The SW color card for Caviar is beautiful but when I painted my stair tread, it was really brown. I ended up using Tricorn but I wanted it to read true black and white. The depth of color is very pretty with Caviar but it definitely reads brown/browner. You should test them both and on big sample boards in the light of your home.

We painted our front door Tricorn black and loved it.

Fix your lighting first. You can’t have Acres of black anything without adding lots of extra lighting.

Has anyone used Black Magic? Would like a true black but maybe slightly softer than Tricorn without the brown of Caviar.

Can anyone else offer any input here? Also deciding between these 2 colours and can't find much on Houzz

Ditto to what beachhouselife asked!

We painted our island Tricorn black and there’s a lot of brown undertone. What can I paint over it to get rid of the brown?

I painted my front door caviar and i love it.

Painted my bedroom wall with Caviar! Just yummy!!!