheaper. I am not certain of the particle size although I've read people commonly using that as a substitute for horticultural pumice. Dry Stall is mainly only available on the west coast and is for horses (not the same product as Stall Dry).

    I asked where you live because I've been wondering if it would be possible to have a shipment sent to the east coast to distribute. I know there's demand -- just not sure how close people are. I've also

    seen people paying close to $50 a bag for turface, but we have it here in Tallahassee, FL for $11 for 50 lb bags. We need a big supply swap somewhere!

  • 9 years ago

    Karen - Exactly why I linked the thread. =)

    If I run across any other good components, I'll be adding them to the table.

  • 9 years ago

    @Karen I do use perlite in my soil mixes this was just a question about a possible experiment that's all. :)


    I only compared the terracotta to pumice because to me it seems more similar to that than the perlite. And yes I live in the US (Georgia currently), but I don't think there are any local Bonsai suppliers around where I am. I will check it out as soon as I can though.

  • 9 years ago

    Sorry Antlers,

    I didn't see mention that you DO use perlite. You're in the South?

    I seem to recall mention of pumice sold found under the name Dry Stall or Stall Dry used w/ horses as bedding.

    Hum ... let's see if this works, I just found it, Dry Stall is what you want:

    http://www.pacificbulbsociety.org/pbslist/2012-April/o1hajje6fbelappkalaurtl965.html


    HTH = hope this helps.


    Antlers In Autumn thanked Karen S. (7b, NYC)
  • 9 years ago

    @Karen it's okay I don't think I mentioned that I did use perlite (or anything else) in this thread before my last comment.

    Thanks for the info! I didn't really think to check about pumice under other possible names. I always go in places thinking employees will know about things, but so far even ones that work in garden places have claimed to never even heard of pumice or even horticultural sand. I had one actually recommend polymeric sand claiming it was a good option for potted plants. *sigh*

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks! If I still can't find any at local feed supply stores or pet stores I'll get in contact with them about local carriers.

  • 9 years ago

    I wouldn't look for pumice at pet stores, don't think they handle it. I've recently gone to pet stores for bark mix.

    I'd contact General Pumice first as they're likely to supply most of the stores you're likely to try. I'd imagine it'd save you time & legwork to ask them first especially since they're online as well.

    Antlers In Autumn thanked Karen S. (7b, NYC)
  • 9 years ago

    That Lechuza result surprises me as well. It contains slow release fertilizer. I wonder if its a coating applied to the "rocks" or separate pieces.


    A somewhat similar alternative is zeolite which can be had as a product for aquariums. At least when I have found it, it isn't inexpensive but If you're doing a few plants or smaller ones, its not bad.

  • 9 years ago

    I am interested In hearing more about people's experience using the zeolite. I have seen this for sale in some garden centres.

    from my first click in a quick Google search:

    Hmmmmmmm

  • 9 years ago

    Lechuza Pon is very good. The fertilizer is in the form of time-release balls, like Osmocote or something similar. A big tub is way cheaper than anything for aquariums.

    General Pumice Products is also excellent. Low dust and fines, well sifted/graded. Shipping is pretty cheap within the US considering you are essentially mailing rock.

  • 9 years ago

    The US Lechuza site lacks the description of the fertilizer that's on non-US Lechuza sites. I'd guess that's some regulatory issue. I've got a couple small bags in the basement. In the morning I'll have to take a closer look.

  • 9 years ago

    If you don't want the fertilizer in LP, unless you are potting up lots of plants, you can easily pick them out. They are the yellowish apricot little balls.

  • 9 years ago

    If you have a feed store close by you might want to check if they carry a product called Dry Stall ( mentioned above). It's used to keep horse stalls dry and clean but it's pumice. An alternative to pumice that I prefer myself is scoria. I can't find it in my area. Maybe you'll be in luck and find it in yours. It's basically very tiny red lava rocks so it's the same as pumice just a nicer color.

  • 9 years ago

    You can buy a 15 pound bag from GPP listed above, for $25 including delivery.


  • 9 years ago

    Have you done that yourself Manuel? If not, perhaps we could split a bag?

  • 9 years ago

    I ordered from them last year, and still have enough. Don't be afraid thinking it's going to be a huge barn sized bag. It fits nicely into one of those premade usps boxes