Software
Houzz Logo Print
jess_barrett55

how would cedar shakes look?

5 years ago

So I'm contemplating replacing the siding on our gable end with vinyl cedar shakes to add a different look and add some maintenance free siding. then also remove the metal column piece with a wood column cladded out. does this sound like a dumb idea? should I do both, one, or none of my ideas?

Comments (14)

  • 5 years ago

    I would keep just what you have. The shakes will just add another pattern like the brick, and the house will look too busy. What you have looks very nice, although, I am not fond of the color.

  • 5 years ago

    I, too, like what is there. I think you should focus on installing a soft grouping of plants for the foundation and the planter. I don't think your house needs anything else.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    IMO the shades are too busy when placed against your brick pattern. I would either keep what you have or spend the money to do Board & Batten




  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Shakes are too busy. You need to decide what you really want the house to be. It started as a mid century ranch form with characteristic ironwork and narrow Roman brick. At some point the front door became craftsman and you have a vinyl window. A comprehensive end goal to guide decisions could help tie it all together.

  • 5 years ago

    Thanks everyone, I agree with what you're saying and really appreciate the feedback. I really like the Board and Batten but I'm not sure if that's enough of a change for me to justify the $. This may be a dumb question could they do the Board and Batten in a vinyl or faux wood to make it maintenance free?


    Would it look dumb to keep the same look but have it swapped with a maintenance free product?


    So I'm feeling dumb that I've installed a Craftsman door with a mid century ranch home, but I thought it looked nice and we wanted to let some light in but needed to keep the window high since we live on a very busy road.


    So what other recommendations do folks have to replace the current ironwork as it has several layers of paint on it that are cracked and just isn't in that good of shape anymore.


    Thanks everyone!

  • 5 years ago

    I do like the shutter idea, would you add them to our big picture window as well?


  • 5 years ago

    i just realized that the gutter would be in the way of the shutter for the big window :-(



  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Why does the front gable treatment need to be changed? Is it rotting? I would paint all the trim white to go with your white vinyl windows, including the ironwork. The ironwork you have takes a day to scrape and prep for a homeowner and you have years of life out of it at that point. Plant some shade loving ferns in the planter and call it done. If the gable treatment is failing I would re do it in cement (hardi board) not vinyl- it will cost a tiny fraction more but look much more intentional. Yes you can do board and batten in cement, it’s done all the time.

  • 5 years ago

    I've brought the gable idea up being there are some areas where the paint is peeling and maybe some very minor rot/soft spots so I just didn't if it was time to change things up. At this point I'm just going to leave it then. if it was replaced with cement board it would still have to be painted right? Just curious, what would be the benefits of cement board?


    I'd consider painting all the trim white but I really don't want to spend that kind of time nor do I have that kind of time to repaint the whole house. Plus I already have a hard time keeping our off-white stucco clean from the road dust, etc. Plus all our windows have been wrapped in brown recently, that being said would it make more sense to paint the metal windows brown to match the wrap?

  • 5 years ago

    I wouldn't put shutters on a picture window. The rule of thumb is that they need to look functional, even if they are not.

    Don't let rot happen just because you need to paint. The current color works, so I would just repaint.

    Focus on landscaping. You have a cozy, attractive home.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Cement board does need to be painted but then the paint job lasts virtually forever...

  • 5 years ago

    Thanks everyone, and thanks houssaon for the compliment on my house, that makes me feel so much better!


    I'm meeting with a contractor tonight to see what ideas he has for sprucing up the look (other than plants which we'll focus on) .


    Otherwise we'll plan on focusing on adding some shutters and maybe swapping out the ironwork with an updated piece of ironwork.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I would keep the iron railings. Get a wire brush, and clean them good, and get all the looks paint off them. Leave the boards at top, but, clean them good, and prime them good, and repaint them. Thats not a lot of maintenance up there. Vinyl is not necessarily maintenance free either. It gathers dirt like a magnet, and you will be power washing it often. Leave the windows white, just make sure they are all painted the same. The brown around the edges adds a bit of interest. I would really like some railings on the steps, even though they are not high. Someone could step off wrong there, on both sides, and end up injured. Buy some bright colored pots, and put some colorful flowers in them. That alone would add a lot, as would much nicer brighter landscaping. Its a cute house. Since you said the door is new, I am guessing so is the paint on the door. Sorry, but, that paint color does not go with your brick, or your house. Try a shade of darker turquoise, teal, or even a nice rusty red.

  • 5 years ago

    so repaint the iron railing brown then? bummer you don't like my door color as I thought it paired good with the orange in the brick. I do have to say that the one pic makes it look way brighter than it is cause the sun is shining on it, the 2nd pic of the picture window is a more accurate representation of the color as its more of a burnt orange. Also a bummer to hear on the landscaping as we replaced all the river rock, edging and plants last year :-( I do wish we would have added something that has color year round but we don't have a very deep area to work with and the yard slopes towards the house so we can't really move the edging out much further because of that and the sidewalk. so plants that much volume didn't seem to be a great option.

    thanks for the ideas