Did the door itself break or just the mechanism that takes the door up and down?

Raised panel will be the least expensive option. I would suggest Clopay. If you damage a panel in the future, it can usually be replaced without having to purchase a complete door.

The more interesting designs cost more money. Just depends on your budget.

Wow! Thank you! Whats the second one down in your renderings? Is that like a light beige? Do you think that would look good or white? Thanks!

Ack. Remove the shutters altogether please. They are totally out of proportion.

This is from Clopay's Classic collection:

I apologize for redoing the whole front of your house, but I had to. If you want the gable, it should be wider, and I think your portico could use some posts for balance.

Wow!!!! Thank you, this is awesome!!!

Quite a difference with those posts!