This is the floor and cabinet color

Think about other colors in your home decor in adjoining areas. This is a good opportunity to tie things together. What is nearby?

Agreeable gray is on the walls. Is that a color I should use on island to tie it in

what color gray is that? We have open concept floor plan. Our entire downstair wall color is agreeable gray. I would like a contrast,but with the dark wood I don't want it to get lost. I have gray swatches all over at the moment. lol

At the moment I like smoke ember

The photo info indicates it’s a custom color, but Pewter cast by SW is close. If you don’t want to go too far from what you have, Anew Gray by SW is a little bit darker, but a nice warm gray.

We have to use benjamin moore colors on the cabinetry

We used Sherwin Williams on the wall

What are your options for color that you have right now and how do they look with your floors, countertop, etc.? This goes back to having a master plan. Doing one thing at a time, usually ends with a mish mash mess. Think about putting together a mood board to see how all your fixed surfaces work together. If it’s open plan, you need to think about furnishings as well. If there is a sw color you like, you can take it to BM and either find a similar one or have it matched. I am not a fan of having them matched, because they’re usually off a little (every company has a different base). Once you pick a color that works with the floors, countertops and whatever else is in there, get a sample and paint a large piece of foam board or drywall or even wood. Colors look different when they get bigger.

Benjamin Moore should be able to color match a SW color. Is there a reason you want a gray island?

We are under renovation. As of right now, we have our wood floors-seen above, we have our color Scheme. I wanted a contrast in a white kitchen. The cabinets are getting made and they only work with BM colors. I am also not a fan of matching BM to Sherwin Williams. My tops will be quartzite. We like a gray to break up the white. I was looking for a gray that wouldn’t get lost in the dark wood floors but that would contrast with the white.

Pick a real color. Not gray. It will outlast the fad.

There are many beautiful BM dark blue colors that would fit your scheme.

We decided to keep the island white. I will warm up the kitchen with backsplash. thank you for all of your input