Software
Houzz Logo Print
rafugate1

Neem oil safety

I use the ”Safer” brand, in the white bottle w/ purple cap from Lowe’s. It’s 100% neem, the kind you mix w/ water. I usedit to battle whitefly on my indoor tropicals that I put outside spring- fall. It seemed to eradicate them after a few weekly treatments, but then they came back, especially on my crotons. So I went to a local greenhouse that has some BEAUTIFUL specimens. Tt the owner, asked if there was anything else but I didn’t want something toxic to pollinators. He sold me malathion & told me neem is JUST as toxic as inorganic pesticides & will kill pollinators also. I have always read the opposite. Can anyone confirm whether it is or isn’t pollinator friendly? I’ve read that some people in India actually put neem in their tea. I also have pets, & was lead to believe through reading it was pet/people friendly as well- greenhouse owner said no. Appreciate any info from others w/ experience using neem. I havent tried the malathion yet, I don’t want to kill anything or risk my pets getting sick when I bring plants back in for winter (if malathion residue remains on plants). All will be sprayed, as preventative measure, even though not all are affected by whitefly. Also, should I repot now or is it too late?

Comments (15)

  • 6 years ago

    I'm not sure where the greenhouse owner is getting their information from but it is NOT correct!! As long as you do not spray when the pollinators are out flying and visiting the plants - as is the case with any pesticide, organic or not - then there is no harm done. In most cases, the insects need to actually consume the treated plants to be affected by the oil. Pollinators do not eat the plants - they only gather pollen or nectar.

    As for humans and pets, any issue will be dosage. Neem oil is used as a topical treatment for skin issues with pets and flea sprays and shampoos made from neem are actually marketed widely.

    And neem is widely used in the manufacture of cosmetics, soaps, dental products and some topical medicines. And has been for centuries.

    Malathion is an organophosphate or a nerve disrupting pesticide. I would never ever use malathion on anything I or my pets would come into contact with but would not think twice about using neem!

    Rebecca/N. IN/z6A thanked gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
  • 6 years ago

    Neem is not directly toxic to humans or dogs or cats in the case of incidental exposure, however, read on...

    It's wise to think twice before using neem. From Dr. McFaddin, "neem oil can interact with insulin, some oral diabetic medications agents, and thyroid hormone supplementation medication."


    Or, don't use it topically, or accidentally ingest it, and I'd be durned careful with the stuff if you happen to be diabetic, or are on thyroid supplementation. That warning is more for use in shampoo than plants, fortunately. Still, if you happen to be a diabetic, or suffer from thyroid issues, I'd advise wearing gloves. Let's avoid incidental spray, and wash your hands afterward just in case.


    Actually, just wash your hands afterward just in case when using any oil. Ask me about spearmint oil. Nice scent. Deadly stuff.


    And for the love of Mike, can we stop thinking that "natural" means "safe?" Socrates would like a word with you.

    Rebecca/N. IN/z6A thanked User
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Thank you both. My alarms went off when he started telling me it was as bad as other pesticides. I had read SO much to the contrary. Garden gal- I don’t usually spray until late evening so that nothing gets sunburnt. Morpheuspa - I’m not diabetic, thankfully, & no thyroid issues or medicines. Do either of you think it is too late in the season to repot some of the affected plants after I finish up neeming them again? It will officially be fall here in 3 weeks.

  • 6 years ago

    Neem is also directly banned in the UK (and indirectly banned in Canada simply due to not being registered as a pesticide, which is really neither here nor there). I'll let you do the research on that one for yourself. The reasons why are fun.


    I use it sparingly and follow the same rules as other pesticides as I'm familiar with Azadirachtin and its issues (and I'm a middle-aged male). As I said above, natural does not mean safe and synthetic does not mean unsafe.


    Which still doesn't preclude people putting it in their tea or on their faces (women do intentionally drink it in India for...certain reasons, he said obliquely). See Paracelsus' famous quote for that one, not to mention that people have been doing dumb stuff and getting away with it forever; I see people cook with essential oils (note: never do that; use flavor essences from the grocery store--EOs are never to be used in cooking). Queen Elizabeth I used heavy metal cosmetics. American supplements are poorly monitored but people toss 'em down like candy.


    Lecture ends, but yes, you did set me off on a pet subject. :-)


    If you have to repot? Do so. While I'm at the end of my season (three weeks out or so), I just had to repot 9 desert rose that can't live in their plastic starters all winter and 3 hibiscus that were rootbound. It's not perfect, but if you have no choice, you gotta.


    Just follow the rules, step up one pot size maximum (2" increase), and don't overwater through the winter when the plant's normally resting a bit. In my case, I plan on keeping the baby desert rose under lights and disallowing dormancy (they probably wouldn't anyway as they're all less than 3 months old), and the hibiscus are tropical and won't go dormant anyway. With sufficient light from lamps, I can keep those growing fast all winter long.

    Rebecca/N. IN/z6A thanked User
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    To be blunt, I can't fix anti-science. Just the basics:

    "The ingestion of neem oil is potentially toxic and can cause metabolic acidosis, seizures, kidney failure, encephalopathy and severe brain ischemia in infants and young children .[4][5] Neem oil should not be consumed alone without any other solutions, particularly by pregnant women, women trying to conceive, or children.[6] It can also be associated with allergic contact dermatitis."

    If you're ingesting this, that's just foolish and I can't help you, and you need to stop recommending this before you hurt somebody.

    I reported your comment, although I have little hope they'll remove it as potentially damaging to others' health. Houzz just isn't that careful of others.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Oh, for the love of God, do your research. They're still listed as unsafe during pregnancy. And aah, yes, reported for risking others. Good day to you.


    ETA: Oh, here's a fun one. Actually, quite a lot of sites talk about using the seed and other parts--including the bark--to make medicines and tea and additives and whatnot. Sources online show contamination from seed and bark, which are...toxic. So my comment actually does stand. Here's just one warning example: https://www.rxlist.com/neem/supplements.htm


    Again, science and testing. They're what's good for you. Avoiding toxins really are a great idea and I'd suggest avoiding neem products entirely for your health.


    When pregnant, young, low weight, or just concerned, wear gloves and wash your hands when using neem oil as a pesticide.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Yeah, I figured the likes of you would chime in. Typical, GC. If facts mean nothing to folks, that's fine, but I wouldn't recommend ignoring safety issues.

    Please take precautions if pregnant and don't be convinced just because somebody whines loudly and points fingers and screams. There's no reason to lose your baby or poison a young child.

    Keep your neem oil away from children and definitely take precautions, and think twice before ingesting this stuff -- and do your own research. These things are just common sense. There should be no argument about this, regardless of the "pontification" above or the name-calling engaged in consistently by the allegedly "adult" posters above.

    I rest my case and wish you all a great afternoon and evening.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    It's unwise to listen to anybody who doesn't understand what probability, early pregnancy, or ingest mean. Or who, for that matter, belittles what has occurred to real women to prove her own personal point in the most insensitive and tasteless possible manner.

    The probability is much lower--near zero--when spraying, but it's wise to protect yourself in use if trying to become pregnant. The little nugget, during the first few days, isn't so well-attached yet. Capice? Good. And wash your hands, as you would with any other insecticide.

    And don't drink the tea if you're trying to get pregnant due to that contamination problem. For obvious reasons, as I said above.

    I should, of course, also note, once again, the adults in the room would tend not to play those kinds of word games. But I really shouldn't have to. (finger wag and head shake). Try presenting some science the next time rather than playing games with people. Sigh.

  • 6 years ago

    My thanks to the Houzz moderators for cleaning this thread properly; I'm not sure how to send a message directly so I'll simply report my own message as I appreciate the care for the health of others and apologize for stating above that you may be less than careful with your concern.

  • 5 years ago

    I am puzzled by comments that neem oil doesn't kill pollinators, but what about pollinators that appear in my garden in the larvae stage. For example the monarchs in my yard are eating the milkweed I have planted in my garden especially for the monarchs. Or the swallowtail butterflies who larvae eat the dill I especially plant for them. These animals are eating leaves just like other animals neem is used to kill.

  • 5 years ago

    good question, dont know the answer. Sorry- havent been on here in awhile.

  • 5 years ago

    "but what about pollinators that appear in my garden in the larvae stage." You do realize the option of not using neem oil in your garden is wide open, yes?

    Al

  • 5 years ago

    As to HU....’s question: the simple answer is don’t spray the milkweed or dill. duh.

    Spray drift will not be enough to hurt them as long as you are careful.

    Neem oil works primarily in two ways; as a smothering oil if the insects are hit directly, and as an anti-feedant. It is much less of a deterant to flying pollenators.


  • 5 years ago

    I gave the examples of dill and milkweed, but the point is that many insect larvae will eat plants that have been sprayed with Neem with the confidence that it will not be toxic to adult stage insects (pollinators), but indeed, it is toxic to those many insect species we realize are seriously diminishing in numbers. I don't know the answer, but it seems biology has to be taken more seriously and thoughtfully when we attempt to mess with nature.