Software
Houzz Logo Print
jennie_sullins

Need help mid century modernizing our kitchen

13 years ago
We bought a cozy and bright mid century home last year that had been touched by some flippers. We have been in the process of trying to restore it back to it's glory days and create an updated version of it's mid century roots.
The problem is everything was recently remodeled. So knowing we paid for all of it in the purchase price we are trying to work with as much as we can. The kitchen has been the project I am most excited to tackle but also the hardest since I would prefer to rip it out and start over but it's not in the budget.

What I like is the open space, lots of light, layout, and the wide island.

What I don't like is the tone of the cabinets and tile and how with the light bamboo floors throughout the house is an over abundance of warm tones. Plus it was a bad DIY job and they didn't move the stove before tiling the floor so the old, old tile peeks through.

So I'm in need of some advice...what would you change to add some mid century touches without replacing cabinets and countertops? The dark and speckled granite is my biggest challenge.

Some ideas we have thrown around…

Adding a glass tile backsplash in a mint or blue tone.
Taking down the upper cabinets on the stove side and replacing with a range hood and 2 long open shelves.
Refacing the cabinet doors with sleeker ones. (Not sure if this can be done to what we have?)
Adding a dishwasher (can you believe they did a full remodel and didn't put in a dishwasher with all the available room!?)
Replacing travertine floor with a cooler tone flooring.
Replacing overhead microwave with range hood.

Is it a bad move to take out cabinets and replace with open shelves?

Any suggestions are much appreciated!

Comments (18)

  • 13 years ago
    Stove side of kitchen where there is talk of taking down upper cabinets and replacing with open shelves and a range hood.
  • 13 years ago
    Jennie, interesting dilemma. Nothing looks mid-century at all, like you said. Maybe the cabinets could go darker and replace hardware. Open shelving is nice as it seems like you have plenty of cabinet space elsewhere. I personally would not want open shelving because of the dust factor. I live in the Phoenix area and the dust is ever present-especially in the summer! Your granite would never be mid-century but maybe would work with darker cabinets. I would suggest looking at plenty of mid-century photos in the meantime. And I'm sure others will come to your aid. Good luck!
    Jennie Sullins thanked unwantedadvice
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Hmm, perhaps painting the cabinets some kind of taupe would work, then maybe open shelves (Lack from IKEA) in black brown above at the Fridge Wall. (I wouldn't change the upper cabinets out at the range).

    [houzz=
    Rustic Taupe 999 · More Info
    ]

    [houzz=
    LACK Wall shelf · More Info
    ]

    And if it is inthe budget, a full backsplash (the entire wall above cabs at the Fridge) and around the window, in some kind of glass/ stone strip variety:

    [houzz=
    Brown Beige Tones Wall Tile · More Info
    ]

    Also change all handles to the stainless pulls..

    [houzz=
    Atlas Homewares Polished Stainless Steel Pull · More Info
    ]
    Jennie Sullins thanked Aggie dba Aggie Designs
  • 13 years ago
    It's going to be difficult to evoke MCM style with those marble or faux-marble countertops. Open shelves or flat front cabinet doors is one step. You might be able to just swap out the cabinet doors and you can certainly swap out the cabinet hardware.
    Jennie Sullins thanked User
  • 13 years ago
    Thank you for the suggestions. It's true the speckled granite is the biggest problem. It's such an eye sore with the rest of the house being mid century. I havn't even priced out what it would be to replace it. Any ideas how much it would cost and what material you would recommend?
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Some pretty silly flippers!

    Almost good idea: The mint or green glass backsplash is a nice idea, but it won't work with your countertop. Try a glass backsplash in beige. Love beige for MCM.

    Good idea: Taking down the upper cabinets on the stove side and replacing with a range hood and 2 long open shelves.

    Very good idea, but probably not cost-effective: Refacing the cabinet doors with sleeker ones.

    Excellent idea: Adding a dishwasher

    Not worth it until you replace cabs: Replacing travertine floor with a cooler tone flooring
    .
    OK to do: Replacing overhead microwave with range hood.

    One more thing: Paint these unattractive cabinets either beige or camel.
    Jennie Sullins thanked sstarr93
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    I would budget around $50 a sq ft for granite as a general rule. Lower to mid range granite or manufactured stone.
    Jennie Sullins thanked Boerne Kitchens and Baths
  • 13 years ago
    I would leave the kitchen and get the rest of the house out of MCM- what is it that so many are going MCM, it was a terrible design era;) coming from a baby boomer.
    Jennie Sullins thanked User
  • 13 years ago
    Haha Margo C. it's crazy but we love MCM! I love how mid century design can make a small house feel clean and open. But I get what you mean it feels crazy trying to change a brand new kitchen. It's just soooooo not my style and I'm trying to weigh the decision to "just deal" with it or make some changes. We have granite now and I have checked into other material and it's all around $3000 to redo, plus I would be removing granite and replacing with a white ceaserstone or some other material not granite. I'm afraid in our area for resale it would be a big mistake. People love speckly granite :p
  • 13 years ago
    A girl can dream...
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    Well, I always think people should try and fulfill their dreams, we come this way but once...if you are in this home for the long haul, bite the bullet and have the MCM kitchen of your dreams,which by the way looks pretty great ;) def. not the MCM kitchen I grew up in.(burnt orange, avocado, vinyl, and chrome)
    Jennie Sullins thanked User
  • 13 years ago
    I also grew up in the era-sixties, that is. I applaud you for trying to salvage things. The way people seem to be dismantling them, in a few years the remaining ones are going to be worth a mint because it's going to start becoming a rare to find one in tact.
    I think that you could "faux" your way through some things. For example, you could just put down a vinyl floor over the tile that looks like it did "back in the day." Armstrong still has examples of its linoleum. However, I would just do sheet vinyl to take in account the tile floor, just in case somebody in the future happened to like it and then they could figure out what to do about the flipper's "goof." Vinyl shouldn't have to be glued or attached except at the edges, so that should help conserve the tile. Concerning the cabinets, you could stain them a dark stain-although in the fifties and early sixties the cabinets were not dark but usually were this "blond" color-the builders back then even bleached the wood to get it that way. It was in the late sixties/seventies that the dark cabinets came in-just go watch an old rerun of the original Brady bunch. However, I think that you could stain the cabinets whatever shade you choose, and you could replace the middle piece with either frosted glass or some kind of plastic that looks frosted-like the ones shown in your "dream" kitchen. The tough part is the granite. Perhaps if everything else you could do was cost effective, you could find someone to carefully remove it and sell it to someone who would be happy to be able to buy the slabs. I've read that Formica now has some of its old patterns. If you choose a new surface, it would be more in keeping with the old stuff to either be a dark surface, or a light one with flecks-preferably gold ones, if that's possible.
    Here is a link you might find useful. This site is dedicated to helping folks who are trying to preserve or restore mid century stuff.
    http://retrorenovation.com/2013/01/07/1958-sears-kitchen-cabinets-and-more-32-page-catalog/
    Good luck getting your kitchen back to its "roots."
    Jennie Sullins thanked lucindalane
  • 12 years ago
    The granite and floor and cabinet colors clash. I would seriously consider ripping out that poorly done tile floor--who eve heard of not going under the stove LOL. I don't mind it alone, but not with the granite.

    I don't know if you can ever get that granite to work except maybe going charcoal grey or a dark stain on the cabinets and chucking the floor. But if you hate the granite, why bother? You will end up hating the whole thing. Perhaps you could resell the granite to offset the cost of replacement.

    Or you can bit the bullet and replace the granite with quartz (maybe grey). The cabinet color is actually quite popular for the era, but would look better with a clean color, like lime green, and could be painted, not tiled, which is actually more period anyway. Then you could save up for a new floor.

    Or you could paint the cabinets white or off white, and go with the stainless steel edged formica countertops, or period type formed on site with plywood and faced with formica counters. IKEA had some flat formica counters that could work, and aren't expensive. Just avoid the molded kind with the curved back and front edge.

    Mid century modern came in lots of flavors. Retro Renovation has a lot of resources, and tends toward the funky side of retro. Sounds like you are going for the more Atomic Ranch, sleek and contemporary side of midcentury modern. Personally I think the shaker style cabinets and nickel pulls are classic enough to work either painted or unpainted, and the appliances are decent, if you change the counters and floors, which is a good thing since cabinets cost way more than flooring and countertops, especially if you go for period appropriate formica and linoleum.

    It would help to see the rest of the house.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I think what is disconcerting is that you have warmer colors in the floor and the counters and the wood is much lighter and doesn't really create a cohesive look. Look into a warmer stain on the cabinets that ties them in with the floor better. Also, add a backsplash (I like the one Aggie showed). Also, changing the hardware out would help.
  • 11 years ago

    If you really like mid century, forget 21st century blah grays and beiges Be brave and colorful! Browse RetroRenovation for a good look at what mid century kitchens looked like and help with recreating that vibe in your own remuddled kitchen.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Color! If you need to keep the counter tops, look for grey, black and white options in flooring. The cabinets are a Mid Century stain color. You could have fun and paint them red or green or you could do a very simple glass panel back splash. Change the cabinet hardware to Mid Century style. Add some funky light fixtures and decorate with Mid Century knick knacks.

    Arch 14-3/4" Cabinet Handle Bar Pull Stainless Steel Finish · More Info

    What colors are you working wt in the rest of the areas that are seen from the kitchen?

    These geometric white tiles are fun. They have a Mid-Century texture without clashing with the existing granite.

    Rosenwald House · More Info

    Any solid floor can work. You need to kill the fake Tuscan tile floor.

  • 10 years ago

    I'd go for it, reasonably. Kill the floor in favor of Marmoleum. Paint the cabinets in a period appropriate color. Bet you could reuse that granite in an outdoor project, too.