Software
Houzz Logo Print
jetehel

Black spot help

8 years ago

I have a few roses with terrible black spot. I don’t usually treat them and let them do their thing, but a few David Austin’s that I planted this year have totally defoliated. Is there anything I can do to help them? I’m in NY and would like to get them healthy enough to survive the winter.

Also, should I spray my other roses that are covered in black spot but not defoliated or leave them be?

Comments (9)

  • 8 years ago

    I do not spray so can not help but hopefully someone comes along and answers your questions about spraying...

    Not sure there is enough time for your roses to even re-leaf this year??? We will soon be getting frosts here in our area of Pa...So I assume the same for your area?

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks jim. I prefer not spraying too. I just hope they make it through the winter

  • 8 years ago

    They will, so long as the bud unions are buried, and you don't do anything stupid like try to protect them.

    The bigger problem will be next year. The same thing will happen again, and the plants will be noticeably weaker. So do start mulling around the choice between spraying and removing those roses.

  • 8 years ago

    I agree with the survival of the fittest mentality. Even in zone 5 I don't fret about the roses surviving the winter except to make sure they're well watered and have a bit of a wind break. I always bury grafts and tend toward own root roses. I just don't expect much surviving cane from the HTs and floribundas and just hope for root survival. If they're going to survive they survive and if they're going to die there's not much I can do to change that. It's all about experimenting to see what does OK in your zone in the winters. I'm often pleasantly surprised, but my expectations aren't that high for HTs.

    Cynthia

    Jaime 7a NY thanked nippstress - zone 5 Nebraska
  • 8 years ago

    Titan, thanks, will do!

  • 8 years ago

    Nippstress, I purchased the 2 worst roses at a local nursery (carding mill and munstead woods) so I was sort of hopefull that they would be good in my region, but I guess time will tell.

    I was just wondering if there’s anything I should give them, super thrive or fish emulsion that will help them recover from the defoliation and stand a chance at surviving winter

  • 8 years ago

    Both Carding Mill and Munstead Wood survive just fine in my zone 5 yard with or without leaves going into the winter, so I can't think that winter would be a problem in your warmer zone 7 area. Given that you have stronger BS pressure in your zone than mine I can't say that they'd be equally happy during the summers and they might weaken over time as Mad says, but they are not particularly winter tender and should be fine as far as winter temperatures go.

    I wouldn't do any fertilizer this close to winter temperatures even the organics, though I doubt it would hurt. I've killed more roses with kindness than I've killed with neglect.

    Cynthia

  • 8 years ago

    Ha! Thanks Cynthia. Me too! I will just leave them be