Software
Houzz Logo Print
sara_stredulinsky

Defensive Behavior in Christmas cactus?

So, a bit of background: some of my desk plants have bugs.

Just the Christmas cactus and spider plants. The Boston fern, golden ball cactus, and bromeliad have all stayed bug-free despite sharing a cubicle for over a year. I'm not sure who brought the bugs, but I'm pretty confident they're thrips. They look very much like these:

http://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/Portals/0/Gardening/Gardening%20Help/images/Pests/Thrips_Indoors387.jpg

I'll take advice on dealing with them, but brutally murdering them with my bare fingers seems to be working out pretty well. I also dusted them with some diatomaceous earth which may or may not be helping. Either way, I can go almost a week without spotting any before (I assume) a new generation hatches and I spend a couple of days picking off 10-20 of them.

But with that out of the way, I've noticed a fascinating behavior from my Christmas cactus. It's doing pretty well despite the bugs (though they leave some nasty scars), and it's only dropped a few leaves in the past few months. Without fail, every time I pick up one of these leaves there is a bug on it, or evidence of being nibbled on if the leaf dropped over the weekend. So I'm assuming that what's happening is that the attacked leaf is sending chemical signals of being under attack and if the damaged leaf is an end leaf, then the plant jettisons it like a reverse escape pod. I could be wrong, but it seems like too strong a correlation just to be coincidence (and seems less likely that thrips would be especially attracted to dropped leaves).

Has anyone else observed similar behavior in a Christmas cactus?

Comments (16)

  • 9 years ago

    No. Sorry, but I think there may be drainage problems under your CC & that's what's making it shed a segment or 2 from time to time.

    I'd guess it's nothing like your last paragraph suggests, I believe that is more coincidence &/or drainage problems.

    Personally I'd either get rid of the buggy plants or actually treat them for it, not just leave them.


  • 9 years ago

    I would spray the plants with insecticidal soap, under and over the leaves- except the cactus. The cactus would need to be moved away from the super sunny spot while it's being treated- because spraying it with insecticidal soap and putting it in the window right away, it would make the leaves soft. Do the spray a couple times, spaced between a week or two. I wouldn't leave the bug situation as is, because there is no point in letting them damage a plant. Then after you're done you can move the cactus back to it's spot.

    But yes, I am sure the plants have some type of defense, and to heal, that is the amazing part about nature in general. Plants can be quite resilient. If it were me, I would rather nurture and see what the plant's potential is, by giving it the best conditions possible.

    You have excellent lighting conditions- why not test something like this- I have found that the plants in one room do better if I leave the radio on. No joke, it really is true. It's my quarantine room for new plants, or if I think something is wrong with a plant I will set it in that room. And that room isn't super great lighting. So I put them near the window and turn on the radio, and boom- they're happy happy.

    If you're competitive, you could have other co-workers be in charge of who could make the best mini-garden around each of the pots. Then when judged, whoever had the best mini-garden would get a lunch paid by the other competitors.

  • 9 years ago

    Karen: The CC drains well. The water you see under it is just for humidity, but the pot itself isn't resting in the water, it's sitting on an upturned pot tray. I never let the tray fill enough to touch the bottom of the pot.

    Lily: I'd certainly like to eliminate the bugs completely! Research into eliminating thrips was a bit frustrating, because apparently a lot of typical treatments don't work well for them, and systemic pesticides work best, but aren't available in Canada. It probably can't hurt to try the soap, though! Every little bit helps. I do have shadier areas in my cubicle that I can put the CC on soap days, like where my Boston fern is:

    (This is a thinly veiled excuse to show off the big green fluff that started out not much larger than my fist.)

    Are there any particular soap recipes or brands you'd recommend?

    I already know I have at least the most prolific spider plant on the floor. :D The round pot is last summer's spiderlings, and the 'mama' plant in the square pot made, like, 20 more this summer:

  • 9 years ago

    I use the brand, "Safer" insecticidal soap. That stinks you cannot get a systemic. Your fern looks awesome :)

  • 9 years ago

    Yeah! I'm not entirely sure why there aren't systemics available for houseplants locally but they definitely aren't. Possibly they're banned. But at least Safer's insecticidal soap is available! :) So I'll try that out, and maybe try to get my hands on blue sticky traps.

    Thanks for your help! :D

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Just curious, does Amazon do it's thing in Canada? We find all manner of stuff on Amazon that we don't know how to buy otherwise in the US.

  • 9 years ago

    No systemic insecticides on amazon.ca and I'm not sure I should try and order from outside of Canada in this case, on the chance that it's a banned substance, haha.

  • 9 years ago

    I just wanted to mention that you should move all of your plants out of direct sun while they are being treated, not just the cactus

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Sara,

    How about you try something simple?

    Go to your local hardware store or garden center & ask them about remedies to treat insects on your plants. Take one of the damaged leaves w/ insects (in plastic bag) to a local nursery & ask them about it, remedies & treatments.

    I don't know thrips. It's best to be sure what the insect is before determining treatment.

    How do you know the CC drains well? What kind of mix is it in? It looks a bit pale, like it's not drinking well.

    CCs aren't really direct sun plants, that great light off the reflective water may be a bit much for it.

  • 9 years ago

    Andrea: That makes sense, since even plain water sprayed on plants in full sun can be harmful.

    I tracked down one of the products on that list and it looks like systemics might be controlled substances, as it was labelled: "Product is for commercial and pest control use only and cannot be sold to the public."

    So I'm guessing they're only available to the agricultural industry or similar. None of the regular stores (Home Depot, Kent, etc.) sell them

  • 9 years ago

    Is it extremely dry where the plants are for you to need to leave water for 'humidity?'

    Water sitting in saucer will only attract more bugs. It doesn't really produce any humidity. For that, you would need much more than a saucer. I have holiday cactus that spends summers outdoors and winters indoors without any extra humidity being supplied.

  • 9 years ago

    Karen: I can try that next time it drops one! It happens very rarely. More when there were slightly more bugs, but the population has really dropped since I started aggressively picking any I spotted and dusting with diatomaceous earth. Like I say, I can go days without seeing any on any of the plants now, or fresh feeding scars.

    The CC is in an African Violet potting mix at the moment. Not perfect (next time it's repotted I'll add in some perlite), but well draining. I water it when the top 1-2 inches of soil are dry, until water runs out the bottom.

    It may be getting too much light! Some of the newest leaves on the primary sun-facing side have been showing slight pinking, so I've been thinking about moving it.

    @Rina: It can get extremely dry at work, especially in the winter. In the summer the tray can fully evaporate in a day to a day and a half (I only refill it once it's dry or mostly dry). In the winter it can dry out fully in under 8 hours. A tray is one of the better ways to introduce some more moisture into the air without an actual humidifier, since the water has a lot of surface area where evaporation can take place.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Sara

    If it is so dry, it may be much better to get humidifier - not only for plants, but more for ppl that work there :)

    Pebble tray, as I mentioned, is not as much help as ppl think, especially in open office area. Small amount of evaporated water will just dissipate in there, try probably just dries up rather than supplies any moisture. Read this article - as posted by floral in this thread.

    It is probably much better to get rid of any bugs you have (I wouldn't leave bugs in there if I knew about them); and repot plants into thoroughly cleaned pots with drainage holes, into fast drying and well draining new mix. Your existing soil could be full of bugs and/or their eggs.

    Btw new growth on holiday cacti are very often pinkish or reddish. It is not a sign of too much light.

  • 9 years ago

    Rina: Fair enough! Thank you for that article. You don't find a lot of people actually putting in research time when looking up houseplant care. :) I might actually try the humidity experiment myself, since I think my Arduino kit may have come with a humidity sensor!

    I'd have to ask around about if I'm allowed to bring in a humidifier. My nose and skin would certainly appreciate it in the winter!

    I think I'll try the insecticidal soap and get some sticky traps for monitoring first, and then wash and repot if that doesn't work.

    Good to know about the pinky tips! Do you think it might still be a good idea to drop my sun shades some so that the CC only get indirect sun most of the day? I have my shade at half-height on the side with the spider plants and they seem fairly happy with that.

  • 9 years ago

    Sara

    I am wrong person to ask, since I break too many rules, lol. I have TG cactus I keep in full sun for about 7 years now (it was given to me in a pot with Euphorbia milii that likes full sun) - it bleaches out in summer some, but grows, and blooms. I have few Spring/Easter cacti that are in location with few hrs of morning sun and dappled shade rest of day. And I keep them under light whole winter long. Any that died (I killed-:( were most likely over- or under-watered.

    I didn't have to fight thrips yet, so do not have personal experience. From reading about them, they could be bit tricky to get rid of. It would be #1 job for me to take care of pests.

    I do not know what kind of humidity sensor comes in Arduino kit, but the typical (not expensive) ones sold in any store are probably not worth it. One of our members, ewwmayo, has posted excellent thread on some tools, I believe there is review for humidity sensor there too: - click me please -

Sponsored
CHC & Family Developments
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars6 Reviews
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio