Software
Houzz Logo Print
jmamchur

should I paint my brick or not? Mid-mod style!

8 years ago
Background:
Mid-mod home built in 1964. Huge fireplace in the middle of the home that is a feature we love (I know, it's not for everyone). Removing it is not an option :-)

We're doing a kitchen re-model (wall w fridge coming down, complete reconfig), replacing all the parquet to hardwood and plan to keep the mid mid style of the home. I'd like to call it "mid mod glam" The hearth in the kitchen will be converted to custom cabinetry (we don't use it). The wall ovens are staying, and we will eventually replace w new one but I just love them.

Now the photos:
-first photo shows the kitchen "as is"
-2nd is my sloppy rendering of white :-)
-3rd is the view from the other side of the fireplace, I quite like it

So should I paint the kitchen brick white? I love the texture of the brick, so either way I will be happy but I want your thoughts :-)

Thank you in advance all you smart Houzz'ers

Comments (29)

  • 8 years ago

    HI -- A big yes to painting the brick a nice warm white . There is a new show on HGTV -- Brother and Sister team last Name Ford . They just showed a Mid Century home with similar features . The end result is a good example of what you could do . They painted the brick a warm white and had wood and white kitchen cabinets with white appliances . It was stunning !!

  • 8 years ago
    Thank you,Lefty47 for your input :-)
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    In this particular case, I would leave the brick. Looks like it works better with the architecture.

    But I would consider appliances in the new Slate Finish. The white ovens in the brick are not attractive.

  • 8 years ago

    yes, paint it. that current brick color is horrid. it's just not the clean, mid-mod you're after. I like the white, but I also love black brick. (you can also use a concrete stain)

    found a similar one to yours,,,this brick is a lot lighter than yours.

    there are so many cool tile options if you get tired of the paint down the road. I'd prob apply these other glazed brick tiles just because I love the look of this so much

    if going w/the painted brick, consider doing the kitchen in this type of style

  • 8 years ago

    I would wait on any painting until after your kitchen remodel is completed. Then live with it for awhile. I would try to keep the brick as is and only whitewash it later if you really don't like the original color with your new kitchen.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    The whole concept of MCM is to use authentic legitimate materials.

  • 8 years ago
    love the brick and it looks perfect for that style. I would leave it. darker appliances on the wall.. it is beautiful. you can always paint it later... but never unpaint it.
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Paint it. You won't regret it and you'll love how bright it will make the entire space.

  • 8 years ago
    I vote to keep it as is until your kitchen is done because like other said, you can’t go back.

    I like the brick as is, but I’m not a fan of the appliances in it. If it was me, I would trim it out and do wood or drywall over the brick to make it look like the ovens are in cabinetry or a regular wall and then leave the brick untouched around the fireplace. If you did that, you could bring the wood to the same level as you kitchen cabinets and then leave the brick on top exposed. Hope that makes sense
  • 8 years ago
    We bought a mid70's ranch style home with a 10' wide, floor-to-ceiling two-sided see-through fireplace dividing the living room from the dining room. It had been painted off-white and was ugly. We had it lightly sandblasted, which removed the paint and left the brick lightly roughened. It is the main feature of the house now. We have transitional furniture, oriental rugs and wide plank medium-toned oak hardwood floors. I wouldn't change a thing.
  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago


    I have a 1956 ranch with a huge fireplace and I thought i would hate it but embraced the stone and left that stone wall in the kitchen with my fange and some stainless cabinets that are moveable on that wall I love it

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    From the warmth of the afternoon sun that comes in on the other side of the brick wall I would recommend painting both sides white for consistentcy. A warm white would allow for a fresh look and if you decide to keep the appliances they will blend while keeping a little of the past intact.

  • 8 years ago

    If you actually like MCM style, I don't see how you could even consider painting it. At the very least wait and decide when the rest is done!

  • 8 years ago
    Patricia your stone is beautiful!! I love what you did in your kitchen and if I had your stone, I wouldn't consider painting it either!
    I have considered moving my range to against the brick wall, and then eliminating the double oven and using a beautiful blue star instead of the thermador cooktop I've selected...it's scary to be so far along and suddenly start rethinking things but....measure twice cut once :-)

    Thanks for your feedback! I appreciate it!
  • 8 years ago

    I would leave it alone for now. I agree with BeverlyFLA re the concept of MCM design. Live with it , I’d really think twice before mucking it up .... I’m going to Modernism Week in Palm Springs next month, So nice to see MCM design embraced rather than destroyed by a misguided attempt to “update” ....

  • 8 years ago
    K Lawrence - that's great that you are going to MCM week! I'm jealous!

    I don't necessarily think that painting brick deviates from MCM style, at least not my version of it.
    Recently I've noticed that sometimes people think "MCM" and "old" are synonymous, which is hilarious to me.

    I'm getting some great responses on here, thanks everyone!
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    A MCM house that has painted the original brick, painted the original wood, and that has removed the original parquet, has lost all touch with what MCM means. Original unremuddled details adds value. Removing and altering those details removes value. You might as well have bought a 90’s McMansion as try to “modernize” that home!

    A home only has valuable original details once. After that is destroyed, its much harder and more expensive to restore it to its former unremuddled state.

  • 8 years ago
    I have a similar fireplace in my living room. My family was against painting the Rick and I allowed them their choice foe over 20 years. I finally painted it a beautiful white and everyone loves it especially me. Wish I had done it ages ago. I am now struggling with your same dilemma in my kitchen. I am leaning toward a white wash to keep some of the charm and to quiet the brick so it doesn't dictate the entire room. Can't wait to see what you do.
  • 8 years ago
    Hi Sophie!
    Thanks for your input. The parquet that was installed is actually not original to the home. I'm restoring the original hardwood in the kitchen by having the parquet removed and replaced w hardwoods, matching the existing.
    The woods long since been stained, I'll be refinishing it... but this post is about the fireplace.
    I don't think that painting it would look like a "90's McMansion" (HA!) but that's ok if you do :-)

    Personally I wish that the original owners (I am the second owner) chose a different, less reddish brick or stone. I feel like I am always fighting that red tone.
  • 8 years ago
    This is the after photo of my living room.
  • 8 years ago
    Fhannon, I completely understand!
    In our previous home, there were things I didn't change because I had fear associated with change itself and not what I in particular like. I didn't listen to myself.
    I'm actually shocked by how many "keep it" responses I'm getting - it's so interesting! But, a photo can only tell so much.
    I'm glad you love your white fireplace! I was looking at a tutorial someone made about painting faux brick paneling to look like brick! So there is a way to "paint it back" :-)

    I too always feel like I'm fighting that warm brick color with my decor. If so much as one red item enters the room, it throws the entire room off!
  • 8 years ago
    Fhannon, it looks gorgeous! Your beams and mantle shine!
    The art piece on the wall is so beautiful also! I love your style.
  • 8 years ago
    You are so nice to like my living room. I don’t regret one bit for painting it. My kitchen brick is a greater challenge design wise. I will take a picture and post.
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    It is hard to give advice without seeing the colors of the new flooring and countertops. Balancing color is important in this large space. I think you should complete your renovation then decide if you want to change it

  • 8 years ago
    My advice is to white wash it first, allowing for some of the authentic brick to perk through. If you don’t like it, paint it straight white. I think the brick looks gorgeous in your living room as is, but I understand it’s not your vision.
  • 8 years ago
    I would update other elements in the kitchen etc and consider a more modern warm grey or white for the walls and not paint the brick. The brick will remain a contrasting element in the house. I think it’s beautiful as it is.
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Wow. I am loving that view out the window in your third picture! What an amazing home. I just purchased (literally, last week) a 1964 mid-century home which I am working to modernize. I have a fireplace which covers an entire wall and its dark and original. I have thought of staining it, painting it, and even completely refacing it with wood paneling. One of the first responses mentioned white washing, which I agree may be a good compromise as you lighten it, without completely covering your brick; however, you can also have a contractor who specializes in brick staining do a stain "touch-up" and make it look new and fresh while maintaining the same color, or even go with a completely different stain color. The wood paneling idea may be my favorite as I think it gives it a true mid-century modern look, but it may actually take me longer to decide on which way to go than it will to actually do the project! I like your fireplace and the color/tone so I would just go with a fresh/new touch-up. I've attached some photo's showing the whitewashing, staining, and wood paneling. I hope they will be of some help to you in making your decision :)

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    You mentioned that you like brick, Jocelyn, just not quite so red. Using the same techniques I out lined earlier, you could change the tone of your brick slightly

    Before:

    In process:

    After:
    Painted brick: