I would go ahead and paint, etc. first to get a better idea of what actual fixtures will look right in the space.

This would look great in your foyer.

https://www.houzz.com/products/4-light-antique-black-semi-flush-mount-beaded-drum-crystal-chandelier-prvw-vr~48539039?lid=35054314

How about this over your stairs?

https://www.houzz.com/products/4-light-antique-copper-globe-cage-globe-chandelier-clear-glass-sconce-prvw-vr~103908901?lid=79358920

https://www.destinationlighting.com/item/lantern-pendant-light-4-lt-33-inch-tall-bronze/663938

Simple, classic & inexpensive

I don't think the paint will change the size requirements?

The round ones look to be too small based on the calculators I was using?

Beverly, do you think that is big enough? It's certainly cheap, but smaller than what I have fairly substantially. Also don't know if I can take more ORB, since the house is pretty full of it!

The paint may not change the size requirements, but may change your mind about the metal or style.

I'd also consider something like this shape/style.

37.5"hx18.5w"

Not sure if it's big enough though.

The lantern is 5" less than your fixture but that 5" is mostly just decorative metal leaves. I think this fixture might work, but the height it's mounted will determine how successful

It's also available in a combination of bronze and aged brass.

How high would you recommend mounting it? It sort of hangs over the banister, I don't want it to be too close to feel like someone will bump their head.

If that size is ok, then I have more options that are less $$, what about something like this? 33.25"hx18"w

https://www.bellacor.com/productdetail/mill-and-mason-bryan-aged-brass-five-light-pendant-2078928.htm

I had to laugh, we had one of those 'tuscan looking' ones too, same spot!

My first thought for these lights has nothing to do with their beauty and presence, but more about....How will I clean this thing and how will I change its bulbs? :/

So, along that line, I wouldn't choose anything that can collect a lot of dust. Shades or glass with bottoms facing the ceiling would be a no. I have a dislike of viewing a collection of bugs from beneath. :(

Any style you're going for? Other fixture finishes?

https://www.bellacor.com/productdetail/mill-and-mason-bryan-aged-brass-five-light-pendant-2078928.htm

I do like this one :)

what are yr other finishes?

Wanting a very classic, preppy, “old money” type of feel if that makes any sense. Not flashy, glam, or modern at all. Not rustic.

Door hardware and all other lights in the house are ORB. All trim is cream (close to SW Navajo white). Floor is oak.

Plan to replace the rest of the lights in succession but starting here, as it seems to be the biggest and most expensive.

This is my dining room light, which is new

I did order these for the kitchen but they are on backorder and haven’t received.

these are lights I am considering for other areas of the house but have not purchased yet. Always trying to make sure it all works together.

potential family room:

Potential for entry right above door:

Potential piano room:

I like the brass Bellacor fixture for your home. The only way to determine the correct height is to rig a hook at the electrical box and use the chain to temporarily hang the lantern. That will allow you to raise and lower the fixture until you determine the correct height. I wish there was a formula, but this is a complex three dimensional space and the lantern gets viewed from lots of angles so there no easy answer.

All brass doesn't make the same strong statement as the bronze.

Huh. Thanks for the mock up! That seems smaller and higher than I think I would want. Really don’t want bronze though.

If you haven't already, you should check out Lamps Plus website, they have hundreds+ of entry lights in a myriad of styles and finishes and price ranges.

Or check out Edvivi Lighting's page on Houzz. We have great prices right here on Houzz

https://www.houzz.com/user/edvivilighting

How about this- Round Brass/Beveled Glass lantern

Size-31-H" plus 7" chain D-16"

Great price-$550

I agree with kmg11. This is a fixture that is hard to reach for cleaning. unless you plan to get out the big ladder every few weeks, stay away from glass enclosures and panels. Dust collects so quickly on fixtures. Definitely use LED bulbs and a dimmer switch, so you can perfectly control the light

Well, I clean the one that is there...I lean over and grab it and pull toward the railing, clean it, then let it go.

I also found this one at Ballard: https://www.ballarddesigns.com/breakers-4-light-lantern/lighting/indoor-lighting/chandeliers/433918?listIndex=48

Which I think is the same one that is seen on this blog here with a somewhat similar staircase to mine, maybe even a little bigger?

http://www.elementsofstyleblog.com/2018/09/an-exciting-big-project-to-share.html?epik=dj0yJnU9SENzaGxGbUEzRFBtRzM1Y2FkNnktNGRiMHJyd0NETXgmbj1Db1NxWlJQTkxNR3hiQS1rR1hZWFpBJm09MyZ0PUFBQUFBRnhkbkRZ

It does look exactly like the one in the blog. I like it too :)

I like it too. And I like the price :)

I am struggling with a coordinating but not matching semi flush mount or small lantern to go above the door.

I like a globe style

Or lantern style

But I don't think those match very well together...

I'm in the process of shopping for a new fixture in our entry and am seriously considering this one. I wonder if it might be a contender for your semi-flush mount.

I think the issue with the ones for above the door is that they look more like copper than brass.

bac717 is that a Minka Lavery?

https://www.lightsonline.com/minka-lavery-4445-582-laurel-estate-4-light-pendant-in-brio-gold

?

Pretty!

Yes, gypsyrose, I think the finish has to match pretty closely and so hard to do that online with everyone having a different idea of "brass" and "antique brass" and "gold" and whatever else...