From a designer,,, based on the larger wall I'd put a bench there with pillows on it.

Jan, I love that console table you show, but I do have a cabinet there now (you can hardly see it in the middle picture with the couch. would this pouf work in either orange or green?

https://www.wayfair.com/furniture/pdp/mistana-grimes-pouf-mtna3080.html?piid=22619243

Well isn't that an odd little space of different things going on there. Whatever you do, absolutely no poufs. You don't have space for an ottoman in that room. If you want to put your feet up somewhere, sit on the couch.

I do like sitting right by the fireplace in the winter, but I hear what you are saying maybe there is not room and too much going on in the small room already. Thanks.

Take them to a fabric shop and have them reupholstered in the fabric of your choice. After all you are used to having them.

Shiripp. Thank you so much. Any suggestions on color? Would be fun to have a pop of color, but not sure what color or fabric type. I have colors in my rug and also the 4 flower pictures above fireplace, perhaps a color from one of them?

Jan Moyer mentioned orange and you asked about using orange or green. I'd go with the orange.

Sounds like a plan, thank you very much!