I like drapes in bedrooms

and find they are best for real blackout too.

Layered treatments in bedrooms is a MUST!

This way it will provide you the utmost control over light/privacy. And it looks delish.

Romans will always look 'wrinkled' (depending on your fabric selection), it's a necessary evil, so to speak. Perhaps instead of Romans, try a black out roller shade.

The art of layering · More Info

The art of layering · More Info

My romans never looked wrinkled. They have a blackout liner that gives them some heft, so maybe that is the difference. However, they allow a lot of light to come in at the sides since they do not sit flush with the window frame. I have roller shades under them, but they are not light blocking since they make the room too dark during the day. I have privacy issues and can't just open everything. I curse my neighbors who refuse to turn off their flood light at night!

Honeycomb Black out shades are a great option for the installation. I see in the pic that your previous blinds were mounted directly to the window trim...bad decision. Go with minimalistic bottom up top down blinds that mount inside mount the your window. Ours for example require only 1/2 inch of flat surface to be installed and you will get the best of light management and privacy.