Software
Houzz Logo Print
jay6a

Name this succulant

8 years ago

It was at the garden center, by clearance, with no tag, and the very last specimen, so I had to have it.



Comments (18)

  • 8 years ago

    Here's another pic. When I post more then one photo, only one uploads.

  • 8 years ago

    The girl at the garden center said that these have red flowers, with petals, and a center.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    iochroma, yes that's it! It has a new name..... Dorotheanthus bellidiformis. Finally a new name easier to pronounce than the former. I cringe with fear every time I have to say or spell out Mesembryanthemum. This plant looks like the cultivar " Mezoo Trailing Red".

  • 8 years ago

    <i>Dorotheanthus bellidiformis</i> is a different plant. An image-search for the cultivar you named does indeed show the putative Aptenia, but it is not correctly identified. A search without the cultivar will show many examples of the valid <i>Dorotheanthus bellidiformis</i>.

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked iochroma
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    iochroma, now I'm confused. I did a search of Dorotheanthus bellidiformis, (excluding the cultivar name) and it shows pics of the more common iceplants with the moss rose type foliage, but it also shows pics of my plant along with the others. Wiki says Dorotheanthus bellidiformis was formerly called Mesembryanthemum crinifloris. I thought the wider leaves were gotten through selective breeding. So, are there 2 of the same species that look so different, that they could be mistaken as 2 different species, or is my plant not actually Dorotheanthus bellidiformis? I haven't seen the name Aptenia mentioned anywhere. It must be quite archaic.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Don't be confused. It's just that there are many incorrectly identified images on the first page of Googling under Dorotheanthus bellidiformis. Your plant is what I learned as Aptenia cordifolia but which, I learn from Iochroma, is now Mesembryanthemum cordifolium. Take his/her word for it when it comes to warm climate plants. The cordifolium/cordifolia bit of the name tells you the leaves are heart shaped, as you can see on your plant. If you Google Aptenia cordifolia you will see many images of your plant under its previous name. (Which although long established was in use until very recently, so not particularly archaic.) I don't know why you didn't find any.

    Forget about Dorotheanus bellidiformis, it's an entirely different species from yours and is just clouding the issue.

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
  • 8 years ago

    ***** Thank you floral! I understand. *****

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Most plant image searches I do return a percentage of pictures of plants other than what I am looking for - often if I click on the different looking ones they aren't in fact identified by the source site as the same plant I searched

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked Embothrium
  • 8 years ago

    I grow the non variegated form of this plant to eat! It's very nice, a little salty, slightly sour, juicy and crunchy. One of the best edible succulents I have tried, it's not slimy or too astringent like some.
    Not suggesting you should eat yours, Jay, but around here the green leaved one can get a bit weedy. Of course it may be good to know in an emergency : )

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked Cheap Shoots
  • 8 years ago

    Cheap Shoots, I did not know that. Brings a whole new meaning to the term " garden salad". Good to hear it's not slimy. I forgot to rinse the nopalitas the last time I made cactus salad, and it was really gross to see it while eating it. I'm just growing the succulant as an annual, because I don't have good indoor lighting, so maybe I'll make a succulant salad with nasturtiums at the end of the growing season. Is it ok to trim these iceplants back a little? Mine doesn't need it yet, bit it would be a good excuse for nibbleing on a couple leaves, so I can see what they taste like. Do you keep the green weedy one controlled by eating it? :)

  • 8 years ago

    Jay, we're eating nasturtiums almost every day at the moment. They're quite peppery and we eat them in mixed green salads rather than alone. The flowers have a different, sweeter flavour to the leaves and they look very pretty in the bowl. What's stopping you enjoying them now? By the end of the season they'll be coarser and less tasty.

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
  • 8 years ago

    Well floral, I've been following your nasturtium comments over on the annuals forum, and since we've been having unbearably hot days I've been thinking about you and how fortunate you are to have such a perfect climate for growing them. The truth is I had a very late start at sowing the seeds, and my plants are still small and can't afford to loose any of their leaves just yet. I sowed maybe 30 seeds of just the normal mixed colors and some Empress of India. After seeing what everyone else is growing I think I'll grow more kinds next year. I like to mix my nasturtiums with other salad greens too. I like them in slaws too. They were really good in a slaw made using Brussells sprouts. I was looking at the plants today and saw a few brown spots on them from the hot sun, but hopefully most of the remainder of summer will be a little milder. Thanks for the tip about their flowers, I'm going to start eating more of them from now on.

  • 8 years ago

    Oh dear, Jay. Brussels sprouts? Eaten before they've had a frost on them? Never! ;-) When the sprouts are ready the Nasturtiums are long dead.

  • 8 years ago

    Floral, I don't grow my veggies. I buy them, so they may be coming from California during the growing season, or Chile in winter, I'm not sure. And they don't say whether they were hit by frost or not. I was not aware that frost makes them taste better. Maybe I've been eating bad sprouts all my life not knowing any better. IMO that slaw tasted pretty good to me. A couple years ago I tried growing mashua Tropaeolum tuberosa. Mostly it was for the hummingbirds, but I wanted to try out eating the tubers also. They didn't do well at all here, and it was another blazing, hot summer.I don't remember the name of the place where I got the tubers, but they sold many kinds of edible nasturtium and oxalis tubers. I was thinking that one could make a good chutney using hottentot figs. ( pardon the pejorative, but I didn't name it, and I don't know how else to describe it).

    )

  • 8 years ago

    Jay, in my experience so far (limited!) It is very much okay to trim them back, they seem to like it. But I haven't eaten too much from my own plants yet as they're quite new. But let's just say I help to keep other people's green weedy one under control by eating it : )
    The new fresh growth from unstressed plants seems to be the nicest to eat. Not surprisingly I guess.

    I haven't ever tried nopales, but I intend to forage some one day soon. I guess I need to remember to take gloves, but I may be less afraid of the spines than the slime.

    I would love to try growing mashua and oca (edible oxalis) some day. Oca sound delicious.

    I have never tried the fruit of Carpobrotus edulis ( hottentot fig) but I have tried the fruits of Australian native Carpobrotus glaucescens aka pigface, and chutney would be the perfect thing. In fact they are like ready made chutney.

    The leaves of c. Glaucescens are edible and are good except for their astringency. They are salty, juicy, crunchy, not slimy but they make your teeth feel chalky and weird. However a small amount in a salad is good, you don't notice the chalky teeth thing then. I need to experiment more with cooking them. But i think i remember sauteing them and they kind of popped/ exploded...exciting food.

  • 8 years ago

    If you can find seeds, try growing "ficoide" - Mesembryanthemum crystallinum

    It is the most tasty succulent I've ever eaten.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I believe, that for every drop of rain that falls, a flower will grow.https://youtu.be/uh5GQ_s6v5s