Software
Houzz Logo Print
robineggblue2

Are china cabinets totally yesterday now?

13 years ago
My husband does not like this piece I got from a family member. He did not grow up in houses with lit cabinets displaying china, but I am from the South (he is not), and everyone I know had one. So is this piece really "old-lady" looking? Or is my husband off base? He is not super design savvy and lets me do our homes, but I want to respect his opinion. Give me the truth, please!

Comments (150)

  • 12 years ago
    Just realized you moved. Your furniture is timeless and will go well no matter what house you are in.
  • 12 years ago
    I posted something similar not long ago as I have a lot of china and need the storage space... I also posted something earlier this evening asking for input on painting my china cabinet or not. I've been struggling with the same thoughts- are china cabs outdated? I like your china cabinet and think the room looks very nice (although I agree on not having the blue urns on top of it in your new room). I agree with most of the last responses- the furniture is classic and there's no need to go with the trends.
  • 12 years ago
    Has anyone noticed the chandelier that is plain and modern? I think it makes the china cabinet look worse. Just pick a theme!
  • 12 years ago
    I love being in a home where the furniture has a sense of history about it..as yours certainly does! Prefer it above all others.
    Also love your sofa- reminds me of a George Smith piece?
  • 12 years ago
    Modern look could lacquer the chairs in the deepest blue from the Chinese jars. Can always repaint white when colour trend fades. Go to Pantone 2014 colour family for ideas. I would favour blue and white silk curtains and a Chandelier with clean lines. LB Interiors pics are good, esp patterned curtains. We had very similar/same rug to Alameda Royal Blue. My boy tipped a whole carton of soy milk onto it and we couldn't get all the stain out. Pattern all over would be better for dining room to hide stains. China cabinet good , do up the backboard to resemble a swish jeweller cabinet. Lacquer any inexpensive ornament to match chairs, if using books, make covers in that exact colour, with lettering. Since from the South, look at the hanging lamps made of tea cups and saucers, could use a group of asst blue and white at diff heights. Others will know the other hanging lights repurposed from cut lead crystal decanters, isn't the south famous for good spirits? Again hang in group of varying heights. Have sparkling silver and crystal on the table. The modern trend is repurposing, with a twist, and coordination.. Move out the traditional framed paintings or paint frames to match blue chairs. Half my picture frames are aqua blue at present! Easy to repaint later. Have you a painting or print of a gracious southern lady? Have fun.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Not at all, especially when styled well. It makes for a great beach house feel
  • 12 years ago
    Keep it, it's beautiful!
  • 12 years ago
    Hey, what did you end up doing, gracious southern lady?
  • 12 years ago
    I don't actually care if a china cabinet is out of fashion or not - I need some kind of storage space for things, and if some of the things I have are pretty then I want to see them more often than just when they're in use! Though I find the display cabinet part awkward for dishes that are actually being used - you have to be careful about how you place things so it looks nice, and that can be quite fiddly if you're dealing with multiple place settings. So I tend to keep pieces like vases and particularly pretty serving bowls or platters in the display area - stuff where I'm only likely to take out a few pieces at a time so the cabinet doesn't look empty and I don't have to 're-stage' it every time I use anything.

    (This also means that the china that gets used can go somewhere closer to where it gets washed for easier use and storage.)

    I do try to keep a couple of pieces from my china pattern in the cabinet, so it all ties together when the table is set, but like I said I find if I use serving pieces and other accessories in the display, I rarely use all of them for a meal. (I might want the platter but not the serving bowls, or the teapot and creamer and sugar but not the platter, etc.)
  • 12 years ago
    I did not put this piece in the new dining room. As someone else mentioned, it may actually be more of a hutch secretary. I have it in the living room with some china below and antique books and other things above, so everybody is happy.
  • 12 years ago
    Glad you're keeping the hutch. My family has manufactured and worked in furniture for 40 years and I think I know a fine piece of furniture when I see. It's not out of style, it's a classic. I certainly would treasure it if it were mine.
    To Traditionalguy. Well said. May I add one more name, Pearson, to that prestiged group of furniture lines.
  • 12 years ago
    @ Robin H, pictures please!
  • 12 years ago
    So glad you found a use for that wonderful piece. I love to see hutches used in non-traditional ways. Please do post a pic!
  • 12 years ago
    I love that hutch, so glad you kept it!!
  • 12 years ago
    I will absolutely post pics but not before paint, sconces, and window treatments are done.
  • 12 years ago
    I LOVE your room and your taste. In my opinion china cabinets are old fashioned but you make it work because your piece is painted and unexpected. I think the suites of matching furniture are the ones that really look dated. Please ignore all the stupid advice by amateur decorators who are telling you what "your problem" is. You have a beautiful space there. I think it looks up to date and unique. I love eclectic design and I love rooms that evolve and I love that your room reflects your upbringing in the South (I am Southern too). I also think you mix things up in an interesting way. There is no need to be all neoclassical or all modern as some of the advice here seems to indicate. Your stuff isn't clashing. It is gorgeous. Most people don't know anything about decorating and yet they have so much advice to offer and saddest of all is that people really don't know they are reacting to a photograph not a space.
    Robin L thanked Kathy Tobacco
  • 12 years ago
    This post started last summer-2013. She updated in Dec. saying she would post pics after painting etc! Actually, several very talented designers gave advice. It will be good to see how she executed it.
  • 12 years ago
    Glad you kept it. Won't be regretted, I'm sure.
  • 12 years ago
    It is a lovely piece and nice to have from family. Honestly, I think it doesn't go with the peach wall colour. If you painted the wall colour perhaps a warm white, and changed the art on either side to something a little more contemporary/classic, it could take on a whole new look. Also, if you updated the seat cushions that would also make the room look younger, yet maintaining the elegant feel. Another thought is to paint or wallpaper the inside of the display cabinet. The leopard area rug, for me, doesn't really suite the feel of the room. In style modern has shown a great pic above- neutralize the background, update the soft furnishings and allow the beautiful furniture to stand out. Good luck and have fun
  • 12 years ago
    Being scolded because everyone jumped in on how to decorate and did not read the dilemma is really the dilemma .I like you hutch.
  • 12 years ago
    What about Starsky?
  • 12 years ago
    My father looked like the captain... :-)
  • 12 years ago
    I like the hutch too, it serves a purpose. Just because one person doesn't need it for that purpose, does not make it "old fashioned" come on.. sheesh lol
  • 12 years ago
    Back to the original question....I love my china cabinet, even though it is a big and cherry. I wanted to change it up, tho, so I took the china out (I never used it) and now only have crystal and cut glass pieces, all clear. It is so pretty and sparkly and is especially nice when I turn on the light inside the cabinet at night :)
  • 12 years ago
    This thread is still getting some life, so I thought I would follow up and get advice on the home I am actually living in. : ) I am attaching pics of the new dining room in the new house. Please understand I just took these this morning, and didn't stage the room. I am a work at home mom to toddlers, so I don't have breakables out unless I am entertaining.

    I am struggling with window treatments and the central chandelier. I would like to add something more modern and promote a more transitional, eclectic look to go with all of my hand me down furniture. I will recover the chairs once my kids aren't soaking them every night. (We eat in the dining room). I am not into fussy window treatments. The room is really bright and airy and I want to keep that. The wall and trim color is 50% Tranquility by Benjamin Moore.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Love the cabinet. I would paint the dining set, it does look like grammas.
  • 12 years ago
    I would love to do this 34 inch wide oval drum pendant:
    http://www.stonegatedesigns.com/detail11_2.asp?ID=140&product_name=Classique
    in what color though?
  • 12 years ago
    A nice window treatment would be just plain pinch-pleat draperies, either solid or a strip to pick up colors from your rug. A faux-silk would look lovely, and there is a site which has faux silk constructed the same way as real would be so they look just like the real thing. http://www.halfpricedrapes.com/striped-faux-silk-taffeta-curtains.html
  • 12 years ago
    The cabinet is in the living room more like a hutch. the room is not yet painted, so i am waiting to post.
  • 12 years ago
    Again, for the lampshade, choose a color from your rug, or go with an off-white.
  • 12 years ago
    Drapes are a challenge in this space, as the walls have no symmetry and one window is flush with the built in cabinet. I think it is better to go with a shade of some kind, because the single curtain look not one I am sure about.
  • 12 years ago
    I am updating the shades, too, or switching out for different lamps once the chandelier is up.
  • 12 years ago
    Love the dining room. It looks so elegant and classy blended with a touch of historical colonialism. Your room has charm and a soul.
    Robin L thanked newlifewoman
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    What is your favorite hand-me down piece in the room? I think the pastel print on the door wall is a mismatch for the rest of the room. What if you move the botanical from between the windows to the pastel spot, and then you have room for simple hung drapes on the window wall.

    I actually like naked windows a lot, but it seems most folks like drapes and I think you don't have room for that print there plus drapes.

    Edited: just saw that you are doing shades instead. I think that works.
  • 12 years ago
    Have you considered a relaxed roman shade with subtle pattern and then recovering your chairs in something to coordinate?
  • 12 years ago
    i LOVE beautiful china. and crystal. and silver. and sometimes even silver-plate. i love old beautiful things. i especially love them if they've been handed-down to me. our rustic home offers very little opportunity to display such things, so we always must entertain in order to display. we actually use our lovely things. but if there ever is a new home in our future (????) i'm going to want some kind of platform to display and view all my lovely things now in pantries and storage bins in the shed. if you've got it, flaunt it! that's going to be my next motto :) so, for me, it's a big YESSS on the hutch if you have lovely things to display. but if you have to dig around and go out an procure stuff, then i'd say get rid of it…it's only just one more thing to dust.
  • 12 years ago
    ie: function over fashion
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Thanks for the update. You've done a great job with the room transition. I love that you chose a light bright soft paint color.

    I think you can have the best of both worlds. transitional/modern and traditional if the chandelier has a bronze finish. I think I'd like the richness of bronze used to work with the dark table and balance the richness that is in the room. The shade is modern.

    I don't think you need the artwork on the wall at the left side of the buffet. I think a blank wall is fine. Without it, the mirror will stay focal. The eye will not get confused. I think a bit simpler.

    I think all the art should be moved down. Center of art about 62" from the floor : )
    Robin L thanked LB Interiors
  • 11 years ago
    I love love love hutches...I keep colorful fiesta dishes in mine because I don't own china. I do however have a turqouise hutch to go with my rustic table and buffet. We live in the SW, but I am not a fan of SW design. I want my house to be warm and welcoming as it sounds like you do too, so I say if you love it keep it. The blue pots are quite bright in the picture and I would suggest turning your dining room table 45 degrees.
  • 11 years ago
    Oh now I see the new room. What happened to the hutch. Love the buffet and carpet.
  • 11 years ago
    I think I would rethink the entire room and that chair with the pillow also. Your hubby is right on this one!
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    To answer your question, the China cabinet is not 'old lady-ish"!
  • 11 years ago
    Update your room - Paint the china cabinet black or a fun aged color. Then replace your table with a farm table or cover table with a cream matelasse tablecloth. You can also paint the chairs to match or recover with fun fabric. If you want to keep the table, add a small high back sofa to mix with chairs for a more casual look.
  • 11 years ago
    Animal print on the chair seats would also look great!
  • 8 years ago
    It is all sorts of yesterday.
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    It truly depends on your decorating style. In all honesty, I actually see them making a come back. I see more painted versus stained. I always tell my clients that if you love it, then it's okay to use. You tailor it to fit your most currently design style. If you have any further questions, don't hesitate to ask!

    Cheers! m.

  • 8 years ago

    Sorry Erin, it was all sorts of a five year old post.

  • 8 years ago

    3 Years and 3 months old :) People shouldn't listen to anyone trying to tell them china cabinets aren't in style. They have been in style for decades if not more than 100 years. It seems not until the creation of decorator forums online have people become bored with things quicker. I think the only reason some people these days when starting out may not have the extra room, or money for a 2nd set of dishes.


  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago


    Robin L

    June 9, 2013

    ^^the date of the original post :)

  • 8 years ago

    If i had a traditional decor i would certainly employ a china cabinet! If i had an MCM decor i would too, as there are some verrrrrry cool period pieces of both china and cabinets from the 50s/60s. But, alas, we have a 2 century old house so we kinda have to go with that.. I LOVE collecting china...and to get my ya-yas out using it, i enter an annual Tablescapes competition and show it off that way.


Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County