Software
Houzz Logo Print
ann_hylton

Flush Mount LED light spacing in dining area

8 years ago

We have a 15x 15 eat in kitchen area that connects to a kitchen (with breakfast bar) which is approximately 15 x 14. We have a beautiful view out the eat in kitchen window area (it is a wall of windows) and we are trying to minimize interruptions in the view and therefore have chosen surface mount lights instead of anything hanging down (example pendant or chandelier type light). I am struggling with whether we have too many lights. We were planning 6 in (or 4 inche) LED flush mount lights. This is a simplistic view of what has been planned. Thoughts? I keep thinking if it is too much, we can put them on a dimmer, but everyone who walks in and sees the electrical states how that is way too many lights, and I don't want it to look silly, but need it functional. This will probably be the main homework hub for our kids. Basically 15 lights in a 15 x 15 space (8 around where the dinner table will be; 7 in the walkway/hallway intermediate zone). The lights are spaced between 32" (about every other TJI- TJI is 16" on center), ceiling is 9 feet tall. We haven't finished electrical yet, so we can still make changes if needed. Thank you for any input.


Comments (7)

  • 8 years ago

    I'd say that's way too many fixtures. How many lumens are they rated at? If they are the relatively common 800 lumen lights, 64" should be close enough, and a dimmer may still be desirable.

    JM$.02W

  • 8 years ago

    I've heard that a good rule of thumb for recessed lighting is to have the spacing be about half the height of the ceiling. So 9 foot ceilings would have an approximate spacing of 54".

    But then you have to take into account task lighting and make adjustments based on that.

    I have to agree with the other people you've talked to. You have too many.

    I also don't think that recessed lighting should be your only source of light. A mix of different types is better. Is there anywhere where a standing lamp that directs the light up onto the ceiling would work? And I doubt that a reasonable size 'chandelier' light over your dining room table would block that much of the view. Just don't make it massive. Pendant lights over the kitchen peninsula might be a good idea too.

    If you do decide to go all recessed, then line them up. The random pattern over the breakfast nook and dining area looks weird to me. 3 rows have 4 lights, one has 3. The row over the dining table with 4 lights has a different spacing than the rows over the nook.

  • 8 years ago

    Claire Larece .. its 15x 15 for the eat in area and 15 x 15 for the kitchen space, so the whole area is 15 wide by 30 long. we have a few lights in the kitchen area, but only about 5 maybe (with under cabinet lighting as well).

    greg_2015 we could possibly do a small chandelier or pendant lights, but we really don't want to. Its a mountain view and I just wanted to keep the sight line as clear as possible. Not anywhere I can think of for a standing light (we have 3 small kids and 2 dogs... so I just see something like that getting knocked over). At 4.5 feet spacing, that would only be 6 lights for the kitchen table/ hall behind the breakfast bar area.. would that be enough? Thanks for all the input.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    9’ walls 30’ long but I would put 15 recess lighting in the entire room Including the pathway. Using 3 or 4 inch than you can add flush mounts where it’s necessary. I would say you need 4

  • 8 years ago

    I suspect that if you install a chandelier or pendants, especially the latter, you won't even notice they're there after a couple of weeks. I don't think they'll spoil your view.

    I'm not a fan of cans. You have to use a lot of them to get even lighting. I prefer lights that cast some illumination upward to reflect off the ceiling and provide even, indirect lighting.

    To me, cans are what you use when you have very LOW ceilings and don't want luminaires intruding on limited human space. They shouldn't be necessary with normal-height ceilings.

  • 8 years ago

    Keep in mind that LEDs, by their nature, tend to be very directional, so you'll end up with distinct pools of light and not good general illumination. I would certainly add some pendants and/or sconces to get some light that isn't pointed straight at the floor.