I don’t have the Caesarstone counters memorized. Can you post pics of Atlantic Salt and Nougat?

I think your current counter is gorgeous. Why change to Caesarstone?

the Nought looks less limiting , on my screen. Why not take a cabinet door and go compare it to the slabs you are interested in, in person, outside if possible?

@Shannon_WI -- Thanks for the push! It wasn't working to add them on the poll, and I forgot that I could just add them in the post! :) Photos added.

@Mrs. S -- they don't look so gorgeous everywhere! Believe me, it's time.

The "Nougat" reminds me of the floors in my public school bathrooms (45 years ago).

If uncertain about both, I’d keep looking until you are absolutely positive. Be sure to also look at backsplashes, so you get a better sense of a combination you are drawn to; both are important at this point.

Without seeing counter/backsplash samples together, as well as your flooring, not sure how helpful advice is at this time, based on the two samples.

Just based on your wall color, Atlantic Salt is not complementary. Do you want the glitter effect with Nougat? Consider all components, as the cabinets are pretty easy to work with.

Consider a warm, simple counter

Complementary backsplash with present counter or the above examples.

Get a small brush to get into the corners of your shaker cabinets. It needs to be soft so that it does not mar the paint job. An old toothbrush or a small paintbrush may work.