Software
Houzz Logo Print
jdudeck90

Is this too much pruning? (And tree identification)

9 years ago

My landlady had her gardener prune the two big trees in our front yard (against our wishes). He finished today, and I am completely shocked by how much he took off. I'm also upset because these trees shaded the entire front yard, including the front half of the house, and now there is zero shade. I can already feel the difference inside the house - it's at least 4 degrees warmer than when the trees were shading it. I live in Los Angeles, so even though it is technically fall, those 4 degrees are sorely missed.

I don't know much about pruning, so I am trying to understand why he trimmed so aggressively. I have read that you shouldn't take more than a quarter of a tree's canopy off at a time, but I would estimate he took at least 90%. I don't know what kind of trees these are, so I don't know if there is a special consideration for the species or something. I've included pictures of leaves and bark to help with identification. Apparently, the gardener does this heavy of pruning every 2 years, and has done for a long time. This is our first year in the house, so we haven't seen it before.

Based on the pictures, did he prune too much? Are the trees in any danger of dying from this much canopy loss? And, assuming we're here in 2 years when it's pruning time again, do we have any grounds to stand on to request a lighter pruning so that there is still some shade in the front yard?

Comments (7)