Software
Houzz Logo Print
miyekot

help style built-in to keep clutter free

We have an old built-in cabinet in our living room by the front door that is the go-to drop zone for our family. How can I style the top surface to help keep it clutter-free? I've tried photos, plants, and ceramic knick knacks. The photos and knick knacks end up looking cluttered in themselves, and we still manage to find space between things for the mail, etc. I'd love to try plants again, but since this is an east facing window, the plants get a lot of sun in the morning, then no sun the rest of the day. The plants I've tried tend to bolt toward the window, leaving brown ugly stems at their base. We're converting another space at a side entry to a mudroom, hoping that will alleviate some of this, but in the meantime, I'd love some advice on how to style this clutter-magnet surface.

Comments (20)

  • 7 years ago

    I'm afraid you need to deal with the way you actually live, not the way you wished you lived! If everyone in the family now uses this as a drop spot, you need to either re-train the family members, or control the clutter.

    Perhaps a few low baskets? One for mail, others for each family member (or whatever system makes sense to you). At least the stuff would be a little better contained.

    What is currently in the drawers and behind the doors? Can you clear those spaces out, and teach folks to dump their stuff behind a door?

  • 7 years ago

    I had a table that resembled your clutter heap. Resolved to keep it bare for 21 days, making a habit. Then added “decor” back till It felt right.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Remove everything and place one large, low piece (i.e., pottery, decorative basket) in the center of the built-in and declare the space OFF LIMITS to your family. I'd want the one thing there for decorative purposes, but I would not add back smaller items; just keep it to one thing and one thing only. If it's large and striking enough, it becomes a "statement" of sorts in the room.



    You'll really have to be diligent about ensuring that everyone puts their stuff away instead of dumping it here, but the results will be worth it I'll bet. I think that if you provide baskets/receptacles in which to store the clutter, you're going to end up with overflow and be right back to starting at a big mess again. Good luck!

    Front Porch Design Studio thanked User
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Wonderful advice! A bit of a reality check here, because you're absolutely right about our family's habits. I love your suggestion IdaClaire! I've only been thinking of putting many things there to fill the space so there's no room for clutter, but that just covers it with clutter. (I'm not really knick-knack person.) I'm going to start looking for a beautiful statement sculpture per your suggestion. And get some alternate drop-zone options and start up some "training" guidelines. Thank you!!!

  • 7 years ago

    What do you keep inside the cabinet? Are there shelves in there? Perhaps each family member could have a shelf with a basket in there? I can appreciate that some things need to be close to the door, but there needs to be a designated spot.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I would have 1 or 3 houseplants of varying heights in pretty containers and a large pottery piece. Turn the plants once a week when you water. There are low maintenance plants that would love this light. Bromeliads, Cyclamen, Philodendrom, Fittonia (nerve plant) and Bird in Nest fern are a just a few easy care plants that love east light... which is really great because plants get bright morning sun but not the hottest sun all afternoon. African violets would also do well.


    Your mudroom should help this area immensely. fwiw, being tidy takes effort. DH is not as tidy as I am, so I tend to pick up behind him to keep my sanity rather than complain. But if started, it become habit. For example, mail comes in the house and is immediately dealt with (kept or trashed). Jackets and bag are put away. There's no leaving it until later. The new mudroom is a great time to start new habits.

    Front Porch Design Studio thanked Allison0704
  • 7 years ago

    Two options that will make it impossible to pile things on top of the china cabinet:

    One- Install a custom wood framed window at the front edge of the cabinet. Two- Have the china cabinet "extended" up into the space by adding clear glass doors at the front edge of the cabinet, so it looks part of the original cabinet.

    Front Porch Design Studio thanked apple_pie_order
  • 7 years ago

    Styling won't help. If they need the space, they need the space.

    Why aren't you using the cabinet below for that stuff? Simple. Everybody gets a drawer and a shelf inside the cabinet. Problem solved.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    More great ideas, thank you!

    I haven't liked the idea of keeping mud room items in the glass part of the built-ins (ironically, because it's too visible - ha!), but I always forget about the solid cabinets on each side. These would be perfect for extra storage for everyone's dump zone items. Plus, we have been intending to overhaul what we keep in the drawers, so another good spot for smaller items.

    Allison0704, thanks for the specific tips on plants! I looked this weekend for a single sculptural piece, per IdaClaire's suggestion, but quickly realized that it will be difficult to find something that is large enough to command the entire space but also low enough so that it's not blocking the light too much. I think a hybrid approach like you suggest will be helpful (until we find that perfect piece, if ever).

    Apple_pie_order, I love your out-of-the-box thinking! I'm definitely intrigued. If we really can't get everyone to change habits here, a custom cabinet front might just be what we need.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Clear it off

    Place a table lamp to illuminate the area


    And place a glass jar so that anyone caught leaving something on the top of the cabinet must contribute $1 to the jar.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    ha! I love it! Also like the idea of having a light there, thanks.

  • 7 years ago

    How many people in your family use this? You have 4 drawers. Four people could each have a drawer. Their stuff goes there even if you are the one that puts it there to begin with. Keys, paperwork, gloves. The 2 side doors can hide lager things, hats shoes. If there is a shelf inside get baskets to fit the space so each person has an assigned space there too. Looks like you have a mail drop. Put a small table there with a basket to hold it on top. You could have a basket underneath that if someone doesn't use their space their stuff goes there. If they have to hunt for things they may start using their own spot. I think the top should be for plants. there are a lot that don't need that much light. Fill the space with plants so it can't be a catch all. As others have said it involves breaking habits and creating new ones.

  • 7 years ago

    It’s called a flat surface problem. We have it. Nothing seems to help....

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    FSP - ha! Thanks for sympathizing.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Cheryl Smith, yes we have 4 in our family. That's a good idea for the drawers. The papers that go back & forth to school will be perfect there.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    one re-training idea, get some cheap plastic dish pans (Dollar Store), line them up on that flat space, fill with water so nothing can be dumped in them, wait as long as it takes for family to use the drawers, baskets, and shelves in the entry cupboard, only then put in place the light and plants. If they revert to bad habits, back come the dishpans!

    You could install some battery-powered hinge lights (or motion sensor lights) in the cupboard to reward them with a lighted space when they open the cupboard doors.

  • 7 years ago

    @smiling. Haha flat every surface I have would have dishpans!

  • 7 years ago

    We have a somewhat similar set up in our entry - an old copper bowl holds house keys, car keys, and, occasionally, sunglasses and loose change. We installed a hat rack on the wall behind the door (perhaps not elegant, but practical, and I like to think of it as an ever-changing artwork!). Other than that, it's kept pretty clear - mail goes straight to our little office, and anything else goes to bedrooms or the kitchen (or straight to recycling).

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    This thread is a yr old; did your plants survive? I was thinking your built-in IS your go-to drop zone. You just do not want to use the top of it used for "drop-off". So how about using designated areas inside the built-in? But make it easy to "drop-off" something there, by removing the 2 central doors for example?