Software
Houzz Logo Print
gdinieontarioz5

ID for cactus.

8 years ago

I saw this handsome fellow in a garden centre, but as I like to know what I am buying...



Who knows what this is?

Comments (28)

  • 8 years ago

    Thelocactus bicolor.....

  • 8 years ago

    Probably not in the best exposure, hence the lackluster spine color.....

  • 8 years ago

    Thank you, Stefan, that’s it. Now decision time: to buy or not to buy ;-).

  • 8 years ago

    Id buy it. Not the most eye pleasing one, but it is sought after.....

    No way id meet one in dutch wholesale.

    With some care youll get it too look good.....

  • 7 years ago

    Nor would I find it in most nurseries here (careful about Dutch wholesale to a Dutchie ;-) ). It is a privately owned garden centre, and I think they often buy from smaller sellers and even hobby sellers. I am tempted, but I am even more tempted by a Parodia buiningii they have. I might go for that one. At least I think it is buiningii... What do you think?

  • 7 years ago

    I would get both...:)

  • 7 years ago

    But where do I put them! They all have to come in for winter. And I have a looooong list for my favourite DUTCH grower too. I need a greenhouse!!!

  • 7 years ago

    Wholesale is wholesale.Its business. I hold no grudges against the dutch, but businessmen running the whole "flora exchange".. 7 years of buying, and only seen good plants this year. Thank you ubink and novicactus ....Rest were just "standard".....


    As for the parodia buingini, id get a smaller one if i could.....

    Eyeing it, id say 12-16m (5-6 inches) c diameter?

  • 7 years ago

    It is also a question of what your suppliers buy. In 2015 I got this from one large general garden centre in one buy: my return to succulents.

    The last two years it has mostly been Colasanti: standard, easily grown, quickly grown plants. No mesembs, except for lithops the size of golfballs or the shape of cucumbers.

    There is only one P. buiningii. Why would you want a smaller one? Your size estimate is probably correct, around 12 cm from memory.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Mine buy(from their words) a "plants stock market" or plant"exchange or whatever,

    Ive memorized with most producers, but it is still a matter of luck on whats available and what is chosen......

    So far for small cacti, edelcactus, ubink, van der linden, and novicactus are all the ones ive seen product from....

    Might have been some species haworthia, rhipsalis and echeveria sellers, but for cacti those few.

    Novicactus has that e.rigidisimus rubrispinus in their catalogue that i so desperately want, but doubtful the fool buying the plants will aim to please me. Odds are theyll get a bunch of pilosocereus, a-c-opuntia subulata, opuntia monacantha, some common parodia and grafts too.....

    This year actually began quite terrible for cacti in the begging. In march ,only rarity i saw proper was maybe a baby coryphantha(that i regret not buying , but monetary constraints and such). On the aspect of succulents though, euphorbia galore. Medusa head, a whole tray of obesa......i even saw ancampseros and avonia(but i have no intention of buying those for x reasons)...

    But not cacti at that time.....

    They got better during and after september though.....

    This is one year ill be sad it was passing....

  • 7 years ago

    I hope they get the good ones for you!

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Did you end up getting the Thelocactus? Thelocactus do make beautiful flowers:). Love the Parodia buiningii. Did you end up getting that guy too;)?! I just bought one this spring and it is tiny. Maybe an inch wide now. I wish they bloomed that small. I like the wavy tubercles in between the areoles.

    I just went to my local nursery and they just recieved a nice new shipment of cactus. What heck?! Why now and not 4 months ago.



    They have a few more cactus I want, but I think I’m good for now. The only reason why I bought so many is because they don’t really protect their succulents from the cold and rain. So I didn’t want to wait and see what these guys looked like in March.

    Look how cool this Parodia looks. Right when I think I know the characteristica of some cactus, there’s always one that will confuse me.

    Parodia sanguiniflora



    If somebody asked me for an id. I would have no clue. My first thought would be a Mammillaria, but the top does look like a Parodia. Those thin red hooked center spines look sooo Mammillaria like. Tricky little dude;).

    I’m glad I’m not the only one buying cactus in November;).

  • 7 years ago

    So funny, Kara, went to a local nursery recently and got almost the same lot than you. Actually I am questioning one of the ID, the Frailea looks more like grahliana than buenekeri to me. I have the grahliana from a different source than the buenekeri from Lone Pine one and they look identical. And they also match the F grahliana description on Llifle, let me know what you think.


    I also agree that many will not make it through winter in the nursery. Somehow the Lone Pine nursery soil retains water very well and those local nurseries drown them on regular basis. A couple of them fell to the floor at the nursery as I picked them up, making an ugly splash on the ground like an overripe fruit. Sad. I had to transfer the M duwei right away in dry soil after wiping the roots with a paper towel :(

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Alain, you know great minds do think alike;). I was so happy to find that M. duwei because I’ve wanted one for awhile. Wish it was bigger tbh. Lone Pine’s mix is a forever mystery because it looks like it shouldn’t hold onto moisture, but it does. Whenever I leave plants in their mix the plants always goes south. I was pretty excited to see the new shipment at my local nursery. They had a couple cactus I’ve wanted for awhile and the duwei was one, the other is Mammillaria albicoma. I like how the albicoma has tufts of fluff and no hard or hooked spines. It’s different;).

    I think you are totally right about the Frailea! Looking at grahliana and buenekeri pics, and mine looks a lot more like grahliana instead of buenekeri. I was reading that Frailea are cleistogamous. Which means the flowers can make seeds without even opening. That’s good because it sounds like these cactus are short lived.

    OT-Alain I’m thinking about repotting the Aloe suprafoliata you gave me because I’m seeing roots at the bottom. I think I’m gonna put in a terra cotta pot. Have you repotted your suprafoliatas?

    Looks really neat up close. I like how you can see the teeth indents. In the past month it has put on some noticeable growth.

    I’ve been wanting to show you how big the Puya you gave me has gotten. It’s finally starting to look like a Puya;).

    I will probably go back to the nursery more sooner than later and get the other cactus I want. There’s a Melocactus warasii, Neoporteria villosa, Sulcorebutia Muschii, and Parodia penicillata. I moved the Melocactus so it would be more protected from the cold. Luckily there’s a couple of them so if one doesn’t make it. Oh ya there’s a really nice Copiapoa hypogea clump that I need;).

    Dinie, sorry about my off topic comments to Alain:). This is my first R. narvacensis. Your cactus is the reason why I bought mine. Thanks a lot;). Jk. I remember yours blooming like crazy and I don’t believe I have any flowers with that coloring. I love a good bloomer.

    I could imagine mealies eating M. duwei. There are some plants that look like mealybug magnets and duwei looks like one. I will have to keep a close eye on it. That’s why I wish mine was a little bigger because if anything were to happen there’s not much plant that could be saved. Can’t wait for that Parodia/Mammillaria;) to bloom the flowers are purty.

    My itty bitty P. buiningii;).

  • 7 years ago

    NP, Kara. I hope you get the plants you mentioned. What choice you have, you make my mouth water (or bleed from the spines?). I think we are mutual enablers. I know I have a few of your plants on my list. I think you mentioned Lobivia bonniae f. Fiambala, to Stefan, I think. That one is on my list now. I will let you know if I get it ;-). That buiningii is cute. I still have not bought mine...

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Nice list indeed, always growing though!

    Dinie, my Frailea castanea flower gave a seed pods and I made a note to send you some but clumsy me it fell off my hand somewhere on the ground or some pots, could not find it :( Oh well, there is always next year.

    Kara, the Frailea are indeed short lived. My grahliana had a seed pod when I purchased it, several seeds in it that germinated in a couple days!

    Good growing on the Aloe and Puya! Yours doing well too! I did transfer the Aloe last spring (it was larger than yours). I have it in a ceramic pot. I am a bit of a scavenger when it comes to pots so I use what I can get. It's so dry here, Aloes won't mind it.

    Last OT point (sorry Dinie): One thing that might contribute to the soil issue with Lone Pine plants is the top dressing. They use unusually large and heavy gravel for the plant size, and a pretty thick layer of it too. So that could affect evaporation as well as put too much weight on the soil that is less aerated and stay soggy longer. On top of that the retailer they use water succulents and cactus like they do all other plants...

  • 7 years ago

    Thank you, Alain, that was very thoughtful. I would love some seed of F. castanea whenever you have some. Did you know that mine died? Alain and Kara, I do have a few F. cataphracta. If it sets seed, would you like some of that?

    Funny thing about the nursery with the two plants above: they use their own soil mix, peat with a lot of fine sand. I would never use it myself, but it is so easy to get it off the roots! The plants come away with hardly any root damage. Big point in their favour.

  • 7 years ago

    Dinie, yes I knew, you mentioned it after I posted a pic of mine in bloom in the monthly Bloom thread some time ago. It's not an easy one to find/replace :( Would love some seeds from the cataphracta if/whenever you have some as well, that plant with a few other Frailea, is definitely on my want list, in the top 100!! Like for the castanea, not an easy one to find!

  • 7 years ago

    I don’t even remember mentioning that. I got my cataphracta in Holland. Potful of 7 or so for €8... One I gave away, one died, five left :-). Got my castanea in Canada. One plant for $30 or more, forget the exact price. Was a real ouch when the mealies, actually the treatment, killed it. Was not planning to replace it at that price. This way maybe we can both have both. Kara included of course.

  • 7 years ago

    wow, that was a great deal for the cataphracta, in the US you can find the castanea for $12-15 nowadays but it's still hard to find.

  • 7 years ago

    Dinie- The day I find that Lobivia famatimensis var. bonniae I will be one happy person. I don’t order online because I have to draw the line in the sand somewhere or else I will be overrun with cactus;). I’m lucky enough to live close to pretty decent nurseries and shows. I was able to find a Lobivia famatimensis, but it’s not the variety I really want. When I first saw it at the San Jose show I got excited, but when I got home I realized it wasn’t totally what I wanted, but it still a unique looking cactus.


    Hasn’t bloomed yet, but I think the flowers are brighter yellow. They don’t have that unique flower like the bonniae variety has.

    I would Love some Frailea cataphracta seeds if you don’t mind. I don’t think I have any amazing seeds you will probably want, but I will have to check.

    I have noticed the best time to kill mealies on cactus is the fall/winter. This is of course they aren’t covered in the spring. Waiting till winter would be a death sentence. I find treating for mealies when it’s hot out difficult because I have to quarantine, which is usually in a north facing window in my garage. I don’t want to leave out in the heat while I spray rubbing alcohol. So a cactus in a north facing window during the growing season is not the best, but in the winter they aren’t in active growth. So I spray with rubbing alcohol during the cooler months I don’t have to worry about etiolation or scorching the cactus. Lastly, a great bonus during the cooler months those mealies are not nearly as active. So I can kinda get em while they’re already down. The summer they’re thriving. That’s just my opinion of course;).



  • 7 years ago

    Since this is an ‘ID cactus’ post I thought I might ask you guys what do think this cactus is? I have no clue;).

    It’s about 4 inches long. It started out as a ball and now it’s becoming columnar.

  • 7 years ago

    Also some kind of Thelocactus?????

  • 7 years ago

    At first glance I thought Echinocereus but you must have ruled that out, Not sure otherwise, sorry.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I don’t think it’s Thelocactus. Maybe Echinocereus? The spines remind me of Echinocactus grusonii, but I’m fairly certain it’s not an Echinocactus grusonii/Golden Barrel cactus. Idk maybe it is a weird Golden Barrel. I have a feeling it’s going to be one of those cactus I won’t know what it is for years.

    Anyways went to the nursery and bought a few plants;).



    The Mammillaria on the right wasn’t on the list, but that’s ok;). Saved the Melocactus, it was still in the hiding spot;). I know that thing would have been mush by spring. The little Crassula pangolin in front will probably be dead by next summer. I don’t do well with those cute little stacked Crassulas. I admire Eww because he grows them so beautifully.

    I mainly went back to buy to the Parodia penicillata. Upon closer inspection I found some mealybugs:(. I really want that cactus too, but I can’t knowingly buy a cactus with bugs on it.



    There weren’t a bunch of mealybugs tho. Look at me trying to talk myself into going back to buy it. Just say no Kara;).

    Alain I found another little pot of Trichodiadema bulbosum. I passed on them. I mean I do have five little ones, and there are probably three in that pot below. So that would mean I have eight little baby Trichodiadema bulbosum. I think five is enough;). Plus the surrounding pots had mealies.



  • 7 years ago

    Kara, that's what I thought, E grusonii, if one dismisses the lower part of the stem, strange!

    And, yes, 5 is a good number :). But there is always a good reason for new cactus!