Software
Houzz Logo Print
mblan13

No vinegar for adjusting Ph?

9 years ago

Due to the high tap pH of my water, I was adjusting to around pH 5.5 to 6 using 5% vinegar. I read a study that said to never use vinegar, but did not state a reason.

It said to use sulfuric, nitric, or phosphoric acid, but again, gave no reason why, nor did it state a % solution to use.

The only thing I was able to find was a recount of someone using vinegar in hydroponics that stated that the "mother" of the vinegar can react with sugars in the fertilizers and cause a "slime" in the nutrient solution reservoir.

Is that just a hydroponic thing?

Anyone else ever hear not to use vinegar to adjust pH?

Comments (9)

  • 9 years ago

    Vinegar will lower pH but is not a good buffering solution. You may feel better by seeing a lower measurement on your water but once it's added the effectiveness is quite poor.

  • 9 years ago

    ooooohhh, I love the battery acid suggestion … NOT

  • 9 years ago

    All I can say is that it brought my Daphne back from brink. I will post pic later. But after 1 year without any leaves I finally see leaves coming out after I started adding vinegar to watering can.

  • 9 years ago

    True, hydro is a whole different game, but what i failed to add was that the article that the slime, or yeast and bacteria may be forming in the soil and on root surfaces as well...basically where air touches a water. Does it hinder nutrient uptake, or possibly even help?

    Just Started, Glad your Daphne came back! How long has it been that you have been using the vinegar solution? I would be interested how it performs long term.

    I would rather use white vinegar as well, as it is safer and cheaper, but I'm used to working with chemicals, so it's not a big deal to me. Use gloves and eye protection!

  • 9 years ago

    @mblan I had nothing to lose. Those Daphne's were at the point of being pulled out and thrown away. I have been using vinegar for around 2 months now. The Daphne's are in 511 mix and I add vinegar at very weak strength. One cap of vinegar and one cap of plant food in 9 liter can !!!

    Idea is not to make the mix acidic. Rather I want water to be acidic enough to temporarily allow the plant to take in plant food. After a few hours I guess the acidifying property of vinegar would be gone anyways.

    PS: I am bad at chemistry.

  • 9 years ago

    New growth on Daphne thanks to 511 and vinegar based fertigating.

  • 9 years ago

    I've been using Sulfuric acid. They sell it as drain cleaner at your local Ace Hardware store as 'Liquid Fire' Also other places like NAPA.

    I'm pretty sure I'm more careful with it than your average yutz using it to clean his plumbing. Eye protection, long pants, gloves, acid to water instead of vice versa.

    Six capfuls, 60 ml, in an old 1.75 liquor bottle if water makes a solution of a little over 3% acid. About 1.5 times stronger than vinegar. Four capfuls of that from the jug into a 5 gallon bucket takes my tapwater into blueberry range.

    No, you wouldn't expect that alone to acidify your soil. Just kind of maintain.

    PS. I wouldn't think of using this on my pipes. Only things I eat.



  • 9 years ago

    You can also use phosphoric acid, which can be bought from beer home brewing stores relatively cheap. It is used for lowering the pH of sparge water (water used to rinse the remaining sugars from the grains once the wort has been drained.)

    Hmm, for some reason I'm getting VERY thirsty all of a sudden!

    The auto parts store was closer.