It is beautiful as is! I would focus on the perimeter countertop when the time comes.

Looks so pretty. I think you are experiencing a normal reaction to a new item. Get use to it and you too will see it as a beautiful choice and will most likely cease to second guess it.

Relax, it’s perfect.

I'd take the $3K and use it to upgrade all of your countertops.

You'll void the warranty with a refinish. It looks fine.

Everything will dull down over time. Don't sweat it.

@BeverlyFLADeziner Thanks! I considered that too! when it was installed my initial reaction was wow, that's REALLY shiny!! Sigh...I am clueless when it comes to this stuff, plus get overwhelmed with so many choices.

So easy to become overwhelmed. Use that energy to remove clutter from countertops and above the cabinets. Looks like a great spacious kitchen. Enjoy it.

Looks great! I deter my clients from matte unless they do leathered...which isn't available in Cambria anyway. Keep as is!!!

I love it! Don’t obsess about it. It’s not like people will look and say hmmmm she really should have gotten the matte.

Love it! So nice. Leave it!

The polished is easier to keep clean. I spot tested both finishes. When I visited the Cambria showroom, the fabricator told me the polished finish has other advantages too (sorry - can’t remember now - perhaps others will weigh in). I ended up using a different material — but IMHO, I think your polished top looks lovely.

It’s beautiful and perfect.