Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_745185586

Seeking advice on base cabinet drawer configuration!

Hi there!


I've decided to replace my old kitchen cabinets w/ white shaker cabinets and am down to two choices of drawer configurations + hoping for some opinions.


For reference, my kitchen is a long/skinny kitchen w/ two rows of cabinets that face one another in an enclosed room. There is not room for a kitchen island as the kitchen is quite narrow. It's a very simple layout w/ a small kitchen table just in front of a mirrored pantry on one end (the end you can't see) and a bathroom/mud room on the other end.


The cabinet design person was strongly advocating a new style of base cabinet that I've decided to go with along the entire length of the LEFT side of the kitchen. That cabinet configuration is a two drawer cabinet w/ a hidden 3rd drawer inside. I was told this was quite "euro" and sought after and liked it due to the clean look. However, I'm not sure what to do for the RIGHT side of the kitchen as there is a sink/sink cabinet + corner cabinet + dishwasher + fridge on that end. The only place on the right side of the kitchen that I could have the 2 drawer cabinets are on the two ends of the row of cabinets so there would be no way to make the entire kitchen look "uniform." And those cabinets are narrower than the row of 30" cabinets on the left side of the kitchen as they are 24" cabinets, so maybe it would look better to have 3 drawer cabinets for those two end cabinets?


Question: what is more appealing to the eyes?


Here's a photo of the LEFT side of the kitchen. And, btw if you're wondering what the brown lines in the photo are, those are floating shelves (we've decided to include a couple of wooden floating shelves along a portion of the left side of the kitchen + also along the narrow end of the kitchen (on the right side, there's a window + a fridge). We will only have a handful of upper cabinets located around the range to store things we wouldn't want "displayed."



The second two photos are of the RIGHT side of the kitchen + I've circled the two base cabinets I'm wondering about. What do you think looks better:


1) having the end cabinets have 2 drawers just like the cabinets on the opposite side, or


2) having the end cabinets instead have a 3 drawer configuration?


OPTION #1:


OPTION #2:


Also, one other question: regarding the floating shelves (which I've drawn in brown). On the narrow end of the kitchen, I'll keep them symmetrical as that's the only option due to wall space. However, for the floating shelves that we'll be installing along the wall of the LEFT side of the kitchen, is it better to have them staggered (e.g. having one shorter than the other, or moving them so they don't line up), or is it better to also keep them symmetrical (like an = sign)?


Again, thank you so much for taking the time to give your opinion! I really appreciate the help!:)

Comments (9)

  • 6 years ago

    Individual drawers with pulls. At least three per cabinet, sometimes four.

  • 6 years ago

    I was thinking about how to make the kitchen more uniform, I know you're asking about the cabinet fronts with the already planned layout and I agree with the above that they do not need to match especially if it is going to impact function.


    I want to share my thoughts with your for your consideration and please note that if you completely ignore them, you're kitchen will be lovely. I am imagining the left side of your kitchen as your cooking space, and the right as the prep and cleanup.


    Here's two ideas:


    1. Looking at the scale of the room, the fridge seems to over tower the room and moving it to the left side would create a better balance of scale. Apart from they way it looks, this will mean that your open shelves won't be broken up, and if you have nice dishes they'll be closer to the dishwasher and easier to put away. Also, you'll have room right next of the dishwasher to put your plates, cups and bowls which store in pull out drawers quite well. I'd use 3 tiered drawers here, as you'll be going into your cutlery drawer frequently enough not to want to open up two drawers each time.


    2. Looking at the left side compared to the right side as a whole, I'd make them both straight and cut out that L which would create a sense of symmetry. Apart from the way it looks, and although the L provides more storage and more counter surface, it changes the space from a 1 person station to a 2 person station & whoever whoever is working next to the sink gets to see out the window. Depending on your style, you can make the wall where the L goes a peg board, or a chalk board, or a lovely wall hanging.


    With both of these suggestions, it should be easier to create a uniform design of drawers on either side of the sink. And as I said already, you're kitchen will be great either way.


    Jeanine Kitchen Remodel thanked Amber Ryder
  • 6 years ago

    The only thing I hate more than a drawer-within-a-drawer, would be just a plain old lower cabinet door! I much prefer 3-drawer or 4-drawer stacks.


    It isn't a new style of base cabinet! Ikea does it this way too. I think you are worrying too much about looks and not enough about functionality and ease of use.

  • 6 years ago

    Hi Amber - Couldn't see how to comment under your comment, so I'm just commenting here!:) Thanks so much for taking the time to diagram the move of the fridge, etc.!;)) It can't be done that way due to a bulk head on that side of the kitchen + doors on either side of the corners of the kitchen--the house is an old Victorian. Though if it were a different configuration I would agree about the fridge placement! Thanks for your time + have a nice weekend!:

  • 6 years ago

    Jeanine, there's lots of old threads on here about mapping and maximizing drawer storage. Function first. You might also want to consider going to 27" deep cabinets on the range side which would give you extra counter space and storage. You could also just pull the 24" cabinets forward by a few inches. I am afraid that you might be frustrated with all of those two-drawer stacks if you don't measure everything first and then decide how many and what size drawers you will need. I would not use hidden drawers for things that you would typically store in a top shallow drawer, use often and want to grab quickly like silverware, spices, cooking utensils, knives and wraps and foils. I have a Rev A Shelf pullout for knives and utensils. It has a narrow footprint and stores everything that used to reside in crocks and a knife block. It is one of my favorite things as I can see everything at a glance and it stays dust free.

    I do think that hidden drawers have a place and can maximize your storage by using air space in deep drawers. In a three-drawer stack a hidden drawer/tray adds an extra layer of storage without going to a four-drawer stack which usually has three shallow and only one deep drawer and limits the size of things that you can store. Four-drawer stacks are great for small prep items. If needs change a hidden drawer can be easily removed so that you have full use of the deep drawer. I use them for organizing 'like' items behind one drawer front to keep the drawer from becoming a jumbled mess like my linens drawer (dish towels, microfiber mats, and aprons) and the other for paper, picnic and plastic items. Two others have broiler pans and extra oven racks and glass cookware. My only two-drawer stack has a chef's drawer on top which is nice to have near the range top.






  • 6 years ago

    Wow!! Your kitchen sounds amazing * you look so organized! Thanks for the tips!:))

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I would do 3 drawer stacks. And not worry so much about all the drawer counts all matching. It’s a small space and no one has x ray vision to see through the walls like your diagram so all the bases won’t be visible at once for the most part. Plus most people will be looking down and that angle won’t make differences stand out. The lowers will be not that noticeable in general.

    I do think the floating shelves should line up. They are near eye level and higher contrast.


    i like the idea about extra deep counters on one side. Good luck!

  • 6 years ago

    Thanks everyone for your helpful tips! Hope you had a nice weekend!:))