Software
Houzz Logo Print
ujwolfe

Propagating

9 years ago

I can only get my succulent leaves to grow roots. They have looked like this for about 3 weeks. I can never get my green echeveria leaves shown here as well to grow anything!! I have left them on succulent soil dry. I have only watered rarely once I saw roots. Has this happened to anyone else?? Will I grow leaves after this long.

Comments (14)

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    have you used any root creams? you can make your own with honey if you dont want to buy any.

  • 9 years ago

    No I have not tried that. I will try the honey. I have literally been growing these for almost 3 months.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    after 3 months i think it is stunted indeffinitely, but then again if the roots seem healthy you might as well keep trying.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I never used any rooting 'stuff' for leaves. Most will grow roots and plantlets - some will grow only roots - some will grow plantlet and no roots and some will not grow at all.

    uj

    You have pretty good roots on at least some of the leaves, and 3 weeks is not that long. They still may grow.

    Here is copy of what I posted on another thread:

    There are many different ways ppl root the leaves - my method is: forget about them :) What I mean by that, is not to be 'helicopter mom' and constantly fuss about them, over water, overspray, lift/disturb all the times to see if they are rooting...

    Leaves could be just laying on surface of mix. Or stuck in it. Many will root without any soil - here is photo (again!) of the leaves that were left sitting on a saucer; I left them there on purpose to be able to show how they grow without soil and water - I am not saying they should be 'tortured' like this, and probably not all plants will respond this way (2 different plants); I am just showing that they need to be hovered over:

    (Photo above was just taken now, and I have showed the progress before.)
    They should be kept in bright spot but not in strong sunlight. They should have good air circulation. And above all, should not be constantly disturbed.

    Mother leaf has lots of moisture and that is usually enough for roots and/or plantlet to start growing. Mother leaf should be left on until it is 'spent' - it will eventually dry up, shrivel and detach.

    I don't water or spray them until the mother leaf is almost gone. They are more-or-less ignored, so they can do what they want to do. Not all of the leaves will grow, and some plants are more difficult than others. Some will not propagate from leaves at all. It doesn't happen overnight, some will grow in days, some will take weeks or even months.

    Nik finds pachies difficult - I don't. It may depend on species, maybe climate/temps - I don't know.

    I usually pot them up into their own pots when bigger and container gets crowded - now I wait even longer before doing it than I did when photo below was taken:


  • 9 years ago

    goblin, what is this root creams? Is the purpose of it to form more roots? ...or nourishment to help a cutting develop the plantlet? ...or is it like rooting hormone? Make your own with honey and what else? Never heard of root cream. Sounds interesting.

    Tyler

  • 9 years ago

    Ok thx. Just don't want to throw in the towel but don't know if I will ever get leaves

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Four words That have crammed down my throat my whole life. Patience is a virtue;).

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I'm no expert at this for sure, and I've also had some that didn't seem to go past roots. But I did notice that once I put them under a grow light for an hour or so a few days a week, many of mine really took off. Leaves and stems just appeared after being inactive for so long. I just bought the only bulb offered in the bulb section at our Home Depot (so nothing fancy), put it in a desk lamp I already had, and it was great. I think maybe it was around $10. I had them sitting on top of gritty mix and would just spray with a light mist of water every week or so. It may be worth a try!

  • 9 years ago

    Thx everyone! Will continue to be patient!!

  • 9 years ago

    UJ,

    Pls. know that every time one picks up a leaf to check its progress, it disrupts the new roots one is trying to make grow.

    The best new indicator of something having rooted is the appearance of new growth. After that one can move the leaf to plant it & also can water a bit too.

    Otherwise, am sorry to tell you it is still a waiting game.

  • 9 years ago

    I had the opposite problem! Most of mine would not grow roots but instead leafs. Most of them weren't set on soil though. Rocks if anything. I had them outside until it was too hot. They stretched because they were inside. Just recently ive had success with roots but they are now set on soil. And some I used rooting hormone powder. A lot of them I have had for months also. But they are very slowly growing. I water them once a week with or without leafs until I see roots. Then two or three days I spray the roots. I think setting them on rocks or a clay pot may help. I believe rooting hormone has helped some of mine grow leafs that hadn't yet. I experiment a lot lol

  • 9 years ago

    Ok thx Obi

  • 9 years ago

    I've found that the Echeveria nodulosa leaves take a much longer time than others. I've successfully started plants but they were rooted leaves for many weeks before anything happened. One even almost completely filled a 1.5" pot with roots before I saw the plantlet emerge.

    kd

  • 9 years ago

    Ok thx!!