2!! I voted for 2 it is very fresh and will look amazing in your beautiful kitchen

@Jennifer Havin Thank you! I think that is it. I keep second guessing myself. We were supposed to be done about two months ago, but due to delays, I have had more time to search for stuff and so, I keep finding other options. Having more time, in my case, is a double edge sword, so may pretty fixtures out there.

With your island are you factoring the size and placement. . your island is large . is the scale correct? These look small... other sizes avail???

@herbflavor Honestly our design/build company sucks! The electrical rough is already done so adding a third light would be a major change because it would mean patching two holes. Their designer recommended the first light and she said size between 12-16 inches would be fine. I have learned so much from this renovation- never again will I use a design built company- their designer is focus on keeping things in line not in helping us achieve our goal. - everything from layout to paint colors had been an uphill battle. Can’t wait for it to be done. Sorry for the rant. Thank you for pointing out the size consideration.

Id go more for the 16 in and perhaps a style w light directed down will help. shapes that widen out to spread the light onto that top as well. not that difficult but choose carefully.

I think your choice of number two is perfect. That pendant absolutely belongs in your kitchen! Beautiful!