Software
Houzz Logo Print
mqcola

Efficient ( lumber cost) Ceiling Height - 11 ft or 12 ft

5 years ago

Hi,
We are designing our retirement home and the designer specified a 11ft ceiling for the foyer. The remaing of the house is 9ft.
As we are very budget conscious, I asked the framer what he thinks. He said with a 11ft ceiling we would be loosing 1 ft of each lumber. Doing some research ( web) it seens that the size of a 2x10' lumber is 9'1/4" and for a 2x12' is 11'1/4". I would like to learn and clarify if we ask for a 11ft high ceiling we will be wasting lumber or not.
Thanks for sharing your experience and knowledge with us.

Comments (19)

  • 5 years ago

    Imo wasting lumber in this context is a non issue. I would be more concerned about how the overall architecture would change by adding or subtracting a foot to/from the foyer just because.

    mqcola thanked JJ
  • PRO
    5 years ago

    If you want to save money, why are you planning a house with 9' ceilings? Why not 8'?


    it seens that the size of a 2x10' lumber is 9'1/4" and for a 2x12' is 11'1/4".


    You should do some more research -- a lot more research.

    mqcola thanked PPF.
  • PRO
    5 years ago

    In process with the same question.


    It can be easy to incorporate 11-14' walls through the middle of a single level home that starts with 9-10' around the edge.


    Two story homes are different. The first floor has to carry the floor with stresses in multiple directions.


    One can use high end production builders to gauge lumber efficiency. Mostly you will see 9' and 10' walls used, even towards $2 million, sometimes with a two story living or entry. Some high end luxury projects in the 2-4mil range by production builders use 12' lower level walls.


    Standard studs are designed to work with 3 2x plates, one on the bottom, two on the top to achieve 8'1",9'1", 10'1" & 12'1". Any other sizes are from larger pieces and not typically cut at the mill and delivered by the unit.


    Taller walls mean more engineering loads and values, achieved by more concrete, steel and thicker plywood, whit more blocks. The walls are heavier and take more time to raise. Takes more materials inside and out, more time to wire & the ceilings, more steps in the stairways taking up more space, etc. Did you want more glass? Add the cost of the glass plus the cost of energy offsets.


    Over time standards and amenities change. I'm seeing a few 12' lower levels be specified. It will cost more.

    mqcola thanked Jeffrey R. Grenz, General Contractor
  • 5 years ago

    You will be wasting 1ft of lumber. The 11.25 lumber is sandwiched between a board on the bottom and 2 on the top as Jeffrey stated...giving the overall wall 12'1 inches in height. After your flooring and drywall ceiling, you will be back about 12 foot for the actual wall height once everything is done. That being said, 11 ft may still be better for your overall plan than 12ft.

    mqcola thanked B Carey
  • PRO
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    2x10 is the nominal dimensions of a piece of dimensional lumber that is actually (in theory) 1 1/2" x 9 1/4"

    2x12 is the nominal dimensions of a piece of dimensional lumber that is actually (in theory) 1 1/2" x 11 1/4".

    Dimensional lumber normally come in lengths in two foot increments. Lengths availability vary geographically.

    I do not understand what the cross sectional dimensions have to do with the ceiling height?

    mqcola thanked Mark Bischak, Architect
  • 5 years ago

    I would do all 9 ft ceilings. Thats a very nice height, and cuts down on your heating and cooling a bit, and sure is a whole lot easier to paint both ceiling and walls.

    mqcola thanked cat_ky
  • 5 years ago

    @Mark Bischak, Architect,

    Yes I messed up when I sent the original topic, I thougth the dimensions were the height and not the cross sections.


  • 5 years ago

    Doing some research ( web) it seens that the size of a 2x10' lumber is 9'1/4" and for a 2x12' is 11'1/4".

    You need to do your research on the job site and the lumber store and maybe back to 4th grade? but hopefully not.

    You are confusing nominal lumber sizes with actual lumber sizes and confusing actual lumber width (inches) with lumber length. (feet)

    A ten foot 2 x 10 is always going to be 10' long. Usually 10'+. A twelve foot 2 x 12 is always going to be 12' long.

    In reality a 10' 2 x 10 is going to be 1 5/8-1 3/4 inches thick x 9 1/4" inches wide x 10' (or 10' plus long).

    A 2 x 12 is going to be 11 1/4" wide....


    I have no idea why anyone would want 9-12' ceilings in a retirement home. Costs more to build, costs more to heat and cool and costs more to maintain. The burned out light bulbs are farther up the ladder & the cobwebs are harder to reach. Costs more to paint when you want to change up the color & likely puts it out of DIY'er ability. Because you need to scale up windows & doors then it costs more to buy & replace larger window coverings. Those taller windows are harder to reach the top of from both the floor and the ground when they need to be washed. And the roof is farther off the ground when you need to make an emergency patch to stop a leak. Something YOU may have to do if there is a widespread weather event and every contractor & handy man has so many jobs lined up that he isn't answering his telephone.



    mqcola thanked ci_lantro
  • 5 years ago

    Thanks all for the good commenta. The house is a single level and all rooms except the foyer are 9 ft. The Foyer is 11ft at this point. I will check how much of a difference on the exterior design if we decide to go with a 10 ft ceiling ( foyer only). It seens based on the comments 10 ft would be the most cost effective.

    As JJ said I will review with the designer the impact of reducing the height to 10 ft.


  • PRO
    5 years ago

    If you want you could post the floor plan and elevations and get comments, but . . .

    WARNING: Posting your entire floor plan opens you up to facts you may not want to know, but should. Be prepared for suggestions that will make for a better design. Keep a thick skin, open mind, sense of humor, and a glass of wine within arms reach. You may not enjoy it, but everyone else will and you will be better off in the long run if you heed well the advice.

    mqcola thanked Mark Bischak, Architect
  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Why does the foyer want to be taller than the rest of the home? As far as costs: 11' and 12' ceilings will each require 12' studs. 10' studs save you a little bit, but we're talking a small area. Do what feels right for the home and make sure the entry door (and transom) fit the height of the space.

    mqcola thanked Summit Studio Architects
  • 5 years ago

    Hi,

    For sure when posting we need to understand we all have diferent ideas and I do consider all sugestions.. I even changed the original draftman to a architect tech following some suggestion. LOL. I still don't have the floor plans yet.

    @hazel summit, The foyer being taller was me asking for it after seeing (maybe too many LOL) photos in Houzz, was hoping to have the exterior looking "grand" Now I am thinking on the transition of a 11ft to 9 ft etc. But this is food for another post when I receive the "almost" final floor plan. Thanks all

  • 5 years ago

    I think everyone should build and focus on energy efficiency.

    That being said, aren't utility costs a very minor issue in 2021?

    My current house costs me about $500 in energy costs per year (not even that much) and my taxes are $13k per year. My insurance is $2k per year.

    Even an average new house probably should be more concerned with taxes than anything else.

    My planned retirement house is older and probably has $2k in utility costs per year but taxes are just $3k. (We rent this house out)

    As another point, my low utility bill house has 10 ft ceilings (and up to 14 in great room) while my planned retirement house has 8 ft ceilings.


    I suppose a 10 ft or 11 ft foyer would have an 8 foot door. That is the real cost so worrying about 1 foot of lumber (x20) does seem silly.

    Cleaning that extra foot is a non issue. Lightbulbs are LED and once you get past a few bad apples, the average retiree won't ever change a bulb. I also wouldn't expect paint for the average retiree.

    Now - cobwebs - hadn't considered that. An aging shoulder might not prefer those.


    mqcola thanked David Cary
  • 5 years ago

    The cost of scrap lumber for the foyer studs is of no importance; it can be used for blocking in the wall. You should be focusing your attention on design.

    IMO making the foyer if a one story house 2 or 3 ft taller than the rest of the house can come dangerously close to "feigned elegance" especially if its part of a tall entrance feature attached to a giant hipped roof full of trusses.

    I hope I'm wrong.

    mqcola thanked res2architect
  • 5 years ago

    Lightbulbs are LED and once you get past a few bad apples, the average retiree won't ever change a bulb.

    In theory. At least 3 years on, I'm still working my way thru bad apples. To include some Cree bulbs that didn't last any longer than cheap LED's. YMMV. I'm talking about 'bulbs' that screw in. So far, all of the integrated recessed flat panel LED's have held up.

    But those bulbs in the chandelier in the foyer with 11' ceilings? Don't count on never having to change them. Maybe if you buy a tall ladder they will behave since they know you can come & get 'em if they act up. :-)

  • PRO
    5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    "A retirement home for most of the citizens of the US should be small, cozy, and economical."

    There is absolutely nothing wrong with a home which has spatial variety. In fact, there's a lot that's right about spatial variety, especially for someone (or a family) that will be spending a lot of time inside the house.

    I agree, however, that simply making the entry with a higher ceiling is rather odd and doesn't add much spatial variety that's worthwhile. Without seeing the plan and exterior, if it was my house, I'd simply make all the ceilings ten-feet high, including entry.

    mqcola thanked Virgil Carter Fine Art
  • 5 years ago

    Well, maybe cozy 8 foot ceilings are fine for most retirees, but DH and I are building our "retirement home" and it has 9' ceilings. However, DH is 6'5" and 8 foot ceilings have always made him feel claustrophobic. No tall foyer though, just a simple L shaped ranch with the normal height front door opening into a foyer/seldom used dining room. I don't know how much more money this is going to cost us rather than having 8' ceilings, but we're saving our money by doing the construction ourselves. (I know that isn't possible for everyone).I Good luck.

    mqcola thanked Buzz Solo in northeast MI
  • 5 years ago

    In my experience, Crees aren't great - despite the name.

    I too changed out a Cree just yesterday. It was probably 8 years old in a bathroom vanity at the beach - so a bit harsh. We have changed the fixture already from rust.

    In our 2 year old house, we are batting 100% (about 150 bulbs/fixtures) and that includes chandelier's with candelabras.

    I think asking the original LEDs (ie 8-10 year old Crees) to be perfect is a bit optimistic. Just like asking dollar store LEDs to be 100% is similarly optimistic.


    mqcola thanked David Cary