Software
Houzz Logo Print
kwpcreative72

Advice about gritty mix

6 years ago

Hi. I recently created a succulent tower with gritty mix (Repti-bark, napa flor dri, chicken grit). I took a bunch of my succulents that were potted in Miracle Grow cactus soil and put them into gritty mix inside of graduated cement bowls. My succulents were doing ok in the miracle grow, but I had all the ingredients for the gritty mix, so I figured give it a try. I bring my succulents outdoors in the summer and then inside under grow lights in the winter.


Was it a good idea to change over to this new soil? Or should I have left them in their miracle grow? One issue that I often face is meal worms or aphids while they are indoors during the winter months. I think they often infest my plants due to the moisture from the miracle grow soil. Do you think that's the case?


Just concerned that I shouldn't have changed the soil, even though I know gritty mix is healthier for the plants overall. I don't doubt it, just a little worried.


Thanks for listening!



Comments (8)

  • 6 years ago

    Your succulent tower looks good!

    I guess there will be lots of potting into pots in fall?!

    My vote would be yes. BUT I don't use anything but gritty mix - without any bark. Why don't you use gritty in pots too? I never had meal worms or aphids on my succulents, don't remember seeing a fungus gnats either. If you know MG soil stays wet, why do you use it? Just wondering...

  • 6 years ago

    Thanks! I used the miracle grow because it seemed to always work out ok despite some wetness. But I read alot about the gritty mix, so I wanted to try a change. I just freak out when it's such a big change.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    May I suggest a compromise?

    Re-use your current mix, just amend it w/ equal parts Perlite or Pumice. It'll be fast draining, but not so drastic a change as to gritty mix (which I don't use).

    Handsome tower you've built.

  • 6 years ago

    Do you feel gritty mix is too problematic?

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Karen will tell you how she feels about gritty.

    I do not think it is problematic - mine is made without soil; just approx. equal amounts of sifted perlite and grit, and about 10-15% of turface. I have few pots of succulents where I used cocopeat instead of turface, since I was given few 'bricks' of cocopeat. And some plants needed to be repotted. I just did that, so do not have any results yet, but I believe mix may behave as one where I used turface. It is only handful of pots - maybe there will be more eventually.

    What is drainage like; are there drainage holes in your cement bowls? (I would guess yes?)

  • 6 years ago

    Yes! I have holes in all of the pots. I've been experimenting with succulents the last 4-5 years. Just when I think I've gotten the hang of it, something weird happens and I lose a few. I mistakenly watered them after transplanting into the gritty mix. I should have just let them alone for a week. Let's hope most pull through. I learn something every time I toy with them! If I notice them dying, I guess I will try to reassess my mix.

  • 6 years ago

    Gritty mix didn't work out for me, nor for the person who gave it to me. I tried it, but couldn't get the hang of watering it. I only grow indoors, I use C&S mix & Pumice works just fine & seems much simpler.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Keith

    They should be ok even if you watered right away: gritty mix will drain up fast and it seems to me that all were rooted. I grow same as you - outside, and inside about 6mo. Do not have any pumice, so I use perlite. Otherwise, mixing my 2 or 3 ingredients seems to me as simple as mixing C&S + pumice. I have about 300 pots of succulents. I also have many tropicals, and grow most in a mix I add to lots of coarse perlite, and some also grit (like olives, figs, laurel/bay for example). I have been using this mix for succulents for about 8 yrs now.

    Hope you won't have any problems, and pls. pst photos again. I would like to see how they do next mo and after that...It is lots of plants together, makes for a nice display. And all plants look quite mature, and well grown.