Software
Houzz Logo Print
oldvictorian1915

Are wood countertops dated?

6 years ago

Considering using wood countertops on our island. Kitchen cabinets are all off-white, we're thinking counters surrounding will be marble. Thoughts? Most of the inspiration photos I've found are from many years ago. I would love opinions!

Susan G. Komen Showhouse · More Info


2009 Showcase Home on Park Alley · More Info


Residence in California · More Info


Comments (15)

  • 6 years ago

    In our remodel three years ago we put cherry on the island and we love it. The perimeter counters are stainless steel which we also love.

  • 6 years ago

    And I forgot to say our cabinets are white. We are in Coastal California.

  • 6 years ago

    Several thoughts:

    1. They're not dated

    2. You don't have to stick with dark brown, so consider how another wood or finish might look than what you show in your photos, e.g., oiled maple.

    3. Recognize that wood counters will need a little more care as they can get scratches, finish deterioration if water sits on top, and further damage if you put a hot pan on them, or cut on them.

  • 6 years ago

    I wouldn't say dated they are classic. I put walnut stained butcher block on my island and love it.

  • 6 years ago

    I would avoid them purely from a food safety standpoint.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I would avoid them purely from a food safety standpoint.

    May I ask why? Aside from rolling out pastry or cookies, food never touches my counters. If I had wooden ones, I would buy a big marble pastry board.

    PS Do people really put food on their kitchen counters without a chopping block? Even if your counters are wooden and you don't worry about harming your knives, you will mar the surface of the counters very quickly by cutting directly on them.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Hanson- Good points. But I will also note that some wood species, like rock maple, hickory, or Brazilian cherry are incredibly hard. I have had maple on my island for almost 15 years, and the only damage I’ve had was the one time my significant other decided to pulverize rock salt crystals with a metal meat tenderizer hammer directly on the counter!

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I love wood counters. In my dream kitchen I would have part of the counter a butcher block so I CAN cut directly on it. I'm short so even a few inches of cutting board on top of counters can make my shoulders sore after a while.

  • 6 years ago

    Thanks so much everyone! We're going to go with wood on the island. And Hanson, thanks so much for the photos of the beautiful project you completed. It's a very similar look to what we are going for, so we are reassured that it will look great. I'll be sure to post a picture when we're done!


    Zalco - The reason we want to go with wood countertops is we like the warmth of them . We wouldn't be cutting directly on them. The house we are renovating is from 1915 and has high ceilings, and I was a little concerned our kitchen would end up feeling too cold for our tastes/for the house. Great idea about the marble pastry board!

  • 6 years ago

    Hey everyone! We talked to our contracter and he advised against doing the wood countertops because we have a sink in the island. I have seen inspiration photos that have done this. My question: Is it a crazy thing to do? We really love the wood look and have no alternative location for the sink.

  • 6 years ago

    And an undermount sink I assume?

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    Not dated at all, but they do require maintenance. If you go with a furniture finish it will be like polishing a dining room table. But if you go with butcher block, you'll have to oil it every so often to keep it from drying out.

    AL AL thanked Sabrina Alfin Interiors
  • 6 years ago

    You could keep it looking good if you wiped up every little drop of water and every bit of moisture every time the sink was used. The problem is that most people are not up to that continually and over time you may find some staining. If you have an undermount sink, the top perimeter is exposed wood, much of it being end grain, which sucks up water more; and if you have an overmount sink the tendency is for moisture to wick under the edge of the rim where it sits and causes damage.

    You can avoid a lot of this by having a durable, polyurethane finish applied, but water will still cause deterioration over time. If you want to go with wood anyway, you might want to reconcile yourself to refinishing the wood every few years. I will point out that: a) some woods are more moisture resistant than others, and b) in general, darker woods show staining less than lighter ones.

    I've never seen a kitchen with a wooden counter that has a sink in it that remains pristine over time. I'm not saying it's impossible, but it requires constant vigilance. I know myself, and I just don't want to cope with more maintenance than needed so I would personally avoid a wooden countertop with a sink in it. But you may be a more determined person than I am and it will be just fine.



    AL AL thanked kudzu9
  • 6 years ago

    My DD used cherry butcher block as all her kitchen counters when she moved into her 18th century house.

    They look great. Sink is over mount. Not that much upkeep- occasional wiping with butcher block treatment but that’s all. She does use a countertop cutting board but her counters do not get constant vigilance. Has three kids 5 and under.

    Must admit I tried to talk her out of them.

    AL AL thanked HU-821800902