Software
Houzz Logo Print
milliways1

Asbestos in attic?

7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago

I helped a friend with some contracting work (rafter upgrades) last week - a total of about 3 hours with a dust mask on - and am concerned that I could have been exposed to vermiculite. The home was built in the late 50's and has had quite a bit of work done - remodeling, multiple additions, etc. For insulation the attic space had plastic wrapped batts/rolls between the floor joists, covered by a thick layer of blown cellulose. I did quite a bit of raking/movement of the cellulose and laid boards on the batts to crawl around. The homeowner is a contractor and the only thing they said with regards to the attic was that there was little to no insulation up there when they moved in 5 years ago but I am hesitant to completely trust their word.

Considering the age of the home, is there a chance that there was vermiculite hidden under the batts, i.e. would it be common to hide it under poly-wrapped insulation? If so, would my exposure have been significant?

Comments (9)

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Considering the age of the home, is there a chance that there was vermiculite hidden under the batts, i.e. would it be common to hide it under poly-wrapped insulation?

    You said that there was cellulose & batt insulation up there. You didn't see vermiculite, did you? As far a 'hidden' vermiculite, forget that. If it was there, you would have seen evidence of it. I use it as a soil amendment...not as puffy as perlite but the stuff goes pretty much wherever it wants to go. Would be impossible not to have seen some of it laying around.

  • 7 years ago

    Especially since you were wearing a mask, why do you fear significant exposure? And why do you think your friend would lie to you?

    Let it go.

  • 7 years ago

    My husband (a retired geologist) says that vermiculite is not the same as asbestos. Which do you fear? Are you unsure?

  • 7 years ago

    Ah, please disregard my previous post. Hubby just read to me that vermiculite might be correlated with asbestos.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    That's correct, the mineral deposits they make vermiculite from (by puffing it up in an oven) sometimes contain traces of asbestos. One of the major vermiculite mines (Libby, MT) did, so millions of homes have (or had) vermiculite insulation with traces of asbestos in it.

  • 7 years ago

    A dust mask doesn't protect against asbestos.


    Health Canada on vermiculite.

  • 7 years ago

    Good info but zero evidence that the OP encountered any vermiculite. Just because a home was built in the late 50's doesn't make vermiculite a given. My mom's house was built in that time period 1958-59; the insulation in the attic was fiberglass batts. Not a speck of vermiculite.

  • 7 years ago

    >>A dust mask doesn't protect against asbestos.


    That all depends on the type of mask. If you're referring to the typical cheapie hardware store dust mask, then I agree wholeheartedly.