Software
Houzz Logo Print
cheri127

Would you replace front this door?

8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago

Because of scheduling and lead times, we couldn't use the fantastic shop we wanted to make our front door. We hired another local artisan, who came highly recommended, (same high price) and he delivered us a highly questionable product that we never should have installed, but to stay on schedule, we did.

Shortly after install, in August, the door swelled and wouldn't close. It's spanish cedar and was primed with Kilz. The builder's carpenter trimmed the hinge side of the door and he did a lousy job rehanging it. The door isn't square in the opening and hasn't closed right since. During the winter, the door shrunk back and the handle side was too far from the jamb causing even more problems when closing the door. You could also see daylight, so the weatherstripping at this point was useless. We had the hinges shimmed to center the door in the opening but it's still not square and the weatherstripping needs to be replaced. The door maker has been stalling since September about coming to the site and making this right.

In addition, the door was delivered with the wrong threshold. I have no idea what the man was thinking, but he installed a threshold for an out swing door! This is an easy fix but while measuring for a new, interlocking threshold, I saw that the sill is perfectly level; it doesn't slope to the outside to let water run off. I know the wood is rot resistant and it's painted, adding an additional layer of protection and it's also under a small porch, but this is a beach house so I'm concerned that it won't hold up to the harsh conditions down there.

The question is should we fix the door and live with it's imperfections while hoping the sill doesn't rot? Or should we suck it up and have the door guy we wanted to use make us a new, perfect door? As much as I hate spending the money, I'm more worried about the unintended consequences of removing the existing door and possibly damaging the Hardie artisan siding. Do you think spanish cedar is robust enough last 20-30 years under these circumstances?

I'm most concerned about water pooling where the jamb meets the sill.

Comments (6)

  • 8 years ago

    "I know the wood is rot resistant and it's painted,"

    Doesn't matter much if it is sitting in water, it will rot.

    cheri127 thanked millworkman
  • 8 years ago

    I'm talking to the builder tomorrow. We are waiting for our CO so replacing the door will be outside the contract. I'd still like him do it since he's familiar with how it was installed. I hope he says it can be done with no disruption to the siding. I'm also meeting with the guy who made the door to try to get at least some of my money back. This makes me sad.

  • 5 years ago

    Here we are two years later and I thought I'd follow up. We decided to remove the "flawed" door and install a new one made by the "fantastic shop". HA! The door leaks, the panels cracked and it swings to 180 degrees no matter what. Part fabrication error, part installation error. The only upside is that we paid to have the builder reframe the opening, as per the architect's drawing, so the door is now in scale to the house. Cost us a pretty penny to rectify the builders mistakes! But sheesh! I've learned plenty from the experience...there really wasn't anything wrong with the original door (except that it was too small and that wasn't the fabricators fault) and the new door is worse. Haven't decided what we'll do now but thought I'd update you all. LOL.

  • 5 years ago

    @cheri127, "I've learned plenty from the experience"


    The most valuable thing to the Houzz community would be for you to share what you've learned so others can benefit.

    cheri127 thanked strategery
  • 5 years ago

    One mistake that you made was getting the builders carpenter involved. Should have gone back to the original maker of the door, first.


    Our newly installed manufactured door is unstained for the next few weeks. It is already swelling with cold temperatures, rain and snow. Needs to be stained ASAP. However, I am worried that if we stain it now, it would stay swelled and not shrink back down. Ours came with the wrong color of threshold and hardware (hinges and handle.) Black instead of ORB. Not sure who's fault that is, but it is what it is. I guess it was a blessing. (See below)


    We also had two sets of French doors, as well as a single installed. While the handles are black, the hinges on the doubles are bronze (thankfully, these are outswing doors.) On the single (which is an inswing), the hardware is all black. The doors are in the same room. LOL


    We would love to see your new door...cracks and all!