Both too small. Sorry : ) Whatever the width of the floating sideboard, subtract six inches. That's the size/ diameter you want.

I am guessing you need a 36 inch diameter

Although it's a bit small, I like the teardrop mirror. The starburst competes with your hanging fixture.

Thanks all, a while back I was told I should replace the starburst as it didn't really go well in the space, that's why I tried the teardrop.

That was probably a different group of folks who answered. It is all about opinion...Good Luck.

Thanks for your input everyone! Yes shirlpp, it was when I posted about the art. I guess I will leave the starburst unless I find something that looks better and I'm willing to pay the price!