Better photo of smaller brick like tile. Lighting is terrible!

The larger brick tile. The small look too busy for my taste and I do like the larger one, but thinking it looks a little too sleek for the mirror.

What do you think? - ORB faucet and light or brushed nickel? I was all set to go bronze, but the mirror is brown metal and the nail heads lean more towards silver

Do not worry about matching every little detail. That will be boring.

So only a pedestal sink, no vanity or counter?

You might want to re-think that.

Larger one.

Personally, I prefer minimal grout lines in bathrooms so I’d pick the large tile with a 1/16 grout line. You’ll need a rectified edge for that though. Not sure if that’s what you have.

I like the one on the far left, but I would install it in a herringbone pattern on the floor and the wall behind the pedestal sink & have it act as a backsplash to protect your paint.

It’s difficult to make a suggestion on which tile to use since you haven’t offered and other details about your style. Would you say you decorate traditional, modern/contemporary, transitional,rustic, eclectic...? What does the light fixture look like? Each tile you selected will give you a different look.